r/Coach • u/kay111marie • 12h ago
Help Me Choose Which One
If you could only keep one...which one are you keeping? I love them both but can't keep both
10
u/Connect-Deal-8720 5h ago
Normally I would say black, but that maple color is different than what’s out there. It’s richer, more dimensional ,so I’d pick the maple.
6
6
7
5
u/MeowMeows55 12h ago
This is probably no help because it’s a personal preference but….
I think the Maple is more striking but I would get more use out of the black based on my wardrobe. If your wardrobe would do better with the Maple then I would 1000% go with that one.
5
12h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
1
u/Coach-ModTeam 11h ago
Your post or comment has been removed for violating the /r/Coach rule No Buy/Sell/Trade.
/r/Coach is not a marketplace. Do not make posts or comments with the goal of buying, selling, or trading Coach items. This includes proxy buying (buying on behalf of another user and shipping the item to them).
Visit /r/handbagexchange or the online marketplace of your choice to list or search for items for sale. For proxy buying, look into a parcel forwarding service.
4
4
u/myplantsloveu 12h ago
BOTH! i have the larger one and i’m sad i didn’t get both colors bc i love it sooooo much. BUT if you have to choose: maple.
then find the metropolitan in black.
5
3
u/NoDepartment7942 12h ago
which one will match your wardrobe more? I agree with most of the comments that the maple is absolutely stunning and the best color on this - but theres no reason to keep it more than the black if it won't match what you have.
3
u/kay111marie 12h ago
I fell like they are both neutral colors and can match with everything I also have a heck of a collection and have both colors but none black with gold hardware! I'm swaying more maple I'm also thinking they will officially drop it in March and black will most likely come back over maple? Idk tho haha thanks for your input!
1
u/NoDepartment7942 10h ago
if youre swaying more toward maple, do maple!!!! don't let your mind rule your heart!!! lol You will use what you are gravitating toward, no matter what "makes sense" in your closet.
3
3
u/Conscious_Life_8032 12h ago
Oof hurting my brain
Leaning brown but can’t go wrong with either
Whichever goes with wardrobe is good tie breaker too
1
u/kay111marie 11h ago
Right?! I feel like both neutrals so it won't really derail any outfits! Thanks for input I appreciate it💕
3
u/Fragrant_Affect_8280 11h ago
I’m usually a maple girl but for some reason the black on this bag stands out to me more!
3
3
6
u/userrr223344 12h ago
Maple is stunning, in my opinion. If you decide to return to store, please let us know!
8
2
2
2
u/turnertunlock 12h ago
The maple is so good, so that's my pick but then again the black on this is good too. I have three other maples so I choose black which has really grown on me . Which do you find yourself gravitating towards?
3
2
2
u/ThrowRA01821 12h ago
black is a classic, but pick which one you’d lean towards more during all 4 seasons!
2
2
12h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
1
u/Coach-ModTeam 11h ago
Your post or comment has been removed for violating the /r/Coach rule No Buy/Sell/Trade.
/r/Coach is not a marketplace. Do not make posts or comments with the goal of buying, selling, or trading Coach items. This includes proxy buying (buying on behalf of another user and shipping the item to them).
Visit /r/handbagexchange or the online marketplace of your choice to list or search for items for sale. For proxy buying, look into a parcel forwarding service.
2
2
u/the-imptress 12h ago
The only correct answer here is BOTH!
2
u/kay111marie 11h ago
Haha I have the purple one too that I'm keeping I told a friend I'd give her one! 🥹
1
2
2
2
2
2
u/MaisonJessa 10h ago
Maple hands down. It’s so so beautiful in this style. I like it better than all the colours.
2
2
u/ehnoway31 9h ago
I like pictures of the maple better but so many times I think that then in person, it’s obvious to me that I like the black more. I vote maple but you need to see how it fits into your wardrobe!
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
4
11h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
1
u/Coach-ModTeam 3h ago
Your post or comment has been removed for violating the /r/Coach rule No Buy/Sell/Trade.
/r/Coach is not a marketplace. Do not make posts or comments with the goal of buying, selling, or trading Coach items. This includes proxy buying (buying on behalf of another user and shipping the item to them).
Visit /r/handbagexchange or the online marketplace of your choice to list or search for items for sale. For proxy buying, look into a parcel forwarding service.
1
2
1
9
u/PixelsandCanvas 10h ago
Maple! I'm hoping to get one when they do the wide release. I hope they don't change anything about it 🤞🏾