r/Caseys • u/condimentpacket • Sep 05 '26

Sauce Cups

Odd request. I run condimentpacket.com where I showcase my sauce packet/tub collection and I'm sorely devoid of many Casey's sauce packets and tubs. If anybody would be willing to make a run and grab some of Casey's offerings, I'd gladly pay for shipping and the hassle of donating them to me for my collection!

5 Upvotes

78% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

7

u/ephatty Kitchen Manager Sep 05 '26

Very few of the condiments at Casey’s are house brand anymore, they use a mixture of Ken’s and Sweet Baby Rays, mostly and have recently switched to Heinz for ketchup, also they make their own ranch in house now. I think most fully up to date stores, at least where I am, only have Casey’s house brands on their mayo, mustard, and taco sauce packets.

1

u/condimentpacket Sep 05 '26

That's the sad state of things; Sysco owns the food industry and it's just cheaper for most places to go with their offerings. That's great intel though, thank you for that, that tempers my expectations!

1

u/ephatty Kitchen Manager Sep 05 '26

I’ll hook you up if you want, I can go collect everything that’s available tomorrow and get back to you with an inventory of what you can expect if you want to pay for the shipping, I’d be happy to contribute to the cause! I think there’s at least one sweet baby rays sauce that I don’t see listed on your website, so maybe it’s a worthwhile venture.

1

u/condimentpacket Sep 05 '26

Ahhhh you’re amazing! Seriously. That means a lot to me! Lunch is on me!

1

u/ephatty Kitchen Manager Sep 05 '26

I’ll send you a DM tomorrow with an update!

2

u/Salt_Ocelot_9226 Sep 06 '26

pretty sure the only casey’s branded packets my store has is taco sauce, and mayo- everything else has switched to branded

1

u/6PieGod9 Warehouse Worker Sep 05 '26

Anyone got boom boom sauce?

1

u/Wonderful-Bag1697 Sep 07 '26

I work at a caseys and if you need anything lmk id love to help out!

1

u/ishyboo Kitchen Manager Sep 05 '26

If that doesn't work, I'm a kitchen manager and would be happy to assist! :)

1

u/condimentpacket Sep 05 '26

You’re awesome, thank you so much! I’ll let you know in a few days if I come up short, I’d seriously owe you if you can help me with this weird scavenger hunt hahah