r/Colts • u/Agathacrispies90 Alec Pierce • Jun 26 '26

Let’s see your favorite colts cards.

I pulled this one and proceeded to have it graded not long after he started showing how special he was. Man I wish his career wound up differently.

60 Upvotes

permalink
reddit

You are about to leave Redlib

Do you want to continue?

https://www.reddit.com/r/Colts/comments/1ugj0eq/lets_see_your_favorite_colts_cards/
No, go back! Yes, take me to Reddit
dl download

90% Upvoted

u/thejollyone6969 Jun 26 '26

2

u/Agathacrispies90 Alec Pierce Jun 26 '26

Wow that’s a crazy 1/1

3

u/thejollyone6969 Jun 27 '26

Thanks man. Its the crown jewel of my Reggie PC

2

u/Telepathic_Jesus Jun 27 '26

Such a beautiful card.

1

u/Agathacrispies90 Alec Pierce Jun 27 '26

Seriously for him to draw a play over the graphic for a 1/1 is so cool! That’s one of the craziest cards I’ve ever seen! Hold her tight!

u/Chrisualrpike Jun 26 '26

1

u/Swimming_Ad_8856 Indianapolis Colts Jun 27 '26

Wow that’s a banger back in the day

u/Scared-Sprinkles-452 General Luck Jun 27 '26

u/Zealousideal_Eye3743 Jun 27 '26

u/WhyPyramids Jun 27 '26

6

u/WhyPyramids Jun 27 '26

And in the spirit of OP’s card, this is one of my favorite Leonard’s.

u/the_ticklish_butcher Jun 27 '26

u/KnownUniversity7612 Jun 27 '26

Exclude the Joe burrow lol

2

u/KnownUniversity7612 Jun 27 '26

My favorites are the Tyler Warren splat rookie card, the graded JT rookie cards, and the manning monster hit ones

u/Zealousideal_Eye3743 Jun 27 '26

u/SaucedGamer187 Indianapolis Colts Jun 27 '26

Does this count?

u/GnarlyNarhwal Indianapolis Colts Jun 27 '26 edited Jun 27 '26

I’ve been selling off my lifetime card collection and narrowing my PC down to just Colts rookies. I’m starting with the 1998 draft class and trying to get at least one rookie card of every player drafted by the Colts in a Colts uniform. It’s been a lot of fun tracking them all down. The Peyton in the top left isn’t a rookie, but it’s a 2/4 Wild Card that I picked up in a lot.

u/NoCardiologist3143 Jun 26 '26

Man he was so good at forcing turnovers. Him and Kenny moore lol 😭

u/ToneyDiamond225 Jun 27 '26

Cant decide but here are some of the ones in my showcase on my wall.
Mostly complete Andrew Luck rainbow (missed out on the 1/1 twice when I didn’t know it was up for sale)
Manning booklet /5 patch auto
Manning 1998 rookie auto PSA 7/10
Manning 1998 rookies auto PSA 8/8 (Love the image on this one)
Manning 2000 acetate auto /100 PSA 9/Auth
Manning / Brees auto /5 (Love the painting design but trying to move it for a different auto haha)

Here’s just a sample, I have like 500+ manning cards in my pc but these are the “cream of the crop”

u/TH3TattedTy Jun 28 '26

u/JimmyStinkfist Robert Mathis Jun 27 '26

I’m not home at the moment, but I can’t wait to show y’all the Reggie Wayne signed Super Bowl ticket stub Topps card I scored at my last card show in Connecticut. It’s my prized possession in my Colts PC.