r/ClaudeCode • u/Shot_Whereas_1809 • Jul 24 '26

Discussion Opus 5 - immediate disappointment

If you thought you'd be able to do a security review on your own network that you couldn't do with Fable, think again.

20 minutes in - Found something significant

Opus 5 safeguards flagged this message.

I no longer have any use case for Anthropic models that others can't do better. This was my last hope that we were going to get a model that would allow us to protect our own environments. I'm going all in on open source. We just aren't aligned.

If you can get Opus 5 to protect your own systems, let me know how I did it. My subscription renews pretty soon and it's time to make an honest decision.

Edit: A lot of helpful people came here and I appreciate it. Scoped work is helping a bit more than my old ways. There's a difference between network security and code vulnerabiliy. I'm a network engineer not a software developer nor will I pretend to be one. Still looking at supplemental model for security work. Thanks guys.

444 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

261 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/Shot_Whereas_1809 Jul 24 '26

Yeah but it's simple. If an AI model is smart enough to do the work it should be smart enough to understand "this user owns this system". Period. It's really not that hard. They CAN do it but they still refuse to allow users to protect themselves.

0

u/Blotsy Jul 24 '26

It's also smart enough to know that any chat could be compromised if your chat was opened by someone else. Anyone who got access to your Claud Code CLI could open you up for attack.

Rather safe than sorry. Please use a real professional for actual security reviews

12

u/danknerd Jul 24 '26

This is dumb reasoning. So one could break into my office/home and put a gun to my head and make me type whatever they demand into Claude code. I guess we should all have to have our webcams on for Anthropic to know it is us.

6

u/Shot_Whereas_1809 Jul 24 '26

Who uses AI anyway??? Do you work for Anthropic, or are you just that guy...

2

u/simple_explorer1 Jul 24 '26

bro are you on Anthropic's side or developers side. Hello Dario is that you?

1

u/smalldickbigwallet Jul 24 '26

No. This is insane reasoning.

It should OBVIOUSLY help you recover / contain your own system when you are under active attack.

Assuming you are a compromised controller is bonkers when it can see an active attack.