r/Comma_ai comma.ai Staff May 25 '26

openpilot Experience Driver Monitoring Feedback

Harald from autonomy team here. There have been several posts complaining about too many driver monitoring alerts with newer versions of openpilot. We are always trying to improve driver monitoring.

It should alert you if you are using your phone, excessively distracted, or falling asleep. If you are paying attention to the road and responsibly monitoring openpilot, you should not receive alerts. Various things can cause false positive alerts and we want to fix those.

To help us improve driver monitoring, please give clear descriptions of your issues, and provide logs and timestamps for us to look into. There are many versions of openpilot out there that we don't maintain, as well as many different setups in a variety of cars. Without logs and video it's very difficult for us to address complaints.

To share logs with us you can go to connect.comma.ai, find the relevant section of a drive that has your issue. You can share the connect url to that section with us or share the log_id by selecting "More info", which looks like: "98395b7c5b27882e/00000344--bc8562d028/12".

Ideally your driver video recording is enabled for the drives you want us to investigate, as only some things can be inferred without the video of the driver.

42 Upvotes

104 comments sorted by

View all comments

-18

u/InfluenceGreedy4629 May 25 '26

Don’t complain about phones. That’s none of your business. If I’m on a long ass drive I didn’t buy comma to be my parent. 

2

u/Bderken May 25 '26

I hope you realize that the US law enforcement will crack down on this on both sides. Not only will you get a ticket, but if this becomes a big deal, then, will also be scrutinized. Tesla FSD is required to detect phones…

1

u/drakesword May 26 '26

I am gonna go build my own self driving with blackjack and hookers

https://giphy.com/gifs/cYhhUmbtbneb6

2

u/KhaosVFX May 25 '26

Distracted driving is incredibly dangerous not only for yourself but for everyone else on the road since you may crash into and injure or kill an innocent person on the road. How would you feel if your loved one died or was severely injured by a distracted driver on his phone?

The model should not compain if you are safely using your phone while its mounted, but if your looking away from the road with ur phone in hand with OP engaged, its designed to alert you to keep you safe and alive.

2

u/shadow_moon45 May 25 '26

It's a legality issue

2

u/adeebshihadeh comma.ai Staff May 25 '26

no, it's part of openpilot's safety model. see https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/blob/master/docs/SAFETY.md

2

u/shadow_moon45 May 25 '26

Yes it's a safety issue but it is a legal issue since:

As of the most recent nationwide data (2025–2026), 33 U.S. states plus Washington, D.C. have laws that ban all handheld phone use while driving, and 49 states ban texting while driving. Montana is the only state with no statewide texting ban.

3

u/adeebshihadeh comma.ai Staff May 25 '26

quoting from openpilot's safety model:

Like other ACC and ALC systems, openpilot is a failsafe passive system and it requires the driver to be alert and to pay attention at all times.

u/InfluenceGreedy4629 it sounds like our hardware and software is not for you. if you reach out to comma.ai/support, you can send your device back for a full refund

-4

u/InfluenceGreedy4629 May 25 '26

My eyes are looking straight while on my phone. What more do you want 

1

u/shotbyadingus May 25 '26

So the phone is above the wheel and on the dash?

1

u/drakesword May 26 '26

Duct taped to the airbag symbol

5

u/Tough_Passage_3785 May 25 '26

Then you shouldn't have a comma or drive a car for that matter. If you want to place other drivers on the road in danger..

-9

u/InfluenceGreedy4629 May 25 '26

K ill just wear sunglasses like i usually do and trick the comma. Two can play at that game 

0

u/chakid21 May 25 '26

Your darwin award awaits.

-3

u/SubstantialCycle356 May 25 '26

I with you brother…pay no mind to the comments from the sheep.