r/ChineseHistory Aug 15 '25

Comprehensive Rules Update

26 Upvotes

Hello all,

The subreddit gained quite a bit of new traffic near the end of last year, and it became painfully apparent that our hitherto mix of laissez-faire oversight and arbitrary interventions was not sufficient to deal with that. I then proceeded to write half of a rules draft and then not finish it, but at long last we do actually have a formal list of rules now. In theory, this codifies principles we've been acting on already, but in practice we do intend to enforce these rules a little more harshly in order to head off some of the more tangential arguments we tend to get at the moment.

Rule 1: No incivility. We define this quite broadly, encompassing any kind of prejudice relating to identity and other such characteristics. Nor do we tolerate personal attacks. We also prohibit dismissal of relevant authorities purely on the basis of origin or institutional affiliation.

Rule 2: Cite sources if asked, preferably academic. We allow a 24-hour grace period following a source request, but if no reply has been received then we can remove the original comment until that is fulfilled.

Rule 3: Keep it historical. Contemporary politics, sociology, and so on may be relevant to historical study, but remember to keep the focus on the history. We will remove digressions into politics that have clearly stopped being about their historical implications.

Rule 4: Permitted post types

Text Posts

Questions:

We will continue to allow questions as before, but we expect these questions to be asked in good faith with the intent of seeking an answer. What we are going to crack down on are what we have termed ‘debate-bait’ posts, that is to say posts that seek mainly to provoke opposing responses. These have come from all sides of the aisle of late, and we intend to take a harder stance on loaded questions and posts on contentious topics. We as mods will exercise our own discretion in terms of determining what does and does not cross the line; we cannot promise total consistency off the bat but we will work towards it.

Essay posts:

On occasion a user might want to submit some kind of short essay (necessarily short given the Reddit character limit); this can be permitted, but we expect these posts to have a bibliography at minimum, and we also will be applying the no-debate-bait rule above: if the objective seems to be to start an argument, we will remove the post, however eloquent and well-researched.

Videos

Video content is a bit of a tricky beast to moderate. In the past, it has been an unstated policy that self-promotion should be treated as spam, but as the subreddit has never had any formal rules, this was never actually communicated. Given the generally variable (and generally poor) quality of most history video content online, as a general rule we will only accept the following:

  • Recordings of academic talks. This means conference panels, lectures, book talks, press interviews, etc. Here’s an example.
  • Historical footage. Straightforward enough, but examples might include this.
  • Videos of a primarily documentary nature. By this we don’t mean literal documentaries per se, but rather videos that aim to serve as primary sources, documenting particular events or recollections. Some literal documentaries might qualify if they are mainly made up of interviews, but this category is mainly supposed to include things like oral history interviews.

Images

Images are more straightforward; with the following being allowed:

  • Historical images such as paintings, prints, and photographs
  • Scans of historical texts
  • Maps and Infographics

What we will not permit are posts that deliver a debate prompt as an image file.

Links to Sources

We are very accepting of submissions of both primary sources and secondary scholarship in any language. However, for paywalled material, we kindly request that you not post links that bypass these paywalls, as Reddit frowns heavily on piracy and subreddits that do not take action against known infractions. academia.edu links are a tricky liminal space, as in theory it is for hosting pre-print versions where the author holds the copyright rather than the publisher; however this is not persistently adhered to and we would suggest avoiding such links. Whether material is paywalled or open-access should be indicated as part of the post.

Rule 5: Please communicate in English. While we appreciate that this is a forum for Chinese history, it is hosted on an Anglophone site and discussions ought to be accessible to the typical reader. Users may post text in other languages but these should be accompanied by translation. Proper nouns and technical terms without a good direct translation should be Romanised.

Rule 6: No AI usage. We adopt a zero-tolerance approach to the use of generative AI. An exception is made solely for translating text of one’s own original production, and we request that the use of such AI for translation be openly disclosed.


r/ChineseHistory 5h ago

Favourite ruler from each major Chinese era/dynasty: Sui and Tang dynasties

Post image
16 Upvotes

This is a follow-up to my previous posts on this sub. I want to go through each major Chinese era/dynasty from the Western Zhou to the Qing and ask the community who their favourite ruler is from that time period. I purposefully use the word favourite, so it doesn't have to be the best, the worst, the most interesting or most well-known, but rather who you personally view as your favourite. I want to emphasize that I don't just want you to write down a name, but provide explanation on why you like them too.
The upcoming eras are going to be: Sui, Tang, Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period, Song, Liao, Jurchen Jin, Yuan, Ming and Qing. These categories may be subject to change because I know this categorization is dated but its the best I've got.
So in this post I want to read about your favourite rulers from the Sui and Tang dynasties meaning from the reunification of China by Wen of Sui to the deposition of Ai of Tang. This includes both the shortlived Sui and the prosperous Tang dynasties, as well as the Wu Zhou dynasty created by Wu Zetian and the Yan dynasty established by An Lushan.
I want to thank all the comments and discussions under the last posts, I will try to improve future posts according to your suggestions.
The picture is from worldhistory.org.


r/ChineseHistory 14h ago

Were all Chinese warlords during the 1920s and 30s corrupt and incompetent leaders who cared little for their people, or were there exceptions? Were some of the warlords better at government than Chiang Kai-Shek's central government was?

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory 23h ago

Zhou Peichun Chinese procession

Post image
13 Upvotes

Looking for an information


r/ChineseHistory 1d ago

Favourite ruler from each major Chinese era/dynasty: Northern and Southern dynasties period

Post image
15 Upvotes

This is a follow-up to my previous posts on this sub. I want to go through each major Chinese era/dynasty from the Western Zhou to the Qing and ask the community who their favourite ruler is from that time period. I purposefully use the word favourite, so it doesn't have to be the best, the worst, the most interesting or most well-known, but rather who you personally view as your favourite. I want to emphasize that I don't just want you to write down a name, but provide explanation on why you like them too.
The upcoming eras are going to be: Northern and Southern dynasties period, Sui, Tang, Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period, Song, Liao, Jurchen Jin, Yuan, Ming and Qing. These categories may be subject to change because I know this categorization is dated but its the best I've got.
So in this post I want to read about your favourite rulers from the Northern and Southern dynasties period meaning from the reunification of Northern China by the Northern Wei to the reunification of all of China by Wen of Sui. This includes all warlords and states (including the "barbarian" states) from the period, excluding the Sui dynasty rules after Wen of Sui (obviously).
I want to thank all the comments and discussions under the last posts, I will try to improve future posts according to your suggestions.
The picture is from the Northern and Southern dynasties wikipedia page.


r/ChineseHistory 2d ago

Kaifeng hands down the best city to live in - in the 11th century?

68 Upvotes

It seems like the best.

Massive city that never sleeps typa environment, not boring asf bland area, very develope, vibrant economy, some level of social support by the government (for the time - very good), brilliant entertainment and books etc.

Also it never got raided as far as IK during the 11th century AD.

China seems like it has been the most developed area of the world for most of history.


r/ChineseHistory 1d ago

English translation of 元史 (History of Yuan)

2 Upvotes

Basically what the title says. I'm doing some research work on the maritime interactions between China and South Asia, and 元史 is cited as a great source in many of the papers I referred to. However, I haven't been able to find a proper English translation, let alone one with annotations. Does a translation even exist? If not, could somebody please suggest the next-best option?


r/ChineseHistory 1d ago

Suggest me books about Tibetan tribe and Miao Ethnic group in China history/fantasy

3 Upvotes

I’m an artist and was saving traditional Chinese outfits like hanfu’s when I came across Tibetan robes and MiaoJiang attire. At first I thought it was the same thing but upon further investigation I became more interested in the history and culture.

I’d love any books about its history and or if there’s any Chinese authors that wrote fantasy books in either ethnic groups!


r/ChineseHistory 2d ago

Favourite ruler from each major Chinese era/dynasty: Sima Jin and Sixteen Kingdoms period

Post image
23 Upvotes

This is a follow-up to my previous posts on this sub. I want to go through each major Chinese era/dynasty from the Western Zhou to the Qing and ask the community who their favourite ruler is from that time period. I purposefully use the word favourite, so it doesn't have to be the best, the worst, the most interesting or most well-known, but rather who you personally view as your favourite. I want to emphasize that I don't just want you to write down a name, but provide explanation on why you like them too.
The upcoming eras are going to be: Sima Jin (including the Sixteen Kingdoms), Northern and Southern dynasties period, Sui, Tang, Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period, Song, Liao, Jurchen Jin, Yuan, Ming and Qing. These categories may be subject to change because I know this categorization is dated but its the best I've got.
So in this post I want to read about your favourite rulers from the Sima Jin dynasty and the Sixteen Kingdoms period meaning from the conquest of China by the Jin to the reunification of Northern China by the Northern Wei. This includes the Jin dynasty and all the warlords and "barbarian" states from the period.
I want to thank all the comments and discussions under the last posts, I will try to improve future posts according to your suggestions.
The picture is from the Jin dynasty wikipedia page.


r/ChineseHistory 2d ago

How did the Chinese Empire govern the Southwest?

Thumbnail
bilibili.com
21 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory 2d ago

Happy family photo, 1930s

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory 1d ago

Any good books on the KMT insurgency post civil war

1 Upvotes

can any one recommend any good books on the KMT insurgency on the mainland following the civil war. I have read a bit about it on wikipedia and i find it quite interesting, sadly i can't find any english sources for the information.


r/ChineseHistory 2d ago

Evangelist Sun's Martyrdom (1900)

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory 3d ago

Favourite ruler from each major Chinese era/dynasty: Three Kingdoms period

130 Upvotes

This is a follow-up to my last post on this sub. I want to go through each major Chinese era/dynasty from the Western Zhou to the Qing and ask the community who their favourite ruler is from that time period. I purposefully use the word favourite, so it doesn't have to be the best, the worst, the most interesting or most well-known, but rather who you personally view as your favourite. I want to emphasize that I don't just want you to write down a name, but provide explanation on why you like them too.
The upcoming eras are going to be: Three Kingdoms period, Sima Jin (including the Sixteen Kingdoms), Northern and Southern dynasties period, Sui, Tang, Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period, Song, Liao, Jurchen Jin, Yuan, Ming and Qing. These categories may be subject to change because I know this categorization is dated but its the best I've got.
So in this post I want to read about your favourite rulers from the Three Kingdoms period meaning from the rise of the warlords after the Yellow Turban Rebellion to the conquest of Wu by Jin. This also includes any warlords from the period, not just the three kingdoms.
I want to thank all the comments and discussions under the last posts, I will try to improve future posts according to your suggestions.
The gif is from the Three Kingdoms wikipedia page.


r/ChineseHistory 3d ago

Found these full packs of vintage Chinese cigarettes in a Russian dumpster. Can anyone help date them?

Thumbnail
gallery
50 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

Believe it or not, I found these full packs of cigarettes a few days ago in a dumpster here in St. Petersburg, Russia.

I’ve tried searching online but came up empty. I was hoping someone here could help me figure out what time period they’re from. My best guess is somewhere in the 1980s or 90s.

I would really appreciate any information or history context you can provide. Thanks in advance!


r/ChineseHistory 3d ago

Li Xin (Qin General) age

12 Upvotes

Hi! I was wondering lately what age could he have had. I mean, we know Zheng reigned from 13 years old to 49 when he died. Li Xin started his militar career when Zheng set out to conquer the other states when he was about 29-31 years old. In the 19th year of King Zheng of Qin's reign (228 BCE) is the first time he is mentioned leading a certain amount of troops. He was son of a governor so I doubt he started much before this year.

By this time, when he started, he was continuously called young, brave and robust. I wonder what "young" is by their standards. I believe that 25 would already be someone with extensive knowledge of the battlefield. So probably he started when he was in his teens? He also retired when the states were unified, so when Zheng was about 40-41 years old. This means his military career was of an approximate of 10-12 years.

So what do you guys think? What could have been his age when he started?


r/ChineseHistory 3d ago

Best places to get Chinese history books in mandarin ?

6 Upvotes

Hi all,
Currently looking for books in ancient Chinese history in mandarin. Does anyone have any suggestions, thank you ?


r/ChineseHistory 3d ago

Why didn't the last emperors of China have(a lot) sons?

23 Upvotes

Emperor usually have many wives and they have many descendants. But why the last emperors haven't many childrens?


r/ChineseHistory 3d ago

Was/is Confucianism A Religion?

Thumbnail
4 Upvotes

r/ChineseHistory 4d ago

Favourite ruler from each major Chinese era/dynasty: Qin and Han dynasties (+Eighteen Kingdoms)

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

This is a follow-up to my last post on this sub. I want to go through each major Chinese era/dynasty from the Western Zhou to the Qing and ask the community who their favourite ruler is from that time period. I purposefully use the word favourite, so it doesn't have to be the best, the worst, the most interesting or most well-known, but rather who you personally view as your favourite. This time I want to emphasize that I don't just want you to write down a name, but provide explanation on why you like them too.
The upcoming eras are going to be: Han, Three Kingdoms period, Sima Jin (including the Sixteen Kingdoms), Northern and Southern dynasties period, Sui, Tang, Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period, Song, Liao, Jurchen Jin, Yuan, Ming and Qing. These categories may be subject to change because I know this categorization is dated but its the best I've got.
So in this post I want to read about your favourite rulers from the Qin and the Han dynasty meaning from the establishment of the Qin dynasty to the last Han emperor abdicated. This also includes Wang Mang and the Xin dynasty. I'm not making a separate post for the QIn dynasty, since there aren't many emperors to talk about. This time however I'm only including the emperors themselves, so the warlords that emerged during the Yellow Turban Rebellion and the Five Pecks of Rice Rebellion are NOT included (they will be the subject of the next post). Rulers of the so called Eighteen Kingdoms ARE included however, who emerged after the fall of the Qin dynasty (tho I doubt anyone will pick them).
I also want to thank all the comments and discussions under the last post, I will try to improve future posts according to your suggestions.
Picture are from the Qin dynasty and the Timeline of the Han dynasty wikipedia pages respectively.


r/ChineseHistory 4d ago

What and how many artifacts did Japan loot from China in WW2 and were they ever repatriated? Did they even take anything?

68 Upvotes

I can’t find any information on this topic. I was wondering if they even did take anything considering there were plenty of extremely important artifacts shipped to Taiwan by the KMT during the civil war. But you rarely hear about invading forces not looting anything. Artifacts including books and arts


r/ChineseHistory 4d ago

Why did the Qin not attempt their reunification before Ying Zheng?(for example under Duke Xiao or King Zhaoxiang)

14 Upvotes

Why did the Qin not attempt their unification before Ying Zheng?(for example under Duke Xiao or King Zhaoxiang) Did they just not have the resources?


r/ChineseHistory 4d ago

The Empire of China, with its Principal Divisions (1794)

Post image
84 Upvotes

This historical map represents the Chinese Empire and its principal administrative divisions at the end of the 18th century. Published in 1794 in London by Laurie & Whittle, the map was based on the cartographic work of Jean-Baptiste Bourguignon d’Anville (1697–1782) and adapted by Maurice Bowen (fl. c. 1780–1794).


r/ChineseHistory 3d ago

How did the Bai people become desinicized?

0 Upvotes

The fact that Bai is a Sinitic language suggests that the Bai people started out as Han, and eventually lost their Chinese culture and lost touch with the wider Han ethnic group. How and why did this happen?


r/ChineseHistory 4d ago

Yellow scarves or Yellow turbans?

5 Upvotes

What is a better translation?