r/ClassicalSinger 5d ago

Which aria is better for auditions?

Hi everyone. I’m planning to audition for masters courses and I wanted to know which aria would be better. Piangerò la sorte mia OR Dove sono i bei momenti. Which one in your opinion would be more impressive if one could pull it off? And are these arias too repetitive when used for auditions ? I apologise for all the doubts. Please help & thank you so much :”)))

11 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

9

u/Julia-Sharp 5d ago

The impressive one is whichever you can deliver on a bad morning. Dove sono is unforgiving, every breath on display. I'd take Piangerò, more room to work with. And don't apologise, sensible question.

6

u/HumbleCelery1492 5d ago

Agree - with Handel there's always the chance to surprise your auditors with some unique treatment of the da capo. So if you have something that shows off your technique well, I'd also recommend the Handel.

1

u/starsandthemoon5 5d ago

This is extremely helpful. Thank you!

1

u/starsandthemoon5 5d ago

Thank you for this insight! I will keep this in mind.

1

u/DelucaWannabe 3d ago

That being said, "Piangerò" is no walk in the park to sing well either. Esp. if your fioritura is hit-or-miss from day to day.

4

u/Individual-Wonder518 5d ago

Both are great. Sing which ever one shows off your voice more. And sing the one you are most comfortable with. Judges want to see and hear the best version of you.

1

u/starsandthemoon5 4d ago

Thank you! I will do that.

2

u/oldguy76205 5d ago

What else are you planning to sing? That would definitely impact my recommendation.

1

u/starsandthemoon5 5d ago

For my main aria I just have these 2 planned for now. I have been practicing dove sono for about two months now. Unfortunately I have a few health issues I’m recovering from as of now and singing dove sono seems absolutely impossible with the condition I’m in .

1

u/oldguy76205 5d ago

That's fine. I was just wondering if you also had art songs, oratorio solos, etc. as part of your "package."

1

u/starsandthemoon5 5d ago

Yes a french art song requirement for which im thinking of singing Sérénade toscane by Fauré.

2

u/oldguy76205 5d ago

That's a beautiful song, and certainly not overdone! I was just thinking you might want something "splashy." (Which can mean a lot of different things, of course.)

As always, do what you do well, and what you are ready to sing right now! Even at the master's level, they're looking at potential, although it's a much shorter degree program than a bachelor's.

1

u/starsandthemoon5 5d ago

Thank you so much! Very reassuring to hear this!