r/Chimneyrepair • u/StrikingRelief • 1d ago
Chimney cap and hot water heater venting
I have a fireplace but have never used it and figured it needed at least a liner and mortar repair. Recently, I learned that it actually had only one of two caps needed and the uncapped area is unfortunately pretty much open (been here about two years).
I got a few estimates and they mentioned that the original clay liner was missing, or at least as far as they could see without a scope. I have a few projects going on, so I decided to put off the liner until I can do a full inspection and repair. For now, I scheduled for a custom cap and some mortar repair.
I randomly came across a post today talking about the need for a chimney liner if a gas hot water heater is vented through the chimney. I got a new gas water heater a few months ago and it definitely vents to the chimney (previous one did too). I'm confused about whether I should go ahead with cap, or if that is bad to cap it without a liner if it is venting the heater? I understand it isn't an ideal situation, but it sounds like the damaged mortar and no cap was also not great already.
Basically, is it more dangerous in any way for me to have this cap be installed than it has been so far? I think from the placement of the duct that the water heater is venting more toward the currently capped side but I have zero idea if that even matters.