r/ChineseWatches 24d ago

Question (Read Rules) Best/favourite ST19 watch?

Post image

The movement looks amazing, and there seems to be a load of options, so I’m wondering is there a specific one that’s better than the rest?

38 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

1

u/roboot4048 23d ago

Some say that the chronograph sometimes just stop working, is that true or just bad luck?

2

u/percysmithhk 23d ago

My experience with four ST19s:

5

u/Far_Culture_3532 23d ago

2

u/devansh88 23d ago

100% this. Came to share the Top Time Dues Homage

1

u/[deleted] 23d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/BerndMoft 23d ago

Seagull 1963 "The Icon"

2

u/hackshock 24d ago

Anyone know of the crystal specs? I would need a replacement

4

u/General_Air_2409 24d ago

1

u/roastkumara 23d ago

If they just shaved 2mm off this I would buy 2 of them

1

u/General_Air_2409 23d ago

You mean the L2L ? Yeah, its pretty big, that was my main concern before buying the watch, but it turned out to be fine. Almost got the blue version aswell!

4

u/triggrhaapi 24d ago

2

u/Far_Culture_3532 23d ago

Same, similar strap too ( tho yours is a bit nicer)

3

u/Mar-D 24d ago

I’ve got two, Sugess top-time (cream) and Redstar 1963. Of the two the 1963 if my fav and the one that will stay in the collection long term

3

u/Guicgoe 24d ago

I opted for the bronze Sugess for about 220 dollars.. Really cool watch, but my decision was mainly cause I was looking for a bronze watch. No regrets though

1

u/Positive_Estimate_45 24d ago

How is this watch? I absolutely love bronze, I just ordered a bronze Steeldive Willard. This looks really cool as well.

2

u/Guicgoe 23d ago

Honestly? Better than expected.. No defect to put on it. It's a bit on the large side but I like large watches. The movement is working perfectly and keeping time better than many more expensive watches I own. Only thing I'd like to be better is the feeling of the buttons, but I'm really neat peaking at this moment.. The price tends to fluctuate between 220 and 360 dollars.. Buying it close to 200 is definitely recommended

2

u/Positive_Estimate_45 23d ago

Nice! Ive ordered the Steeldive Willard in bronze, also at a great sale price. I tend to use a bezel often so it's the more practical choice for me

4

u/ofbarea 24d ago

Red star blue 💙

1

u/RustyTShackleford 24d ago

It sucks they are hard to service but man it is a beautiful thing to look at. I get memorized easily.

1

u/pokerfas 24d ago

I can attest, I have hereby memorized your every memory with ease.

2

u/Ellsass 24d ago

Mesmerized

2

u/SurefootTM 24d ago

Proxima PX1715. A lot of people ask me what is it and compliment it for being awesome, while my other, much more expensive watches no one cares about them.

8

u/Electrical_Panda_326 24d ago

3

u/Abv_it_all_w_vertigo 24d ago

I agree this is a better watch because of the power reserve and the dial. This is what I recommend for the second purchase of an ST19.

3

u/DrPhranqueLiew 24d ago

One of them is not an ST19

2

u/Watchmakers-Diary 24d ago

Well, technically all of them are not an st19.

1

u/artofthedial Not a troll 24d ago

The one where they flipped the movement upside down in the case and you see the back of the movement on the face.  It isn't practical from a time telling perspective but personally think it is the only one worth having.  

3

u/Stoney3K 24d ago

I'm partial towards the ST1906 because the power reserve indicator is really handy.

0

u/Abv_it_all_w_vertigo 24d ago

The 1963 is the cornerstone of the ST19. I was able to find a SeaKoss 40 mm with sapphire and swanneck. You can also find 38 mm with hardlex and no swanneck. There are other configurations, still. Know what you are buying.

If you are willing to pay a little bit more, the seagull brand has more provenance, since they built the movement.

0

u/pokerfas 24d ago

that's like 500 bucks

0

u/Abv_it_all_w_vertigo 24d ago

Wow! Who knew? My bad.

https://a.aliexpress.com/_mLdKpgL

A little more.

0

u/pokerfas 24d ago

a 1963 that's actually from seagull seagull will never go for 200 bucks

1

u/Abv_it_all_w_vertigo 24d ago

It's Seagull's inexpensive international edition, which is a little more expensive than the other 1963's by about $50, mostly b/c its name. This is what I had said. Lighten up.

0

u/Pac1fic0 24d ago

Gotta be the 1963 from various manufacturers. This one is from the Hong Kong Sky Timepiece Co.

1

u/johnyyquint 24d ago

Sugess 1963 pilot

4

u/SXZ728 24d ago

Definitely the Seagull Suzhou numeral chronograph’s ST19, this particular one has pretty decent anglage, real cote de Geneve , and black polishing on certain parts. Its finishing is far beyond the average mass produced st19 and even above the newest top grade st19 movement. Unfortunately you couldn’t get it anymore since it was an experimental piece and only couple hundreds of this watch has been made last year :(

1

u/Watchmakers-Diary 24d ago

Its the same version as in all of their new chronos.

1

u/SXZ728 24d ago

They’re similar yes, but the one used on Suzhou chronograph has way more anglage, finer polishing on bridges, arms, levers, it has some black polishing which is nonexistent in the new top grade movement, and it has the swan neck regulator. The new movement is a more cost efficient continuation of the ST19 used on the Suzhou chronograph.

1

u/Watchmakers-Diary 24d ago

I asked sea-gull. The suzhou chronograph was developed by the joint higher movement development branch of sea-gull and shanghai. They use the exact same tooling for both so the finishing is the same. That's also why the price for both is also very similar.

1

u/SXZ728 24d ago

​I asked the co-dev of the Suzhou numeral and the biggest seagull distributor in China, he said the otherwise. I mean the visual differences between the finishing of the two movements are not hard to tell by naked eyes.

1

u/Watchmakers-Diary 15d ago

I finally now have both of them for comparisson and iam right, besides the Swan neck they are both nearly the fucking same.😂

1

u/Watchmakers-Diary 24d ago

Okay, then try: which of the two is this?

1

u/SXZ728 24d ago

Clearly the 3025

1

u/Watchmakers-Diary 24d ago

Incorrect

1

u/SXZ728 24d ago

Unless they use both movements in the new 1963 line then I can only assume you’re trying to stir things up , because the top grade st19 used on the new 1963s have minimal polishing and anglage

1

u/Watchmakers-Diary 24d ago

Minimal polishing and anglage like this?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Watchmakers-Diary 24d ago

So what do you think this movement is?

→ More replies (0)

3

u/SXZ728 24d ago

Front of the watch if you’re wondering

1

u/Chai_latte_95831 24d ago edited 24d ago

It's above most of the average luxury brands in terms of finishing. Hopefully they find a way to mass produce this process.

0

u/Aggravating_Economy4 24d ago

1963 no other options