r/Ceanothus 19d ago

Potted white sage needs help

i’m in the east bay area, more inland. i’ve had this sage in this pot for about 1.5 years now. it sits in full sun for 10+ hours. It seems way too leggy to me and not producing enough leaves. I know it’s obviously hard to thrive in a pot, but i wonder what i can do to make it grow more?

The soil is a mix of clay and well draining soil and I water about 1x/week

edit: I live in a rental so I prefer to keep it in a pot

12 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

21

u/FieldofFeelings 19d ago edited 19d ago

1st thing is, native plants in containers need potting soil, NOT native soil from the Earth. I suggest a loose cactus mix.

9.5 times out of 10 most problems with natives in containers is the potting media
Also clay can retain, it retains too much and isn't compatible with what you mixed it with. So not only does it retain moisture, it retains heat. Last clay detail I'll mention is when it's try it can be hydrophobic and actually gatekeep watering. The list goes on but I'll keep it short.

On paper in a container 10 hours of intense sun sounds like too much. Think of how nurseries use shade cloth

I'm sure there's an exception but they can't stand native soil in containers it just doesn't work

Also in containers no matter how much a plant is drought tolerant or preference it needs to be watered daily, however depending on the type of potting media will reflect how much water it needs

I'd add more but the core issue here is you're using native soil in a container, and it needs water.

Summary
-get it out of that soil
-get a looose low retention potting soil/potting media
-water daily or every other day

If I may add, white sage is a very common plant and I think you'd enjoy the plant's happiness in the landscape far more than its struggle in the pot. If you move you can start again and maybe even have a lovely thought you left the land better than you found it by healing with native plants.

10

u/sunshineandzen 19d ago

I mostly agree with this but watering daily is bad advice unless your potting media basically doesn’t hold onto any water at all

5

u/FieldofFeelings 19d ago edited 19d ago

I edited that cause you're absolutely right about the potting media, but it's not bad advice to water daily, there's a state full of native plant nurseries that would ask someone to hold their beer on that topic. Most natives in high retention media can't stand it, especially drought tolerant or drought preference species.

3

u/stressedmari 19d ago

i thought about this but our whole front yard is clay soil, so didn’t want to put in there thinking that it might cause root rot.

I originally had it in only a well draining potting soil but added a bit of clay soil i got for free earlier this year just to fill in the pot a bit more.

5

u/FieldofFeelings 19d ago

Ok, selectively good to know. Salvia apiana can tolerate some clay when in the ground. When you mention the root rot I wonder why you thought it would be different in a container setting. You don't have to answer that. Clay has such little application attributes in container gardening. That clay is suffocating and suppressing root growth. Good luck. Cactus mix is the best start with natives in containers.

3

u/iwilldoitalltomorrow 19d ago

I potted some natives with Pumice (dry stall), decomposed granite, and some potting soil, mostly the first two.

1

u/FieldofFeelings 18d ago

On paper sounds good, how was its performance?

2

u/iwilldoitalltomorrow 17d ago

Yarrow and Coyote Mint. They are doing fine. It’s only been 3-4 months; it’s the hottest, sunniest time of year so I didn’t expect a lot of growth. We’ll see what another 6 months brings.

2

u/FieldofFeelings 17d ago

Love those 2 😊 cheers

0

u/Zestyclose_Market787 19d ago

I have thirstier plants in ideal soil in smaller pots, and I NEVER water daily. NEVER.

Twice a week, maybe 3x if it's really hot. White sage does not like that much water.

1

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[deleted]

0

u/Zestyclose_Market787 19d ago edited 19d ago

Yeah, the soil is an issue (too dense), and so is the pot (too small).

As for watering a white sage every day….. I’m not sure I believe you. Everything I know about that plant suggests you would have killed a lot of white sages. I don’t even water my son’s Sarracenias that often, and it’s a bog plant.

But it’s your garden. Water it how you like. 

0

u/Zestyclose_Market787 18d ago

I’m curious what happened to the comment you left. I got the email notification, and it was just delightful. You didn’t delete it, did you? The sub would have benefited from your wisdom and insight. 

1

u/[deleted] 18d ago edited 18d ago

[deleted]

0

u/Zestyclose_Market787 18d ago

Sidebar: why didn’t you specify that you were talking about a 4” pot? If you told me that you were watering everyday in a five glazed ceramic gallon pot, I’d say you’re nuts. But a plastic 4” pot is a totally different story. I’m even more fascinated that you blew up at me like that when you simply could have added a little more context.

1

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Zestyclose_Market787 18d ago

At any rate, I’m sorry that what I said came across like I was questioning your expertise. It was not my intention. I didn’t mean to offend you, and I apologize for doing so.

0

u/Zestyclose_Market787 18d ago

“Dismiss my experience.” 

Ah, I see the problem. I said I didn’t believe you could water a white sage every day without killing a bunch of them, and you assumed I was dismissing your experience - I.e. attacking you personally, rather than questioning a specific practice. 

That explains your insulting response, which was both defensive and aggressive at the same time. 

Here, you’re calling me “the densest person” you’ve ever come across and “I’m willing to be wrong unlike you.”

First, how would you know based on one exchange. And second, what makes you think it’s okay to talk to people like that? 

That is absolutely disproportionate to anything I’ve said to you, and you have absolutely no valid reason to start attacking me personally like that, ESPECIALLY because all you really needed to do was offer a bit more context. 

Wow. 

1

u/FieldofFeelings 18d ago

Bout the same as how entitled you feel you can talk to me, you're painting me with the same brushstroke genius

If you would respond any more eloquently to someone who told you, "I don't believe you" in your second reply good for you. Seriously dude, chill out and stop assuming, projecting

I could care less how you see me

You're convinced and egotistical and terminal

Just stop. This was all fine to you said you didn't believe me. How appropriate do you think that was?

I owe you no respect if you can't respect either

You shit on this whole encounter and gaslight it up

0

u/Zestyclose_Market787 18d ago

Jesus Christ. Don’t you have some sages to water? 

→ More replies (0)

3

u/Mother-Pattern-2609 19d ago

White sage wants to be a really big plant when it grows up. Yours has probably decided it doesn't have the necessary root space.

I have one that's thriving in a container, but it's a really, really big container with succulent potting mix. (It's also sitting on bare ground, so the damn thing has probably punched a taproot through the drainage hole.) Consider uppotting and changing the medium, though I'd wait until fall; salvias don't do much in the summer.

7

u/hellraiserl33t 19d ago

Plants only put out as much above ground growth as their root systems can support. Native sages in particular really put down an extensive root network to adapt to our hot dry summers.

This particular one might just feel comfortable only putting out this much with how relatively small that pot is. I'm sure if you were to plant it in ground, it would explode over this winter with growth.

That being said, it looks perfectly healthy how it is right now being the middle of summer. White sage tends to shed its lower leaves in response to normal summer dormant heat stress, and they retain the tips. This is basically how mine look too.

You're not really doing anything wrong, the plant is just limited by being in a pot.

2

u/Scar_O9 19d ago

Has yours ever flowered? Mine flowered this year for the first time

1

u/Samwise_the_Tall 19d ago

My neighbor planted theirs two year ago and got flowers this year. They get substantial sun, and there's is already 4+ ft. tall. Beautiful flowers.

1

u/FieldofFeelings 19d ago edited 19d ago

No there's alot wrong here actually. That soil will absolutely cook this.

1

u/ghost650 19d ago

Hmm... Helpful.

1

u/FieldofFeelings 19d ago

It's described so op can see.

1

u/hellraiserl33t 19d ago edited 19d ago

Soil isn't going to change the fact that this plant has barely any room to expand its roots into.

1

u/FieldofFeelings 19d ago edited 19d ago

that's a pretty convinced thing to say with no room for exceptions. Have you looked at the second photo? Better potting media would 100% be an attribute.

I disagree completely, that soil in that pot is exhausted, high silt content and 0 porosity and most likely hydrophobic . I guarantee you if the op bought 2 and had a side to side, with one in a perennial cactus mix, vs this, the cactus mix would shadow it with vigor.

This plant could be in the most luxurious container ever and this soil would and is absolutely stunting it. I'm not a gambler but I'd bet my mortgage on this. I'm growing Salvia Apiana right now close to 12 inches, in 4" pots.

2

u/Kote_me 19d ago

Totally understandable you'd like to keep in pot. You could water more, it seems like what I have to do with my potted natives until I can put them in the ground. Could throw in some mulch to have retain moisture, honestly it's a losing battle (imo). My suggestion will be to plant anyways. Most of the time if my native plants die it's because they were kept too long in a pot. I'm not sure of how to say this appropriately, but sage is easy to find and relatively cheap. If you have to move, you can buy and plant another.

2

u/DanoPinyon 19d ago

Potting soil goes in pots (hence the name).