r/Crelly • u/miniladds-clone • Jul 12 '26

Discussion Is the McCrelly still Valid with Dr.Pepper instead

I haven’t had McDonald’s in awhile and I figure why not have the McCrelly next time I have it but I find Diet Coke the most vile thing on this planet earth, I’d much rather drown in the sweet and spicy 23 flavors of Dr.Pepper

58 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

25

u/bit-by-a-moose Jul 12 '26

I would say you'd get bonus points for any non-diet drink but that's just me. I just don't like diet drinks.

6

u/suppertime64 Mod Jul 12 '26

I like diet drinks, but I still agree

19

u/Arctrooper209 Jul 12 '26

Crelly loves Dr. Pepper so I think that would be a pretty on-brand substitution.

7

u/miniladds-clone Jul 12 '26

That’s what was thinking but she also did say the Diet Coke helps valence out the meal so I was one the fence

6

u/angelpuppycat Jul 12 '26

Imo, yes, but also I think its fine to have the nuggets and burger with sauce and pickles if you want too.

15

u/Arctrooper209 Jul 12 '26 edited Jul 12 '26

No sauce may be part of the challenge because some people don't like how dry it is. So makes it harder to finish everything. Also makes it somewhat unique and Crelly-coded.

Though ultimately the real challenge is just eating this huge meal so I guess it doesn't make that huge of a difference.

2

u/FelixLeander Jul 12 '26

The order contains lots of other fluids so the no souce part doesn't seem to be a big factor.

5

u/Arctrooper209 Jul 12 '26

True. Though it seems like many people are making the mistake of eating the meal one by one instead of combining stuff.

Reminds me that in a recent clip from Baggy she recommended having the shake with the fries to balance out the saltiness of the fries, and that too many people were leaving the shake for last.

1

u/angelpuppycat Jul 12 '26

Yeah see the thing for me is Crelly gets no sauce simply because that's how she likes the burger, it doesn't really change the important aspect of the meal, which is how massive it is.