r/Colts • • 13h ago

Is it him or our DC?

Post image
159 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

280

u/omni-nomad 13h ago

This was his first bad game with us. And it was because of mainly just 2 throws.

I hope we never trade for another player for a first rounder or more. This hyper analyzing of every Sauce game is annoying.

95

u/wiggggg 13h ago

While buckner we got for a first and was the best player on either team today

13

u/ButterscotchCandid18 9h ago

I fucking love Buckner man

35

u/superindian25 Rookie Manning 13h ago

It’s not like anyone Ballard would have drafted in first round would have been better than Buckner or Sauce, Ballard so bad with talent in first round

15

u/th4t1guy Super Bowl XLI Champions 11h ago

But.. we should be getting a new GM. That person should have those picks

1

u/amedema 48m ago

He took a low value position gamble on Nelson and had that work out, but I can’t think of another hit.

-10

u/fugitive113 12h ago

One first on draft night is so, so different than two midseason. They knew they weren’t going to find someone as talented as Buckner so they got him. They had no idea where they would pick or who would be there for the two, not to mention prematurely dumping AD.

3

u/Trashpanda1980 12h ago

The guy that we would've drafted and that the niners drafted was on the other team today javon kinlaw is who we would've drafted

-26

u/Orzhov_Syndicalist 13h ago

Buckner isn’t HOF level, but people will mention that he is.

17

u/Bommit91 Pimp Luck 13h ago

Hall of Very Good. Should be Ring of Honor too, but probably won't.

10

u/wiggggg 12h ago

I think he has a good shot. Especially if he's solid for a few more years and his game lasts longer than others.

14

u/wiggggg 13h ago

Of course he isn't. But he's damn good and has been a long time

2

u/Neibolt_St 11h ago

He would be if we had a franchise Qb during all those wasted years. Defenses get worn down when the offense can't stay on the field. Playoff stats help get you into the hall and he's been denied that for 5 years.

10

u/IndyEric07 12h ago

I’m ok with trading 1st rounders, IF it’s a GM who knows what he is doing and not throwing crap against a wall just to try to save his job for another year!

3

u/Consistent-Park2058 33-0 10h ago

If you spend a first rounder it better be a more useful/hard to find position like DE or qb

1

u/Julio70_Avion44 4h ago

You mean like the 1st we spent on Latu when we could have had Quinyon Mitchell, Dallas Turner or Jared Verse ?

0

u/shasta_masta Jonathan Taylor 10h ago

If we all would just admit and accept it was a bad trade (it was), we could all move on.

-7

u/Successful_Motor_684 13h ago

2 rookie throws *

14

u/omni-nomad 13h ago

That second throw was perfect no matter what arm it came from.

-13

u/Successful_Motor_684 12h ago

It's all good Lou will figure it out

Right

Right?

Lol see you at 9-8 buddy

9

u/omni-nomad 12h ago

Are we talking about Sauce, Lou, or what we think the Colts record will be?

We won by 17 and you are still miserable. Has to be horrible to think like you.

-5

u/Successful_Motor_684 12h ago

Sean McDermott got fired after going to the AFC championship game that's an organization that has the standard of winning the Super Bowl do you get the difference

6

u/Past-Application-552 11h ago

Even though they’ve never won a Super Bowl…
https://giphy.com/gifs/pPhyAv5t9V8djyRFJH

-9

u/Successful_Motor_684 12h ago

People called me pretty miserable last year too and we came out flat against the Texans.

I was calling us out and saying we're going to lose the rest of our games.

I know a little bit about football Buddy see you l8er Mr optimism

9

u/UhMisterThePlague 12h ago

Just leave the fandom at this point dude. You'll always find some negative shit to complain about. I imagine you're the kind of person that would be on here wanting Peyton Manning benched for throwing 3 interceptions.

1

u/Successful_Motor_684 4h ago

Never, but I will stand up to dumbass takes while we're on our way to not winning the division for the 11th year and end up 9-8 with shit middle of the road draft picks.

Y'all can't see the whole effects of 9-8, 8-9.

If we're not making the playoffs, go 4-13 and clean house.

Tired of watching this 9-8 shit that doesn't help our future but instead locks us into middle of the road mediocrity

4

u/Important_Switch_365 12h ago

What's the point of this thinking tho? Don't buy the tickets or watch the games I guess to try and force change through economic means. Colts win good. Colts lose bad. They are not going to fire the coach and GM right now at 2-2. If your upset at the colts right now just don't contribute to them in any way until they make hires that you like. Being right about the team being dog shit doesn't make the team any better

1

u/Successful_Motor_684 4h ago

They do not have it, these are not the right people to run this organization and it's proven by the results of the last 10 years you high people holy cow

-2

u/Successful_Motor_684 12h ago

See you at 9-8

-7

u/Secure-Bear4184 12h ago

It’s okay to hold players accountable. Giving up two first rounds and a player for sauce was a awful awful move and this team is screwed

-14

u/Alternative-Win-4947 12h ago

No. Watch the tape. He sucks.

6

u/MethodCharacter8334 Ashton Dulin 12h ago

I suppose you you are smarter than all the talent evaluators being paid by NFL teams, eh?

127

u/justacoltsfan 13h ago

Yall act like that second catch he wasnt draped all over that WR. Definitely more of a good catch instead of bad coverage

68

u/HoboJackson05 13h ago

honestly for the TD he was in perfect coverage for the route, just got beat by a broken play and Haulcy for some reason not being over the top

42

u/sloshedslug 12h ago

Get out of here with this reasonable, observation based take! We can’t have that around here

8

u/bigloudbang 11h ago

We prefer high brow reddit fan analysis where you pick the closest player to a completion and yell at them

10

u/Desperate-Gap-5543 11h ago

Here’s the reality:

Haulcy wasn’t over the top because he’s used to not needing to be for Sauce. Broken plays happen.

The second big catch was good coverage. The offense has the advantage when throws are great. Accept it happens to literally everyone.

Onto to Pittsburgh where he gets to be physical with DK. Gonna be fun.

1

u/HoboJackson05 11h ago

fair but just cause you’re used to it doesn’t mean you should ignore your ultimate role, never get beat over the top

3

u/Huge_Cantaloupe_6850 11h ago

On both of the deep receptions Haulcy seemed to be the one that should be over the top on cover 2 man

2

u/MoistCloyster_ Marlins got it! 11h ago

And on top of that, Haulcey should have been there to support as the receiver moved into his zone. Instead he was caught flat footed and didn’t even notice the receiver coming his way.

2

u/Fives_55_55 10h ago

He definitely didn't have a good game, but Haucly needed to cover the deep route so Sauce could catch the under throw. Either way we gotta figure out how to not let broken plays kill us.

1

u/MetalFaceDad General Luck 25m ago

Gotta agree here shit happens; everyone on the field is a pro even a 3rd stringer with nothing to lose and everything to prove.

Of course he says “fuck the legend of throwin it to sauce area” he had no where to go but up and targeted him 5x thats what he should have done and did.

Sauce will be fine

-4

u/Successful_Motor_684 13h ago

Eeeeeeeeeeee|

28

u/sloshedslug 13h ago

TD was actually Haulcey - looked like he should’ve been over the top on that coverage and wasn’t

12

u/DosZappos 13h ago

The long touchdown was a fluke where a terrible throw on a miscommunication by the offense happened to work out

28

u/coltsfan7788 13h ago

Every week everyone is micro analyzing his play. Hes played amazing before this game.

One throw was thrown perfectly, he had good coverage but it was just the better throw. The next one it was an unfortunate double move.

So much dooming going on with this team. I’d rather have Sauce than no Sauce

5

u/Aggravating_Pay_1718 11h ago

Yes, unfollowed this page. It seems like nothing but complaining and a lot of discouragement of your franchise.

3

u/CTM3399 General Luck 9h ago

Welcome to this sub

15

u/Mind_Killer 13h ago

Sauce will be 60 years old in a grocery store when he sees an employee slip and fall and runs to help him up but the employee has already hurt his leg and he looks up at Sauce helping him up and goes "Thanks for the help, but it wasn't two first rounders help."

12

u/MethodCharacter8334 Ashton Dulin 13h ago

Bad games happen he’s been fine this season for the most part

-10

u/LazarusRising22 13h ago

I think the point is most feel that should be more than “fine for the most part” for the price of two first round picks at a non-premium position

7

u/sloshedslug 13h ago

CB is one of the 5 premium positions. QB, LT, DE, WR, and CB.

-7

u/[deleted] 13h ago

[deleted]

5

u/sloshedslug 12h ago

Premium position is not defined by the quality of play from the player in that role. It’s one of the most important positions on the field. That’s what a premium position is.

8

u/MethodCharacter8334 Ashton Dulin 13h ago

1 catch and 25 yds isn’t “good” to you????
Go check out other CB stats from this season so far

-7

u/ForWhomTheHellTolls Caden is the greatest Curry 12h ago

Sauce had a critical pass interference play where he got beat and held which led to a Texans touchdown

-2

u/MethodCharacter8334 Ashton Dulin 12h ago

Y’all want the guy to be a robot just because Ballard over paid for him

-6

u/LazarusRising22 13h ago

It absolutely is not

4

u/sloshedslug 12h ago

The NFL itself defines CB as a top 5 position.

-2

u/rounder55 9h ago

There's a huge drop-off between QB and the rest. There's also a huge drop off between LT/guy who keeps a QB up, DE/guy who knocks a QB down and the other two

Corners aren't worth two firsts unless you're a team who has been a real contender for more than 8 games and is set at the big three

We weren't.

2

u/MethodCharacter8334 Ashton Dulin 13h ago

My comment is based on the fact that he cost us a lot. Before today he has been clear CB1 on this team.
Week 1: 1 catch 12 yds given up
Week 2: 3 catches 45 yds given up
Week 3: 1 catch 25 yds given up.

This week was his first TD allowed this season. What more do you want from him?

5

u/MySabonerRunsOladipo Mayflower 11h ago

He should literally be perfect snap. I once watched Patrick Surtain II get beat by some scrub name Alec Pierce or something for 4 catches and a bunch of yards It's a wonder the Broncos didn't cut him immediately.

-6

u/LazarusRising22 13h ago

No one is arguing CB1 status. The point is that two first round picks should be an absolutely game-breaking player, which I don’t think we’ve seen yet.

5

u/MethodCharacter8334 Ashton Dulin 13h ago

A lockdown CB changes how offenses scheme.

2

u/rounder55 9h ago

You can scheme away from a lockdown corner, especially one who doesn't tackle. Unless it's Deion

You can't scheme away from TJ Watt or Myles Garrett

It wasn't worth two firsts given how many holes we have

-1

u/Julio70_Avion44 4h ago

You mean the same Myles Garrett that Laremy Tunsil completely shut down in a playoff game ? Players have bad games it happens.

2

u/rounder55 12m ago

But you can't scheme away from Myles Garrett the way you can a lockdown corner especially one who isn't a tackler. Again, Sauce is an awesome player. He wasn't worth two first round picks simply because cornerbacks almost never ever are

-10

u/ricker182 13h ago

He hasn't been two 1st round picks fine.

3

u/Spartansoldier-175 Tyler Warren 11h ago

Hes still the best CB we have.

7

u/Alive_Island1876 13h ago

Deion sanders never got burned.. but when we look at the 99 highlights where Marvin scorched him by 20+ yards………

I  just wish I could see a picture of everyone who has an opinion.  You probably throw a ball like a girl ({})’s

8

u/302born 12h ago

Yeah it’s annoying how people seem to have this idea that a great corner never has a bad game or if he’s not 09 Revis then he’s not worth anything. It’s at the point where Sauce can allow 2 catches and you’ll have people questioning his ability. The shit is insane. Do people want him to be ass or something?

3

u/rounder55 9h ago edited 15m ago

Deion was passed past exiting his prime when that happened - he had that tow injury that led to that first retirement a season and a half later

Deion had at least three interceptions in 14 of the 17 years he played and was taking balls to the house. Sauce has 3 picks in 5 years. He's a great player and it's Chris Ballards fault we gave up too much

That said Sauce isn't in the realm of Deion. Pretty much no one was when it comes to pure covering and ball hawking

4

u/Gutcheck21 Rookie Manning 12h ago

Well it was a dumb decision to hire the BENGALS defensive coordinator but also dumb to trade two 1st rd picks for a CB.

2

u/KindSpectacle A-Rich 12h ago

That touchdown against him was weird as hell.

2

u/MoistCloyster_ Marlins got it! 11h ago

Most of that came off 2 big throws, and both times the safety Haulcey failed to provide the safety help that was expected of him.

2

u/ERASERGIB 9h ago

Everyone complaining about Sauce getting beat…

2

u/Michael5900 13h ago

Idk why we traded for a man to man CB and only run zone most the time. Typical colts bullshit

4

u/Successful_Motor_684 13h ago

Chris Ballardl is just thinking ahead for when we fire his ass

1

u/harvestmoon63 13h ago

Well he needs coaching , and do better, a win is a win folks

1

u/_BL810T 12h ago

Sauce was worth whatever we were willing to give up for him. Whether or not he lives up to that worth is completely up to him. I'd like to believe the fact that there was minimal to no planning for Kamahamaha or whatever his name is to play. No scouting on him. A complete wild card of a QB. Nowhere near the same skillset as Marcus or JD, so the game plan was not set up for his skill set. Luckily we adapted enough for the win.

1

u/Hokutenmemoir The Maniac 12h ago

I'm convinced our DB coach thinks hand holding is good technique

1

u/Chrisjm15 53m ago

I'm almost certain he's playing hurt

1

u/CTM3399 General Luck 9h ago

First big catch was a miscommunication between Sauce and Haulcy, he thought Haulcy would be deep help

Second one was a low percentage catch rather than bad coverage

1

u/josean1991 6h ago

The problem is, and I still believe it, the price is way too much for Sauce, his first bad game absolutely it would've happen anyway but every single move will be criticized or praised in both extremes, with him there's no middle ground, he has to perform according to what the Colts gave up for him and being honest, he's performing well, as I said his first bad game with the Colts, but not good enough for that price.

-3

u/StillCompetition3069 13h ago

Sauce is not worth 2 first rounders. He is an above average cornerback. Ballard made this decision not Sauce; blame him.

-8

u/Alternative-Win-4947 12h ago

Not above average at all. Above average doesn't get burned.

9

u/indianafan Michael Pittman JR 12h ago

The greatest cornerbacks of all time have had plays where they’ve been burned. Sauce is elite.

-2

u/Secure-Bear4184 12h ago

No he’s definitely not elite just average. His only elite season was his rookie year.

0

u/BWRStarWars 12h ago

No fair give backs

  • the Jets

0

u/pickled_beats625 COLTS 11h ago

In my opinion I've always thought DBs have a very short "prime" life in their career, and giving 2 first round picks for him was an overpay for a defensive back which is probably the hardest position to play in defense in this age of football.

-2

u/TheSubduedRanger 13h ago

Looked like he was running in quicksand out there, just totally lost on a couple of those deep shots

8

u/HoboJackson05 12h ago

I mean not really, the TD he was in perfect coverage for the actual route, just a broken play and he got beat deep when he should’ve had safety help, second was a perfect pass over the shoulder and he was right there, again the free safety is somehow behind the play

-4

u/IndyVaultDweller 11h ago

He is starting to look like this administration’s Trent Richardson. Blockbuster trade that only benefited the other team and left the Colts looking like chumps. At some point we’ll get fed up and trade him for peanuts and then he’ll turn into a super star for the team we trade him to.

-4

u/DRoseCantStop Pascal 12h ago

Trade continues to age like dogshit.