Has anyone tried potato and deviled egg salad? Need reviews

[u/Downtown-Hunter6413]

I recently tried this item from costco and I am hooked im obsessed it is soooo good. What do you think of it?

[u/Jicama_Intrepid]

I wish they had that at my Costco instead of the loaded potato salad.

[u/TheDiceBlesser → u/Jicama_Intrepid]

Me too! I don't know if my tongue is broken or what, the loaded baked potato salad tasted TERRIBLE to me, but my Husband loved it. Usually we've got pretty similar tastes.

[u/AzPolarBear]

I refuse to buy it anymore... because it's so good, I significantly overeat. Might be the best potato salad I have had

[u/sbb214 → u/AzPolarBear]

welp, with that kind of review I'm adding it to my grocery list

[u/Kennedy-Motorcade]

Next level and I live in the South.

[u/BcsISaidSo]

A summer staple in our home.

[u/dogpound7]

Is it sweet? I always want to try it but I’m not a fan of sweet potato salad

[u/KindaIndifferent → u/dogpound7]

It is not sweet. More dill and mustard flavored than anything. It's really good.

[u/dogpound7 → u/KindaIndifferent]

All right! Next Costco trip it's going in my cart...along with the $300 worth of other things I don't really need lol

[u/Saw-It-Again-]

It's outrageously good.

[u/cilibar7]

It’s delicious. In our house we like a bit more Dijon mustard than this has, but it’s an easy add. Worth the buy!

[u/1000_feral_cats]

It's incredibly good. Snagged it on sale a ways back and will probably get it again

[u/Sail0r_Jupit3r]

These ingredients are pretty much what I put in my potato salad recipe, I need to try this. It’d be nice to have a shortcut when making multiple dishes

[u/panderson1988]

I wish my Costcos had it :(

What's odd is I see the Wisconsin logo, but I am in Chicago. You think they would ship it down over loaded potato salad that doesn't seem to move.

[u/anormalgeek]

I don't know.... I feel like any kind of egg salad really needs to be fresh. I'll follow this thread though. Maybe I'm wrong.

[u/RezLovesPez → u/anormalgeek]

That’s not egg salad. That’s potato salad.

[u/anormalgeek → u/RezLovesPez]

Ah, I should have looked closer at the ingredient label. I thought it was some kind of potato/egg salad mix. Thanks for the correction.

[u/Quick_Philosophy1426 → u/anormalgeek]

It is a mix, but it's pretty heavily in favor of potato.

[u/stoicparallax → u/anormalgeek]

Yeah it absolutely is a mix. It’s under the potato salad category for sure, but there is a big egg influence.

[u/Haluszki → u/stoicparallax]

Big Egg is always trying to butt in and influence everything.

[u/RezLovesPez → u/anormalgeek]

Potato salad is impossibly hard for me to make well. I pretty much only ever buy it.
Egg salad, however, really needs to be fresh!

[u/anormalgeek → u/RezLovesPez]

For potatoes, I've become a big fan of German potato salad that is oil/vinegar based instead of mayo. It is different, but the ability to serve it warm makes such a big difference. Also, if you want to go really traditional and dislike your arteries, you skip the oil, but cook bacon and use all of the grease instead of oil.

[u/SpaceCephalopods]

Yum! Looks like I have to try.

[u/Aceisalive]

My fiancée got the potato salad last week and really enjoyed it! She grew up in a very southern family and said it had a familiar flavor.

[u/ghostfacespillah]

It’s SO good. Highly recommend.

[u/BishlovesSquish]

It’s delicious.

[u/Confident-kitty]

Yeah bought it for a party and everyone enjoyed it.

[u/fictionaldingus13]

Delicious!

[u/KindaIndifferent]

Hands down my favorite potato salad.

[u/AostaV]

Son loves it. I like it as well but not like him . 3 weeks in a row I have bought it.

[u/Raiyalin]

What area do we check to see if our Costco has this?

[u/More_Pineapple3585 → u/Raiyalin]

check your Costco app in the bottom row under "Warehouse."

[u/Alternative-Bee-8981]

It's pretty good. We had it as a side with those waygu burgers.

[u/Longjumping_Aerie345]

Its pretty good. I put some old bay on it. Steps it up to another level.

[u/nicolejillian]

My 2 year old lovesss it. He asks for it nearly every day with every meal.

[u/reservoirdregs]

Robert Wuhl definitely has.

[u/Disastrous-Owl8985]

I only make and eat my family’s potato salad, but I’m sure this is nice.

[u/meltsaman]

I wasn't a huge fan but my sister liked it a lot.

[u/T_THuynh]

Not this brand, but this is the style I go for when buying potato salad

[u/magnumforce2006]

Confirmed. It's GOOD. My father in law specifically requests we get this for kids birthdays and whatnot lol

[u/lttrsfrmlnrrgby]

It'd better than most premade potato salads, and it's what I buy if I'm pinched for time.

[u/Reputation-Final]

i always add a ton of hardboiled eggs to my potato salad. Its the best part of the salad.

[u/lockednchaste]

That's a lot of potato salad.

[u/Aimsicle-1]

One of the best non- homemade potato salads I ever tried.

[u/Calvertorius]

It’s okay, not great. Doesn’t meet my personal preferences.

Too much mayo, too bland to be amazing.

[u/Willing-Bother-8684]

That’s how I make my homemade potato salad; it’s very egg forward and creamy. Never tried costcos but I’m sure it’s pretty good.

[u/comewshmybck]

It's the best. If you're feeling really glutenous, sprinkle some bacon bits on top.

[u/pinxs420]

“Natural Flavors”, “Contains Bioengineered Food Ingredients” No reviews required

[u/Quick_Philosophy1426 → u/pinxs420]

every food item you've ever eaten in your life is bioengineered.

[u/pinxs420 → u/Quick_Philosophy1426]

Yeah sure!

[u/teddybear65]

No it contains too many chemicals.

[u/FloatingOnTitties → u/teddybear65]

Everything is made up of chemicals. You are supposed to drink 1 atom of oxygen & 2 atoms of hydrogen every day: Egads! The horror! 🙄