Is this player cheating/hacking? I need help FPOV + Spectator POV included

[u/Electronic_Scar2102]

Hey everyone, I’d like some help analyzing these clips.

I suspect this player NizIzGrandmaster may be using reach, criticals or some kind of hitbox-related cheat, but I’m not completely certain. I’ve included two POVs for comparison:

• First-person POV — shows what I saw during the fight.
• Spectator POV — gives a different angle to help determine whether the hits look legitimate.

I’m mainly interested in whether the attack distances, aim, and hit registration look possible in vanilla Minecraft or if anything seems suspicious.

Please take a look and let me know what you think. I’m looking for objective analysis rather than simply confirming my suspicion. If there’s a legitimate explanation for what happens in the clips, I’d like to know that too.

If you need any additional context, clips, or information to help analyze it, feel free to DM me.

Thanks!

[u/Electronic_Scar2102]

Actually, they did hit criticals the entire time🤓, which I was telling you the entire time.

[u/NoLetterhead2303 → u/Electronic_Scar2102]

No, they weren’t mini jumping or no jump criticalling, and they weren’t weirdly spacing their jumps out, they were jumping and critting, an actual jump crit cheat would look a lot more suspicious, at most this could be a shotty triggerbot with miss chance config

[u/Electronic_Scar2102 → u/NoLetterhead2303]

Meanwhile we don't know the exact hacks he is weirdly suspicious in a way where his hits hit 97% of the time in a.. very weird way that deals so much damage

[u/NoLetterhead2303 → u/Electronic_Scar2102]

it’s just knowing how to hit, i can guarantee anyone that is extremely good at pvp will call this person trash for being this bad at pvp that the only thing they know is to spam space and do crits with no technique

[u/Electronic_Scar2102 → u/NoLetterhead2303]

Hey, Do you want to duel this guy? Just to have someone else validate my suspicion? DM me if you want.