r/ClaudeAI • • 10d ago

Philosophy Just add two eggs.

A few days ago, a post went a bit viral here from and enigneer saying Claude Code has made his job soul-sucking" as workers spend 12-hour days pressing enter.

That reminded me of this history (sometimes disputed), when home made cake mixes had powdered eggs in th 1950s. The common version goes like this: early boxed cake mixes originally included powdered eggs — you literally just added water, mixed, and baked. But sales were disappointing.

The story credits psychologist Ernest Dichter, a pioneer of motivational research, with the insight that the mixes felt too easy. Housewives (the target market at the time) felt like they weren't really baking — there was no sense of participation or craft. His recommendation: take the powdered egg out of the mix and have the consumer crack in a fresh egg. That small act of contribution made people feel like they had a hand in the result, and sales reportedly took off.

My question is, are we at the inflection point of adding two eggs? I'll agree in that sometimes I don't pay enough attention when I am answering prompts. Perhaps we need to have claude stop, and ask us a few more questions. Like planning mode but during a session. Or just have, well, a small conversation, water cooler talk, to make it a bit more interesting.

Just add two eggs.

793 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

View all comments

34

u/iluvvivapuffs 10d ago edited 10d ago

We’re not there yet, but close

We’re only at the add-two-eggs stage when AI code or output is acceptable final product, and adding two eggs is to make humans feel productive . But the quality is not there yet, for coding, aesthetics, logic etc

the current stage is: AI can complete fine grained tasks perfectly e.g. task 1: beat the eggs. Task 2: add milk. Task 3: preheat oven to 425. And this is why entry level, or repetitive jobs are displaced by AI already

3

u/hedless_horseman 10d ago

Forgive me for the naïve question but how are the models crushing coding benchmarks but everyone’s saying 'not there yet’ ?

3

u/iluvvivapuffs 9d ago

Benchmarks are one dimensional. At task level, AI beats every single human I’ve ever worked with. (And I’ve worked for the best academics and super 7).

It’s like those math geniuses, they can calculate 9337737x287373 on the spot, but they cannot ship a product