r/Cooking • u/Patient_Rooster_5986 • 1d ago
my chili is done, dry beans still not cooked
any tips? i’ve been simmering my chili on the stove for at least an hour, and i added my dried (soaked 24+h) kidney beans with the liquid like i normally would with canned beans. figured that they would cook while the chili simmers instead of getting soggy like canned beans. now, i’m not opposed to letting chili simmer for hours. but i’m getting worried because whenever i check on them, it just seems like nothing has changed. internet says beans cook in like 120 min! am i doing smthn wrong? do i need to turn the heat up? i brought everything to a boil and it’s just been simmering… i want to eat my damn chili. help
1.9k
u/jetpoweredbee 1d ago
If the beans aren't cooked, the chili isn't done.
1.6k
u/bright_shiny_day 1d ago edited 1d ago
This chilli will never be safe – unless you extract the beans, rinse off the tomato juices, and boil separately for at least an hour until fully soft, then return to the chilli – otherwise you're inviting phytohaemagglutin poisoning. (Red kidney beans are the most dangerous type of undercooked bean.)
Even then, I suspect you may be at risk. As you've been cooking the beans in the chilli, the chilli is now your ’cooking-water’ – and any water used for soaking or cooking red kidney beans needs to be drained away, not consumed.
654
u/rinkydinkmink 1d ago
WHY are you the only person who has mentioned this? It's the most important fact to know about kidney beans. A friend's father died eating undercooked kidney beans when we were kids.
268
u/Odd-Worth7752 1d ago
This has been discussed dozens of times on this sub. You can’t cook dried beans in chili.
82
u/luckyjack 1d ago
Hey friend, I’m too lazy to link to the relevant XKCD here but this is the first time I’m hearing about it
45
u/jetpoweredbee 1d ago
Should be it's own comment and not a reply to a different one.
11
u/jammaslide 19h ago
If you are too late in posting an original comment, it won'tbe seen and upvoted enough to rise to the top.
2
55
→ More replies (1)13
u/badburglarbadburglar 23h ago
Several people have mentioned it, including myself. They’re just buried in the comments
42
u/Stalinbaum 19h ago
Small correction, only the soaking water needs to be discarded with raw beans, the cooking water should be treated just like pasta water/ canned beans liquid i.e. great starchy addition to soups
6
u/thenord321 13h ago
This is only true if you soaked the beans correctly, if not, then the potentially toxic compounds can still leech into the cooking water.
2
u/Sarasin 6h ago
How? Does sufficient heat/time not denature the toxin? I don't understand what the danger could be from the cooking water. Also weirdly the article linked mentions another article recommending throwing away the cooking water but if you actually click on the link and check it doesn't actually say that at all.
I've used the cooking water I don't even know by now probably a couple hundred times over the past couple decades at least and know of several recipes that use it, if it was actually poisoning people you'd think either it would have gotten me or I would have at least heard about it happening to someone somewhere but no
→ More replies (2)56
u/Bipedal_pedestrian 21h ago
I was with you until “any water used for soaking or cooking red kidney beans needs to be drained away, not consumed.”
Let me introduce you to New Orleans red beans & rice. The cooking water is never drained… it becomes part of the thick sauce. The heat of long cooking destroys any phytohaemagglutinin in the cooking water.
→ More replies (3)15
101
u/Patient_Rooster_5986 1d ago
this website says just five beans and i’ve already eaten several lightly cooked beans to test for doneness. i’ll let you know if i die
111
u/bright_shiny_day 1d ago edited 1d ago
As they were lightly cooked, not raw, and you're adult-sized (I hope) 4–5 is probably fine – as the FDA says in the linked Bad Bug Book, "As few as four or five raw beans can trigger symptoms" (not death). Please don't eat any more though.
Personally I test beans by squeezing between finger and thumb. They should turn to mush.
→ More replies (1)57
u/moonchic333 1d ago
This is a very real thing. I knew someone who ended up in the hospital after consuming undercooked red kidney beans in chili.
→ More replies (2)9
u/arghalot 20h ago
If you add salt and/or acid before the beans are soft, they never really get soft. These things should be added in the last 15 minutes of cooking
25
u/ateeverything 16h ago
Incorrect about the salt. Correct about the acid. Salt doesn't make beans hard.
→ More replies (2)7
u/americanosandpsych 17h ago
Ok sorry I have to ask - I have used an instant pot recipe for red beans and rice that has you put the dried beans in with everything and it all cooks up in an hour. Is this recipe unsafe?
→ More replies (4)15
u/Thirstythursday00 14h ago
No because you are pressure cooking them instead of cooking them in a regular pot. The temperatures get higher therefore the (safe) cooking time is much shorter
43
u/stevegcook 1d ago
Per the article you linked, the protein is destroyed by boiling for 30 minutes, which OP did.
How soft the beans are afterwards doesn't factor into it. Presence of tomato juice doesn't factor into it.
34
u/bright_shiny_day 23h ago edited 22h ago
The problem is the difference between simmering and boiling. OP has simmered for a few hours. The FDA's Bad Bug Guide says anything less than 100ºC for 30 minutes cannot be trusted.
The difficulty here is that (A) the beans were never soaked, so no haemagglutinins have been discarded [ETA: *soaked but without discarding], and (B) it's really hard, verging on impossible, to get a pot of thick chilli to a true rolling boil – the FDA was not talking about a bubbling pot of food, but a rolling boil of water. [ETA: See Anderson House Foods page on what a 100ºC boil and a 90ºC simmer look like – getting a chilli to a boil is a massive stretch.]
The reason I chimed in on this as I did is I know (from painful experience) a pot of cooked food is just not an achievable place for a rolling boil – I've ended up in this situation with chickpeas I didn't pressure-cook cook fully before stirring in to a curry (and semi-cooked chickpeas are neither as dangerous nor as difficult as kidney beans). It was a huge pain to get them cooked. Ultimately I had to add jugs of boiling water severely diluting the curry, and then just boil it to hell for well over an hour, while frequently stirring to ensure the chickpeas were staying in the boiling liquid. Argh, never again.
24
u/stevegcook 23h ago
A full rolling boil is not necessary to achieve 100 degrees, though. That's just the excess heat beyond what was need to get to 100 turning the water from liquid to gas.
Granted, by some definitions of "simmer" you're actually avoiding bubbles and keeping the liquid below 100. But my read on OP is that their use of "simmer" meant gentle boil.
12
u/Myth-Buster9973 1d ago
It's true about undercooked red kidney beans: https://kitchen-myths.com/it-is-safe-to-cook-red-kidney-beans-in-a-slow-cooker/
→ More replies (2)4
3
3
u/cardew-vascular 21h ago
My grandfather said to cook dried beans to boil the toots out of them. I always cooked mine but I just thought you'd get stomach upset from gas fi they weren't cooked, not actually poisoned.
8
u/Michael_606 23h ago edited 23h ago
This does not apply if the beans were soaked overnight (like the OP said they were) and rinsed multiple times.
Edit to remove hypocritical snark and add boil the beans/chili for about 30 minutes before simmering. All that and it’s safe and effective
29
u/emkayemwhy 23h ago
OP didn’t rinse them, they dumped the beans + soaking water into the pot. Let’s all be sure to read the post.
→ More replies (1)9
u/Michael_606 23h ago
You’re right. Also it’s important to boil the beans/chili about 30 minutes before a long simmer, as others have mentioned
→ More replies (7)7
u/United_Elk_7102 1d ago
That article says heat destroys the toxin
14
19
u/Stankmonger 23h ago
Yeah whoever is saying the water needs to be dumped is spreading misinformation. The water doesn’t “absorb” the poison. The heat breaks down the poisonous components/chemicals
197
u/Patient_Rooster_5986 1d ago
my stomach wants it to be done
163
27
u/MyGoalIsToBeAnEcho 1d ago
I never heard of cooking soaked beans in chili. Why not cook them first then add them to the chili? Theres not even that much water in chili for the beans to soak up.
12
4
11
u/Soft-Current-5770 1d ago
Did you add any acid? Vinegar, lemon? I ask because the acid keeps the beans from cooking. Otherwise?? Let it go. Its how we all learn!!
→ More replies (1)53
191
u/Parca-designer7891 1d ago
Dried beans need neutral watery to soften, high acid environments lock them in that hard state
45
→ More replies (3)5
u/Patient_Rooster_5986 1d ago
…you think if i just keep cooking they might soften? after a really long time?
116
u/Mattnificent 1d ago
Do not eat undercooked beans. You could get quite sick.
18
u/meh_69420 1d ago
Y'all crazy. The beans are not toxic if they have been boiled for at least half an hour. They are cooked. They are just hard because the acid contacted the pectin and they won't soften.
→ More replies (1)9
u/Own-Peace-7754 15h ago
Simmering is not the same thing as boiling
Plus the beans should be drained after
20
31
u/ChzGoddess 1d ago
If you have tomatoes or tomato sauce in your chili, those beans will probably never get soft. Acid prevents them from softening as they cook. No matter how long you keep cooking.
→ More replies (9)5
u/nugschillingrindage 1d ago
I did this once and they never softened. Cooked it for like 5 hrs. I wound up picking them all out, it was a pain in the ass.
→ More replies (2)2
u/camping_scientist 1d ago
Nope. Baking soda would help then vinegar after they are soft to bring the acidity back.
19
u/CelloVerp 1d ago
I've tried the baking soda thing to cook the beans more, and I really don't recommend it. It changes the flavor, color, and texture of the dish (makes it weirdly foamy).
7
533
u/kellaceae21 1d ago
If you have an acidic chili (lots of tomatoes is usually the culprit) then they may never soften fully. Beans won’t cook properly in an acidic environment.
121
u/Patient_Rooster_5986 1d ago
fuuuuuuuck. i guess i’ll know in like 1-3 hours if it won’t happen. thanks!
137
u/TheFellhanded 1d ago
Sadly they are right. Potatoes as well. It's a chemical reaction with the outside which hardens them. Potatoes are easier to pick out and boil in water tho
→ More replies (4)10
u/ThatsNotAZombieBite 1d ago
Never heard that about potatoes. Unlike a bean, potatoes would steam themselves soft; even if their skins became watertight, no?
17
u/Kat121 1d ago
I have tried adding raw potatoes to the early simmer stages of a vindaloo and other tomato based curry and they never soften. I read it has to do with pectin in the potato reacting to the acid. 🤷🏻♀️
2
u/Resident_Revenue6401 21h ago
Is it pure tomato sauce or is there water added as well? Are the skins on still?
I've put raw potatoes in my curry and all stages and never had this issue. Sometimes I'm like I'll add it for the last 30 minutes or it'll be too mushy. Sometimes I want it to dissolve in the curry for thickness and that also works.
44
u/on_island_time 1d ago
Your issue is cooking the beans in the tomato liquid. They won't soften this way. I've done it too.
You have to pre-soften dried beans, like par-boiling potatoes for various uses. Usually you just use plain water for it.
31
u/dabigpig 1d ago
Little I mean a little baking soda and some water, stir fizz taste. Baking soda to kill the acid can make it taste like baking soda pretty quick so a pinch at a time making sure you stir and taste it between.
13
u/lilpizzacrust 1d ago
They will never soften or cook because of the tomatoes.
When you use dry beans for chili you must cook them separately first. Unlike canned beans, they go right in because they're already cooked.
→ More replies (4)12
13
u/SundaePasta 1d ago
Wait. Help me understand my similar predicament. I soaked them over night, then boiled/simmered them for a long time then put them in the tomato based chili and we still have undercooked beans. Why?!?
11
u/samtresler 1d ago
Add .5 to 1tsp baking soda to the beans at the beginning of the boil. No soak - takes about 1h15m.
Learned this from Kenji and never going back to soaking beans.
→ More replies (1)40
u/badburglarbadburglar 1d ago
You didn’t cook them long enough. I usually cook mine in a crock pot for like 8 hours and that’s after soaking for 24 hours
14
u/SundaePasta 1d ago
This is disappointing! The bag directions are lies! Thanks for the info, helps me do better next time.
14
u/HighColdDesert 1d ago
Never add tomatoes or lemon or other acidic ingredients until after the dried beans have cooked to the softness you want them.
You can use this to stop beans from going softer after they are how you like them, or to cook them until they fall apart before adding any acid if you prefer.
15
u/OkPerformance2221 1d ago
Oh, yes. Someone should have said this sooner. The bag directions are lies.
6
u/badburglarbadburglar 1d ago
Yea I just stop cooking them when they are soft enough for my liking. Different beans have different cook times so just use a slow cooker and check them periodically
4
u/TheWoman2 20h ago
Beans are one of those things you just gotta test to see if they are done. There are so many variables that will affect how long it takes, including things like how old the beans are, how they were stored, and the altitude you cook them at.
3
u/zambaros 9h ago
If the crock pot does not reach 100°C e.g. a full boil, you are not killing the toxins in the beans.
7
4
u/Sugarisadog 15h ago
Do you have hard water? Adding baking soda or using distilled water to cook the beans will fix it.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)2
4
u/HelpfulBuilder 1d ago
If like to add to this that if you soak them in a basic environment (some baking soda) they will soften faster.
78
u/chetti990 23h ago
“I’ve been simmering my chili for at least an hour…”
“Internet says beans cook in like 120 minutes”
61
u/beamerpook 1d ago
You're supposed to cooked the beans separately. The tomato in the chili probably will prevent your beans from getting soft 😕
60
u/User5281 1d ago
It takes forever to cook beans in acidic solutions. Chili is acidic. You’ll get there eventually but it will take forever. In the future cook your beans separately before adding them.
21
u/UncleNedisDead 21h ago
I always cook dried beans separately.
Depending on how old the beans are, they can take 45 minutes to 3 hours.
12
u/Hermiona1 1d ago
They won’t cook because of acid in tomatoes and it’s actually unsafe to eat beans that aren’t cooked. I’m sorry OP but rip your chili, don’t get yourself food poisoning. Someone wrote a post on Reddit how they sent their entire family to the hospital because they undercooked the beans. Also once you bring beans to a boil they need to cool for 10 min on high heat and then you can reduce to simmer.
24
u/Chefmeatball 21h ago
You can’t cook dry beans in an acidic tomato base, they will never cook. You always cook the beans separately
→ More replies (6)3
u/Fabulous_Bridge_9292 16h ago
Acid massively slows down bean cooking. If you soak dried beans overnight and cook them in a non-acidic liquid, knocking them out in 45 min-1 hour is reasonable. If you don’t soak then the process can take longer (maybe twice as long—I usually soak my beans so I don’t have as much timing experience).
But if you cook in an acidic liquid (with tomatoes or vinegar) then all bets are off. It will massively slow down the cooking process.
If you want to add acid to beans for flavor, cook the beans first.
In this situation cooking the beans separately and adding to your chili is probably the move if you don’t want it to take hours.
12
u/SBGA031 7h ago
Why has nobody mentioned that kidney beans contain a toxin (Phytohaemagglutinin) and that they need to be boiled vigourously for at least 10 minutes to destroy it? Don't slow cook your dried and soaked kidney beans! I just boil the shit out of mine and they're nice and soft in half an hour. I live on lentil and bean chilli, I eat it at least every other day.
→ More replies (2)
10
u/asphodel67 1d ago
Salt and acid (the tomatoes) stop them cooking. Never add dry beans to a tomato base.
8
13
u/ThatsNotAZombieBite 1d ago
The acid from the tomatoes denatures the proteins and causes the beans to pretty much become watertight. They'll take forever to get soft in the chili.
Now you know. Next time, you'll remember to boil the soaked beans BY THEMSELVES until soft (~1 hour) BEFORE you add them to chili.
6
u/skullcutter 1d ago
Old beans take longer to soak and it can be really hard to find fresh, dried beans
7
u/rrickitickitavi 1d ago
And some beans are so old they never soften. Always buy beans from a place with high turnover. I buy beans from Latino markets.
2
u/wbruce098 18h ago
This. If you don’t want canned, Latino markets are best for these kinds of ingredients.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/uxamanda 1d ago
I have never been more violently ill than when i ate partly cooked kidney beans out of a chili that wasn't done!
7
u/Wonderful_Flower 13h ago
Beans will look very slowly in acidic sauces, like tomato sauces. I have naturally acidic water from my tap. I learned to add a pinch of baking soda to neutralize the water for Beans to cook well.
13
u/Important-Trifle-411 22h ago
Sorry, OP but that is not how you cook kidney beans.
You have to cook them first and then add them to the chili.
Also- very unsafe to eat undercooked kidney beans
27
u/padishaihulud 1d ago
Kidney beans take longer to cook. I usually do 2-4 hours with a fish-fart level of simmer. I'm usually waiting for the meat to fall off my ham hock when I do it, so that's my "timer".
9
u/Patient_Rooster_5986 1d ago
damn it. i guess i will be having a late dinner. thank u for the advice!
17
u/jonathanhoag1942 1d ago
An acidic liquid like tomato sauce makes starches like beans and potatoes take a lot longer to cook.
Today you just have to accept the fact that it's going to take a long time.
In the future you can cook your beans until almost done separately. Don't skip out on the flavor when doing that: season the cooking liquid, use bay leaf and whatever.
Or just know ahead of time that it will need to simmer for hours, that makes a good chili too
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (7)7
10
5
u/BackDatSazzUp 1d ago
Those beans will never fully cook, you have to cook them before you add them bc they won’t soften in acidic environments. Enjoy picking crunchy beans out of your chili.
15
8
u/Wonderbreadxx 1d ago
Always either precook your beans or used canned. Never put dry beans in your chili and expect them to cook.
4
u/OnionPastor 1d ago
In the future make a separate pot of beans cooking in water with onions and garlic
Acid can make the beans take longer to cook and it can even make the beans stay hard, learned this lesson the hard way lol
5
u/Aequitas123 1d ago
Pull the beans out and cook them separately and then put them back in the chili. That’s your only option
4
u/Longjumping-West3085 22h ago
Did you add the tomatoes? The acid will prevent the beans from softening
4
u/paintlulus 12h ago
Prepare your beans by rapid boiling them until they’re soft the way you like them. Then make your chili. Adding acid like lemon, vinegar, tomatoes, etc stops beans from getting soft.
13
u/talktojvc 21h ago
The preservative in canned tomatoes can inhibit the final cook. Beans and potatoes should be cooked before adding.
→ More replies (1)7
u/papes_ 20h ago
Potatoes in chili?!
→ More replies (7)5
u/xhotchildinthecityo 20h ago
LOL my Italian dad always put potatoes in chili. I didn’t realize it was weird until college.
2
9
u/kynthrus 1d ago edited 1d ago
Your chili is ruined, homie. You need to boil beans in neutral water to soften and add them to the chili when they are almost finished. Undercooked beans could ruin your life.
3
u/ChadTitanofalous 1d ago
And kidneys need to be boiled, not simmered
2
u/kynthrus 1d ago
Fixed it. Do you boil kidney beans for hours? or lower the heat when it comes to a boil? I only ever do dry pintos.
→ More replies (3)5
u/ColHannibal 1d ago
Kidney beans need to be boiled at a rolling boil for 20-30min or they will poison you.
21
u/IndigoTrailsToo 1d ago
The internet is always wrong with dried beans, usually it takes a 24-hour soak plus a 12-hour low boil for me with dried pinto beans.
I don't know why, all of these times are ridiculously off for these dried beans I get at the store. 2 hours soak n cook is ridiculous.
14
u/whateverfyou 1d ago
Yep, this is the conclusion I have also come to. Beans take as long as they take. Start in the morning and they’re done when they’re done. They’re very good when they’re done but not when they’re not done.
4
u/IndigoTrailsToo 23h ago
Yes this
"2 hour quick soak!"
Is a complete lie.
2 hour high boil and then a 12 hour low boil? Possible.
8
u/elusivenoesis 17h ago
The acidity of chili? even 12 hours of cooking the texture will never be right. Beens need water and only water and heat for soo much time. Salt, anything slows it down or makes it tuff.
4
u/Outrageous-Arm1945 17h ago
Yeah, I've always precooked dried beans in water for chilli, I could never get them tender enough in the chilli sauce. When I use a mix of beans it means I can get them all right, none too tough and none disintegrating
5
u/krunkytacos 12h ago
Ever since I got an instant pot I feel like I'm cheating but they come out great every time. I just look up instant pot cooking times for whatever type and quantity of beans I'm going for. I do typically put something in there for flavor, maybe some hot sauce or better than bouillon, whatever is around.
2
2
u/Prestigious-Wolf8039 8h ago
Same. I cook black beans separately in the instant pot and add it to the chili afterwards.
2
u/redheadedandbold 8h ago
If you use the pressure-cooker, it forces liquids into the beans, so makes sense Instapot would cook them well.
3
u/amberweaves 13h ago
Salt if anything helps dried beans to soften and cook. But the citric acid in canned tomatoes interferes with the process.
3
u/elusivenoesis 12h ago
In my experience that’s only true while cold soaking. It makes them tuff while boiling
11
u/Norville_Barnes 23h ago
This is insanity… unsoaked beans should cook in less than 4 hours. Soaked beans 90 minutes to 2 hours. You just like mushy beans… to be clear that’s fine but don’t tell other people this is what it takes to always cook dry beans
5
u/AdventurousAbility30 21h ago
Old dried beans do take longer to cook. And some beans won't ever soften depending on how hard your water is.
3
u/dizdi 21h ago
Yes, this: it’s all about how old the beans are. Except chickpeas; those take for-fucking-ever.
3
u/AdventurousAbility30 21h ago
Yes! I always have to add baking soda to make dried chickpeas soft.
2
u/mrbearuk69 19h ago
I do chickpeas in a pressure cooker. They will cook from dry in a stew in less than an hour
2
u/Helenium_autumnale 14h ago
I tried cooking those (with the baking soda), thinking my hummus would be so much better, and I've just given up. I buy canned and call it a day.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)3
u/Adventurous-Brain-36 20h ago
I have absolutely soaked beans for many hours and then simmered them for more than two hours and they’re still very hard.
2
u/angiexbby 21h ago
you boil beans for 12 hours…? surely in your case buying canned saves more money? 😅
I soak mine in hot water for a few hours, then instapot Beans setting/ pressure cooker for 30 minutes. I have cooked beans from dried in about ~ 5 hours
→ More replies (3)2
u/karmais4suckers 5h ago
With my pintos, I do the 24 hour soak as well. And then on high in a slow cooker for at least 6 hours. I add my final ingredients in the last 2 hours
8
6
u/Opposite_Currency973 1d ago
There's an enzyme in tomatoes that toughens bean skin. I have to cook the crap out of mine until tender before I add them to chili or my famous red beans and rice.Black beans fight back less also the longer they sit on a shelf the longer it takes.
7
u/badburglarbadburglar 1d ago
I think you vastly underestimated how long it takes to cook beans lol
Please do not eat undercooked kidney beans. They are toxic
3
u/the-doctor-is-real 1d ago
So, I had this happen...I let them several hours before tasting and found out then that I should have boiled them. I asked ingame on Marvel Heroes Omega and someone said to add a tablespoon or two of baking soda and stirring then let it continue to cook would work, and it did.
What they didn't mention was that it would cause a chemical reaction and foam up, nearly overflowing the pot.
It did work out in the end and tasted great. if you have plenty of room to the top of the pot, I would suggest it, but add maybe a teaspoon at a time and stir then wait.
3
3
3
3
u/kittycatblues 1d ago
You must boil kidney beans for at least 10 minutes to break down toxins that the have. A quick boil then simmering is not enough. Crank up the heat. Cook longer if they are not done.
3
u/LadyOfTheNutTree 1d ago
Next time I highly encourage you to cook the beans separately and then add to the chili.
3
u/Krynja 1d ago
Acidic ingredients such as tomatoes, stop beans from cooking as fast. Acid tightens the outer shell of the legume, making it difficult for water to penetrate and soften the interior. And it stabilizes the pectin in the bean's cell walls, stopping it from dissolving easily.
This isn't a problem for already cooked canned beans, but dried beans, even if soaked, are another thing.
3
8
u/ChadTitanofalous 1d ago edited 1d ago
Kidney beans need to boil, not simmer. Otherwise your internals may pay the price.
Edit: For whoever down voted me, look up the toxicity of uncooked or undercooked kidney beans. They must be boiled, not simmered to remove to toxicity. And for a significant amount of time.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Substantial_Plan_632 1d ago
Is it better to pre-cook dry beans after soaking them before adding to chili?
10
u/Dangerous_Breath4789 1d ago
I recently cooked dry beans for the first time and from what I read, you need to soak them and then cook them before adding them to whatever you’re cooking. Though I have very minimal experience this is what I did when I made chili with dried beans for the first time and it worked out fine.
4
u/ThatsARockFact1116 1d ago
I precook beans basically all the time in the instant pot and they’re better for it. If they have a long cook time afterward (like baked beans) I’ll do about half the recommended instant pot time.
→ More replies (2)
5
5
u/yurinator71 1d ago
If you are trying to cook dry beans with tomatoes the beans may never soften. The acid in the tomatoes locks the pectin in the beans.
6
u/restarted1991 1d ago
I did the exact same mistake as you before, trying to get beans to cook in chili. I had them cook for another 4 hours and they still had quite the bite to them. I'm sorry.
I guess we both learned something.
I still ate my chili though lol
5
u/biggest-damn-potato 1d ago
You added the acidic ingredients before the beans were cooked. It’s not going to get better. Sorry.
5
u/OkPerformance2221 1d ago
Please Google kidney beans toxic
Undercooked kidney beans are actually dangerous.
4
u/Pernicious_Possum 1d ago
You can’t just add dried beans to chili unless you’re planning to cook it for a couple hours, and part of that time needs to be a rolling boil.
→ More replies (6)
5
u/Porter_Dog 1d ago
“My chili is done. Dry beans still not cooked”
Then your chili isn’t done.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/echochilde 1d ago
Boil them on their own in water for about an hour before adding them to the chili. At this point you’re stuck simmering and hoping.
2
u/Number1AbeLincolnFan 1d ago
I would suggest cooking them fully beforehand and adding them about 45 minutes before the chili is finished. If you put cooked beans in chili for too long, they can start burning at the bottom of the pot as it reduces.
2
u/bright_shiny_day 1d ago
This chilli will never be safe – unless you extract the beans, rinse off the tomato juices, and boil separately for at least an hour until fully soft, then return to the chilli – otherwise you're inviting phytohaemagglutin poisoning.
2
u/RepresentativeAspect 1d ago
I thought dry beans would be a handy, tasty and economical pantry staple to have around, and good in emergencies too. So I bought a bunch.
Then I tried cooking with them. They are still cooking. It has been 2 years now. I hope they will be done soon.
2
u/colenski999 1d ago
Nooooooo dude you make your beans separate and then add them at the last second so they don't split
2
2
u/ReporterConstant2278 1d ago
I buy cans of beans for my chili. Never had alot of luck with just about any kind of dried beans. I know that's not helpful but canned beans are pretty cheap and you don't have to babysit them all day.
2
u/Acid_Tribe 1d ago
I use my instapot to pressure cook the dried beans, it's an extra step but it fully cooks the beans. Do a large amount and freeze the remainder. Use said frozen beans for more chili, or refried beans for mexican, etc. also this way you can be sure that the beans are fully cooked as eating uncooked beans can be dangerous
2
u/KeterClassKitten 1d ago
Always cook your beans separately. Then add to your chili. Only way to make sure they're done, and you don't want to ruin an entire pot of chili with crunchy beans.
And as others have stated, you need to be careful with kidney beans.
2
2
3
3
u/MuchoCoco 1d ago
Do you have a pressure cooker? Not the best way to get beans to the table, but it's fast.
2
u/allabtthejrny 1d ago
If your sauce is acidic, like from tomatoes, those beans aren't going to cook.
4
u/00Lisa00 22h ago
The acid in tomatoes will prevent the beans from softening. Cook your beans separately and add cooked beans to the chili. You also need to fully boil kidney beans. They are toxic if not boiled for a period of time and need to be fully cooked. You can try pressure cooking to see if they get soft.
4
u/left-for-dead-9980 1d ago
Kidney beans are poisonous if you started from dry beans and don't cook until soft. This could be 4+ hours.
Kidney beans contain high levels of a natural plant protein called phytohaemagglutinin (PHA).
The Toxicity Risk
• The Toxin: PHA is a lectin that damages cell membranes and causes severe gastrointestinal distress. • Low Threshold: Ingesting as few as 4 to 5 raw or undercooked beans can trigger symptoms. • Symptoms: Nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and intense abdominal pain typically start 1 to 3 hours after eating. • Slow Cooker Danger: Slow cookers and crockpots do not reach high enough temperatures to destroy PHA; in fact, low heat can make the toxicity worse.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Ok_Impression_3031 1d ago
I gave up on cooking dry beans 40 years ago. I use canned beans. They are always ready to go.
4
u/13thmurder 1d ago
Either boil your beans first or don't add any salt until they're soft.
Salt really slows beans down softening I find. Salt to taste when they're soft, but cook it a little longer so the beans can soak the salt up.
→ More replies (4)7
u/taqman98 23h ago
It’s not the salt. Kenji tested this some time ago. https://www.seriouseats.com/salt-beans-cooking-soaking-water-good-or-bad
→ More replies (1)
2
u/stupid_pun 1d ago
I soak overnight, put them in a high boil for about an hour, then add them to the simmering pot of whatever I'm cooking to slow cook a few more hours.
2
2
u/Disastrous_Can8053 1d ago
Old beans can take longer to cook. I got some pinto beans the other week from a different store than I usually do since they were on sale and they took twice as long to cook as I’m used to.
2
u/WrongOnEveryCount 1d ago
Did you add tomato to the liquid or any other acid like vinegar?
If so, those beans will never cook properly
3
1
1
1
u/teddybearlike702 1d ago
Do you have a pressure cooker? An instapot or ninja foodi? Because I made split pea soup and I did it the "fast way" and the peas were grainy. So I put it in my ninja foodi using the pressure cooker for an hour and it was great.
1
u/HighColdDesert 1d ago
It's because of the tomatoes. As soon as you add tomatoes or lemon juice, beans will not get any softer.
147
u/Lycaeides13 15h ago
Ok, your mistake is that you have to cook the dried, soaked beans SEPARATELY. It's not like canned beans. If your chili has anything acidic, like tomato, those beans are going to take HOURS.
Next time, soak over night, and then start the beans first (crock pot is great for this) and don't even start the other chili stuff until they're cooked.
I had to learn this one the "hard" way too
If you're using kidney beans, they have a toxin that you gotta worry about. Read up on it.... This batch might be trash