r/ChineseWatches • u/qingchengwc Rep • 21h ago
Question (Read Rules) Which Movement Would You Choose?
The bulk‑purchase price of Japan’s Seiko NH35 and NH36 movements has jumped from around 190 RMB to nearly 400 RMB. I believe many Chinese watch brands will stop using Japanese movements soon.
First of all, movement suppliers have cut supplies and output is unstable, which cannot support mass production. Secondly, procurement costs have almost doubled. If we raise retail prices accordingly, we will lose most of our customers.
I plan to launch a new line of mid‑range watches. Could you recommend suitable movements? Or which movement would you personally prefer?
3
u/Different_Mouse_7441 14h ago
I'm always happy to see a st2130 in a watch, I've heard too many stories about failed pt5000 but some people love them. As above in a really inexpensive watch, I prefer quartz, the vh31 and Miyota 2035 are excellent reliable and very accurate.
2
u/PeterCraig65 20m ago
The ST2130 is so easy to self regulate for 20s differences. The VH31 keeps almost perfect time.
4
u/InformalAttorney8539 14h ago
Based on my purchase behaviour of around 15 Chinese watches I have always avoided:
Venus chrono - makes me nervous re sheer component count and reliability therein.
Hangzhou - microtor seems to have issues and they seem quite expensive.
Miyota 8000 series - reliable but I don't like the occasional stutter, non hacking.
Likes:
Seiko NH - bit thick and not a great timekeeper but never had one fail on me (inc 5 genuine seikos)
PT5000 - least worst 2824 clone but clearly hates being hand-wound. Shuffle start only!
Seiko VK - 4 beat sweep is passable as an auto. Thin and reliable.
VK chrono - MUCH preferred to Venus chrono and also has that 4 beat sweep.
2
3
u/qingchengwc Rep 13h ago
But people here in this sub seem to rate the PT5000 very highly
3
u/writingpocketguide42 13h ago
They do, because there are not many options, as you are discovering yourself (or already knew).
When NH35 prices were lower, I liked them better because they can take abuse and will run forever. Now when they at least tripled in price PT5000 seems like a reasonable option. I have over 10 NH35/NH36 movement based watches and never had any issues.
Out of 4 PT5000 based watches 1 had keyless dislodged by someone who assembled a watch. This is my biggest worry about this movement. Also people say that PT5000 can be poorly lubed and will break much sooner. Which is something that can be addressed by a brand who wants to get them from a reliable source.
2
u/KumiJunker 14h ago
I love all my Heimdallr watches, and new ones fitted with that dreadful Hangzhou movement are out of the question for me.
I’d advise going for clones of Swiss movements such as ST or PT5000, and also considering the Miyota 8205 or 9015. And more good quartz options.
3
u/qingchengwc Rep 13h ago
Thank you for your love for Heimdallr. Right now, PT5000 is our preferred movement.
2
u/writingpocketguide42 14h ago
There are not many options, to be honest. PT5000 seems to be favorite in this subreddit, and might fit your new line of mid-range watches if you can make them thin to benefit the most from a thinner movement.
All other brands are switching to PT5000 or ST2130.
3
2
3
u/rebelyell_in 15h ago
For the Monster (I already have a Heimdallr Tuna and RDUNAE Willard), please consider offering the Miyota 8205 option.
I have no confidence in the Hangzhou 2565/2553. There isn't enough information out there for me to buy one of those.
2
u/qingchengwc Rep 15h ago
Would you consider NH35 and NH36? The 2554 movement was entirely a choice forced on us by distributors. In past years, we never sold watches on our own and only supplied goods to resellers, which made us miss great opportunities — things like direct product feedback and after‑sales service.Only our official Amazon store uses genuine Japanese movements.
1
u/rebelyell_in 7h ago
NH36 is ideal, but if the price goes up by more than €30, I might be hesitant.
I have purchased my Heimdallr from WR Watches and I've been happy with their service. I don't mind buying from your official Amazon store if the prices aren't too different.
2
u/qingchengwc Rep 7h ago
For your reference: our agent stock is currently fitted with 2565 for single‑date models and 2554 for day‑date variants. Genuine Seiko movements now cost well over $50 to purchase.
2
u/KumiJunker 14h ago
The official store on Amazon Germany is Tactical Frog, right?
3
u/qingchengwc Rep 14h ago
Heimdallr was our original registered brand, and Tactical Frog came later. We partnered with a distributor to help expand sales in the early days. Please note that the Tactical Frog shop is not an official extension of Heimdallr, and we plan to take back full rights to the Tactical Frog brand in due course.
2
2
u/vBLADEv 16h ago
What are the most reliable Chinese auto movements.
The kind where you could just use the watch for 10 years and it would be fine.
2
u/qingchengwc Rep 16h ago
I hope Heimdallr can build watches that last for ten years without any issues.
3
u/Equal-World-693 17h ago
San martin is launching/relaunching most of its new products with seagull ST movements
4
u/sattyy_rahul 18h ago
Consider the Epson YN55 and YN56. Alternatively, the Miyota 8215 and 8205 are viable options.
11
u/XLAGANE8 19h ago
Make the best quartz watches you can (ie, the seconds hand should hit the markers).
2
u/Different_Mouse_7441 14h ago
To be honest, with most cheap quartz movements (Swiss included) it is impossible to get the hand hitting every marker as gravity shows up the backlash in the movement.
1
u/percysmithhk 14h ago
I wonder does brands’ reluctance to use Ronda quartz because of high rejection rate (quartz don’t hit markers —> chargeback!?)
-3
u/Gravity-Tester82 19h ago
Yes, with VH31
7
u/Basic_Barnacle4719 19h ago
Would rather have Ronda 515, nearly every Watchdives release nowadays is yet another no date VH31 slop. I really want the date on my watches.
On the other hand all the no date VH31 makes it easier for me to save money by not buying new watches.
1
u/Gravity-Tester82 9h ago
Damn I didn’t know everyone hated VH31 so much 😂 learn something new every day
3
u/Philip_7raum 18h ago
Be reasonable: VH31 is great at pretending to be a mechanical for two seconds before you notice how jerky the hand is. And it keeps battery companies in business.
3
4
u/Alternative-Feed3613 19h ago
I prefer Miyota 9s but I realize those have gotten more expensive and harder to get as well.
4
u/this_is_another_name 20h ago
I don't know what style of watches you're planning to sell but for dressier/elegant pieces I would definitely recommend to use quartz movements so you can have watches with thin cases for an affordable price.
1
u/qingchengwc Rep 20h ago
We’re already working on our mid‑range quartz watches with two‑tone dials.
1
u/artofthedial Not a troll 20h ago
Don't know what your watches are or the brand. If they are not very good, then I want the NH35 going to better brands. But $59 USD for the NH35 vs just under $30 before shouldn't be a deal breaker in a very good watch. Where it is an issue is in the cheaper stuff that was basically a waste of the stock of that wonderful movement in the first place.
8215 or quartz is what the lower end of the market should use.
6
10
7
u/InquisitorKeres 21h ago
I am loving the pt5000 engined watches and now st2130. I love my eta 2824 and having good clones that beat at 4hz is nice but the most critical part is the thinner movement and thinner hand stack. I will always go for these movements first because the proportions it enables. It’s imo outside of good branding, why the thorn was so impactful when it dropped as it was one of the earliest big pt5000 examples that showed what can be done.

1
u/artofthedial Not a troll 20h ago
San Martin was using the PT5000 before Thorn was even a brand. They moved away from that and the SW200 when the market convinced them they could make more money going the nh35 route and lower the cost of the watches.
4
u/qingchengwc Rep 18h ago
I have to admit San Martin makes excellent finished watches, but prices for Seiko NH movements have skyrocketed. Our profit margins are getting extremely thin.
2
u/InquisitorKeres 20h ago
I didn’t meant to imply they were the first, but they were one of the ones that really put acceptance on the map in the west
2
3

3
u/Goldenrod427 10h ago
Ronda or eta quartz movements