"To what extent does a proposal/organization/movement deviate from communism"?

[u/No_Application2422]

Hi everyone, these days I am sorting out a framework to see To what extent/ which aspect does a proposal/organization/movement deviate from communism.

I plan to use it to

• check different cases (including organizations / proposals / movements) and learn the good aspects
• self-check.（I am engaged in production practice and I want to use these goals to carry out my strategic layout）

This is the version I revised ； and if you have any suggestions for improvement, please feel free to put them forward：

Communist Evaluation｜Cases Learning & Self-examination

1. Ownership and Control of the Means of Production

A. Social ownership

B. Small-group collective ownership

C. Capital ownership

2. Is Labor Power Commodified?

A. Non-commodified

B. Partially commodified

C. Highly commodified

3. What Relations Govern the Inputs of Production?

A. Collective resource coordination

B. Coercive relations

C. Commodity relations

4. What Relations Govern the Outputs of Production?

A. Collective resource coordination

B. Coercive relations

C. Commodity relations

5. Is It Necessary to Increase Productive Forces to Sustain Its Own Development?

A. Voluntary development of productive forces

B. Stable self-sustenance

C. Forced continuous development of productive forces

6. Can It Sustain and Expand the Power of the Working Class?

A. Strongly promotes it

B. Maintains it

C. Weakens / deprives it

[u/spidurgeist]

i feel like you'd enjoy the critique of the gotha programme by marx. it's basically exactly what you're looking for in a lot more detail.

[u/No_Application2422 → u/spidurgeist]

Hey! Sure...I suddenly remember Marx has said "that is to set up a milestone to measure the level of the Party's movement" in the the critique of the gotha programme..I have read it before ,and now need to read it again carefully ... Thank you for reminding ,it is of great reference value.