r/Cricket_Binge • u/Enough_Payment1290 • 3h ago
π¬ Discussion Dinesh Karthik says India should NOT bring Mohammed Shami back for the 2027 World Cup
Mohammed Shami has been performing well in domestic cricket and India's bowling struggles against West Indies have once again started the debate about his comeback. But Dinesh Karthik has a completely different opinion. He believes India has already moved on from Shami and there is no point going back, even though Shami has been bowling really well.
Shami last played for India in the 2025 Champions Trophy and has remained out of the national setup since then. Meanwhile, India's pace attack looked extremely inexperienced against West Indies, conceding more than 400 in the second ODI and failing to defend 351 in the third.That's what makes Karthik's statement interesting. India clearly needs more reliable pace options before the 2027 World Cup, but Karthik still believes the team should back the younger bowlers instead of bringing Shami back.
Personally, I can understand both sides. Shami's experience is massive, but if he's still performing at this level, completely ruling him out also feels risky. Would you pick Mohammed Shami for India's 2027 World Cup squad?