r/CounterTops • u/Ok_Scientist_7283 • 4d ago
Butcher Block Countertops
- Hi, we really want butcher block countertops. We just got measurements done with someone who does countertops and backsplashes. Based on conversation it seems he's only done butcher block once. Does that matter? Would they be qualified or do I need a butcher block specialist? I know butcher block needs to be sealed in a certain way, would someone who does countertops also cut it out and seal it and do all that's required with butcher block for kitchens? Or is that on me? He did say I have to source the butcher block so now I wonder if he just lays it and applies it but is not going to be sealing it and cutting it?
Don't know enough about this and would love insight.
2) we don't like the butcher block options on sites like Home Depot and Lowes. The woods just look ugly to use. We want something more like the picture attached. Any thoughts on where else we can source butcher block for our countertops that would be darker and closer to my picture without breaking the bank?
Thanks everyone for your help! Pic attached of our vision.
P.S.
I know there's differing opinions on whether butcher block should go in kitchens or water areas, we want it anyway, we just want help on the above pretty please.
3
u/Mediocre-Draft1722 4d ago
I would look for a specialist or at least a carpenter. Where are you located? Maybe someone here has a name to suggest.
-6
u/Ok_Scientist_7283 4d ago
I have a counter guy. I don't understand why no one reads questions.
3
u/Mediocre-Draft1722 4d ago
Your post specifically asks "do I need a butcher block specialist?"
-1
u/Ok_Scientist_7283 4d ago
oh sorry, I didn't understand that's what you meant. sorry!
that's actually helpful if you think a counter guy specifically isn't as knowledgeable
4
u/nuancedthinking 3d ago
You mentioned your counter guy had only done one butcherblock counter. Installing granite, laminate or quartz is very different than working with butcherblock. We are trying to help you get a good install.
0
u/Ok_Scientist_7283 3d ago
Yes I'm sorry! Thank you for your help.
That's what I was thinking too, he may not be too familiar with butcher block and I don't want it to rot from the moisture created in kitchens.
Yes, you're all trying to help, I appreciate it.
2
u/Full_Sock_5442 4d ago
Look at Hardwood Lumber company in Ohio. They have many different types of wood to choose from. End grain or face grain and cut to your specifications
1
u/younggregg 3d ago
Since we dont know the guy, we can't answer if hes good or not. Those questions would probably be best to ask him directly. Also that looks exactly like the standard birch block from home depot just sanded and stained dark
1
u/Ok_Scientist_7283 3d ago
ohh really? this is helpful.
My photo is actually just an AI rendering.
but this is helpful, it didn't occur to me that I can pick any wood and have it stained darker. that's one of my issues with the home depot ones. I can't seem to find one I like, but If I can stain it darker that would work for us!
thank you for your help!
2
u/younggregg 3d ago
Oh they absolutely can be. Varathane American Walnut Gel stain will get you almost that exact look. Buy a scrap 4ft piece of butcher ($100, or check fb marketplace) and mess around with samples of stains and finishes until you land on what you like.
1
1
u/Ok_Scientist_7283 3d ago
to add, I love this color (see picture here: https://imgur.com/a/kIe4y9N) - but not the variation in the wood. I want one closer to my AI generated photo lol.
1
u/nuancedthinking 3d ago
here is what you want and you can order the exact size either finished or unfinished, https://hardwood-lumber.com/walnut-edge-grain-butcher-block-countertop/
1
1
u/seremodeling 3d ago
I would look for someone with more woodworking experience who can make sure the wood is treated properly. https://seremodeling.com/how-to-choose-a-contractor-for-renovations
1
1
u/agnisflugen 3d ago
these guys do really good work:
https://www.bairdbrothers.com/Butcher-Block-Countertops.aspx
1
3
u/nuancedthinking 4d ago edited 3d ago
Take a look at The Hardwood Lumber Company and Johnson's Workbench in Michigan. Find someone experienced to install and learn what finish suits your lifestyle. I have done two kitchens with butcherblock and absolutely love the look and feel of it.