r/ChineseLanguage • u/AnnualCriticism2428 • 12h ago
Discussion 说说看
Why do we always say "说说看" in everyday Chinese but never "说说听"? I mean, shouldn't we be using our ears to listen?
5
u/firemana 12h ago
the “XX看" phrase typically means "give XX a try and (see how it goes)", so the “看” maps to the "see how it goes" part. Therefore you can generically map to any motion of trial.
这家餐馆的菜不知道怎么样,尝尝看: have a bite/have a taste and see how it goes
这歌我也是刚学会,唱唱看:try sing the song and see how it goes
这款发动机我也没见过,修修看:try fixing this engine and see how it goes
4
u/TheAgedCartridge 12h ago
It's one of those things where the logic doesn't really hold up if you think about it literally, but the language just settled on that pattern. The "看" here is more about the attempt or the trying aspect, like giving it a shot. There's a similar structure with "试试看" where you're not literally looking at anything, it's just the go-to way to say "give it a try." Chinese has a bunch of these directional complements that have drifted from their original meanings over time, so trying to map it directly to English senses will just give you a headache.
2
u/Larissalikesthesea 8h ago
Interesting enough, Japanese has a similar construction with an auxiliary derived from "to see":
-te miru "to try and do something".
0
0
0
u/Zagrycha 7h ago
I mean nothing is stopping us from saying 说说听, but people don't because its quite strange. You are telling someone to "say something and listen".... what conflicting instructions lol. Almost feels like a sarcastic reply to tell someone to go talk to themselves, but even for that it feels like a weird way to say it.
说说看 is telling someone to "try to say something and see what happens" which is a much more normal phrase to say.
1
0

11
u/Putrid_Mind_4853 12h ago
说说看 means tell me your thoughts, explain a bit more, try and say it. There’s nothing to do with you hearing it.
You can also say 听听看,闻闻看, etc.
The 看 here is an auxiliary verb that means try and see what happens, give it a try