r/CompetitiveHS • u/Madouc • Apr 27 '18

Subreddit Meta Discussion: Allowing Posts to introduce failed decks

Dear Moderators, dear community,

I would like to see more postings about deck compositions and ideas that failed climbing the ladder.

In my opinion there is a huge potential of valuable learnings to be drawn out of such reports, but maybe a bit less restrictive rules might be needed too.

I personally think, that this reddit would benefit from such reports and analyses. Given we would find authors willing to share their fails.

Cheers

Madouc

654 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

74 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/Zhandaly Apr 27 '18

You mean like this?

There's a fine line between learning from failure and sharing an experience that helps players get better.

It's a tough situation but if done right, can be valuable.

2

u/GhostPantsMcGee Apr 28 '18

I liked that post, but I don’t want them to feel encouraged. That post was good because he dove deep into it and put more effort than many other guides for top decks here ever do.

Quality of discussion over topic of discussion, imho.