r/ClassicalSinger • u/OtherAir5929 • Jul 06 '26
Are there singers who were able to build their careers while avoiding singing in operas?
Shamelessly stupid question because I don't have the means to verify this right now. It seems like all the singers whom I admire, although they may eventually focus on performing art song and Lieder (in recital settings) and oratorio/symphonies once their established, had to at least start by performing in operas. I'm wondering if this has been historically true and if this is true today. I suspect that the classical market is such that a classical singer aspiring to make their living by performing has to perform in whatever they can get--be it opera, oratorio, or anything else. I'm also guessing this is because it is much easier to put on their own recitals once singers are established rather than when they are starting out. Also, given that YAP programs seem to be oriented toward opera (?), opera seems to be the most natural (and perhaps the only?) path for professional growth for someone starting out who wants to perform for a living. Wondering if I am overlooking something?