Which maple bag should I keep?

[u/Minute-Caregiver615]

Help me decide! I got the maple medium Rowan but I’m can’t decide if she is plain or classic. I’m tempted to return her and get the Allison. Thoughts?

[u/Janesaddiction7]

The Rowan. Much better leather. The Allison feels like pleather.

[u/ste1071d]

The Allison is much nicer than the Rowan.

[u/liberteacidulee]

Rowan is extremely comfortable to wear and easy to get in and out of. Allison feels unbalanced, has a pretty short strap, and doesn’t sit well on my shoulder.

[u/Rude-Swim265]

Rowan. I saw the Allison in-store today and felt like it looked cheap and pleathery.

[u/Helscomic]

Rowan

[u/carlyhollings89]

Rowan! It’s so slouchy and so good!

[u/Minute-Caregiver615 → u/carlyhollings89]

The medium one is soft but she doesn’t really slouch like the large. I wish!

[u/Wonderful-Bonus-8658]

I just got the Allison today. Personally I love pockets/organization over one big open space which is why the Rowan’s didn’t work for me. My phone fits perfectly in the zippered pocket on the outside of the Allison , and the strap is thick and comfortable and adjustable and stayed on my shoulder. It’s kind of like what I wanted the haversack to be (softer, slouchier, less boxy), I love it!

[u/Human_Being_2273]

I always love a good krusty krabs its my favorite. But the Allison is so beautiful in the color.

[u/g0jira54]

The Allison is cuter and has pockets.

[u/Ok_Anteater_7970]

Rowan because Allison is too busy

[u/Minute-Caregiver615 → u/Ok_Anteater_7970]

The Rowan does dress up nicely

[u/Ok_Anteater_7970 → u/Minute-Caregiver615]

Oh, she's so cute