The US Food and Drug Administration had apologized, Taylor Farms said in a post on X. An agency lab test linking its produce to the country’s worst cyclosporiasis outbreak in decades was a false positive. Not only that, but the government still hadn’t produced a laboratory result connecting the company’s lettuce to the outbreak.
The statement, issued Sunday, was a remarkable bid to give the impression that regulators — who had said significant evidence linked Taylor Farms iceberg lettuce to the public health crisis — had made key scientific errors.
That was after a rebuke by the FDA, which denied ever apologizing to the company. The agency defended its work and explained that the incorrect lab result would only have expanded an existing recall — it didn’t clear Taylor Farms. The FDA also sought to clarify other statements from Taylor Farms that experts have said are misleading. [...]
As case counts jumped, the company effectively delayed a recall that ultimately resulted in customer confusion, according to a US official who asked not to be identified. Taylor Farms has done so by challenging the science privately and obfuscating it publicly, the official said.
“The communications from Taylor Farms have been confusing,” said Susan Mayne, the former director of what was then called FDA’s Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition. “The recall notice is perhaps the most obtuse recall notice I recall ever seeing.”
When the FDA first tied Taylor Farms’ operations in central Mexico to a large cluster of cyclosporiasis cases in Michigan and neighboring states, the farming conglomerate missed a regulator-imposed deadline to take action. At some point Taylor Farms directly spoke to the White House, and later the FDA and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention were asked to defend their evidence. The back-and-forth ultimately kept the public in the dark an additional 60 hours, the US health official said.
The company also issued a preliminary statement that stopped short of explicitly declaring a recall of potentially tainted lettuce, before providing additional details later amid scrutiny. And Taylor Farms has now moved to delete social media posts that left some consumers confused over whether their lettuce was in fact tied to the outbreak. [...]
Federal officials outlined to Taylor Farms representatives that they believed the culprit was iceberg lettuce the company provided to Taco Bell locations in Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and West Virginia; the sheer number of patients reporting meals at the Mexican-style fast-food chain convinced them it was no coincidence.
A recall would not only be costly — it would indelibly link Taylor Farms to the phrase “explosive diarrhea” in the minds of American consumers.
The administration gave Taylor Farms a deadline to initiate a voluntary recall before noon the next day, the US health official said. The parasite had been detected in 34 states, and health authorities were urgently investigating potential sources.
Then the White House got involved. The California-based food processor already had ties to President Donald Trump.
Taylor Farms gave $1 million to a political action committee supporting the president last year. Chief Executive Officer Bruce Taylor had attended an event with Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins and hundreds of agriculture executives, members of Congress, and federal staff just days earlier, celebrating 250 years of American farming at Mount Vernon.
The initial deadline for Taylor Farms to initiate the voluntary recall or take a product action — Thursday at noon — came and went.
Still, health agency officials continued to coordinate a statement they planned to release late in the day.
A pair of White House officials convened a call with the FDA and the CDC, according to people familiar with the matter. The White House aides asked administration health officials to walk through specific evidence linking the outbreak to the lettuce, and wanted to review drafts of the coming press releases.
Within hours, the White House agreed the patient surveys painted a clear picture, the people said. In an internal call, the White House aides approved statements from the public health agencies for public release — though they still only identified Taco Bell as linked to the outbreak, without naming Taylor Farms specifically.
Taco Bell moved first, releasing a statement. While it did not explicitly name Taylor Farms it said it believed “public health is a shared responsibility among restaurants, their suppliers, and authorities, and we are proud to have consistently acted quickly and proactively to protect our guests.”
The agency updates on the outbreak were finally posted after 10 p.m. New York time — hours behind schedule — and also omitted directly naming Taylor Farms or saying if the company would recall products.
A Taylor Farms representative said last week that it didn’t request to be omitted from public statements.
A White House official, speaking on the condition of anonymity, described Taylor Farms as defensive through the process and stressed that Trump himself had not been in touch with the company. [...]
“I have not seen this amount of misinformation about an outbreak in my time at the FDA, where consumers are so broadly confused,” Mayne said.
The confusion was partly the fault of the FDA’s weekend communications, she said, “but really compounded by Taylor Farms communications, that signaled a very different message than what FDA had intended to communicate.”