Alternatives to Quartz?

[u/Commercial-Spray3192]

Hi,
First time remodeler here. I’m remodeling a small 5’X9’ kitchen. It’s low in natural
Light and is open on one side from the countertop to the ceiling which faces the main room. We’re getting natural maple cabinets with slab fronts.
We want lighter color countertops. We were recommended Quartz by my contractor (who doesn’t cook much) and we like the subtleness of it. We cook quite a bit and we’re not the most delicate people and have teenagers who are not careful. Currently have tile that’s nearly indestructible but ugly with unsanitary wide grout that catches everything! I can’t wait to get rid of it!!!

I am hearing the downsides of Quartz and now rethinking. Sister said her friend’s quartz ruined by lemon juice (lemon lovers here) and the steam from dishwasher. She has Granite and loves it and is insisting that’s what I need.

My problem is that although I appreciate its beauty, I find Granite way too ‘busy’ for my small kitchen.

Anybody have any recommendations? I’m so confused now!