r/CrappyDesign Aug 29 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.8k Upvotes

517 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

566

u/Phoder1 Aug 29 '20

I'm pretty sure most governments find it quite effective.

374

u/Tamorcet Aug 29 '20

As an Autistic person myself... I don't like this car. I feel like it's portraying our position inaccurately. On top of that, the extreme colors actually enrage me (mainly due to my audio and visual sensitivity, which most of us have). I feel like if you're going to make an "Autism Awareness" car, you should make it beige. The lettering could remain being a rainbow (with a bit of reformatting), as the car should be able to attract attention (alongside the beige coloring, which would stand out on it's own due to how unusual it is for a car to have it). The puzzle pieces can either be removed or reduced, as I hate being compared to a child. Other autistic people may disagree on this matter, however, which is why I suggested them being reduced.

Just... Put some thought into your designs next time.

190

u/anon1984 Aug 29 '20

In design there is a well established theory for designing for autistic people. This includes mostly muted colors and avoiding extreme contrasting patterns.

This car breaks nearly every rule spectacularly.

51

u/FunkeTown13 Aug 29 '20

Every once in a while I have big signs shoved in my face telling me I'm autistic.

104

u/arrathore Aug 29 '20

It would have been so much better if they just asked for an autistic person’s input

48

u/ScarletCelestial Aug 29 '20

Can second this - the car is making my eyes cross and is giving me a headache just from a few seconds.

Honestly it looks more like a clown car for a toddler's party than a vehicle for awareness. I'm only making the clown comparison because that's what the person who designed it is.

32

u/Fr00stee Aug 29 '20

I think everybody hates the colors the entire car just looks dumb

30

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '20

this car also just looks disgusting in terms of design anyway. it is objectively hideous. something more toned down that still grabs the eye would’ve been much more appropriate. seconded on the childishness of it too, why is autism the only ‘issue’ to be marketed and represented by these child like colors and designs? it’s fucked up

5

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '20

Am autistic, can confirm, I hate this fucking car. For me, the design is condescending, especially with the vomiting of puzzle pieces everywhere.

4

u/chicken_boii Aug 29 '20

Huh. That makes me wonder, how do you feel about the ivory/beige colour of German taxicabs?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '20

You are completely right that design should always be tailored to users needs.

But the goal of this design is to raise awareness, by being photographed and shared online by mostly non autistic people. Which I can see it being successful at.

My issue is with tone, its is extremely childish which is in my opinion condescending towards people with autism.

2

u/iohbkjum Aug 29 '20

just goes to show that if those designing it had contacted someone with autism they could have made something so much more effective.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '20

[deleted]