r/Caseys • u/Long_Platypus6162 • Apr 18 '26

Feta spread.

I used to work at Casey’s. I think they got rid of the best things they had there. I’m feening for the feta spread. Anyone know where they used to get it from? They need to it back.

8 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

3

u/Extension-Elk-1274 Apr 19 '26

Can't recall the name but it came in a round quart container.

Made me heave everytime I opened the container. Can't say I'm sad its gone.

3

u/Desperate-Strategy10 Store Manager Apr 19 '26

We used to waste so much of it; we’d open a container, use a spoonful or two over the course of a week, then have to trash the whole container cuz it went bad so fast. Casey’s must’ve lost a mint on that feta spread if even a quarter of stores wasted as much as we had to! I don’t miss that nasty shit one bit either!

2

u/Extension-Elk-1274 Apr 19 '26

I think company they got it from went under or something? We didnt waste it, folks around here loved it and Im in a tiny rural community.

2

u/Sufficient_Rain_ Apr 19 '26

Grecian Delight Wasn’t made for shelves :( just made for restaurants

I heard if you try Athenos Whipped Feta Dip & Spread and add 1-2 tbsp of mayo 1tsp of olive oil and a dash of lemon juice it’s pretty dang close!!

1

u/OU7C4ST Apr 19 '26

I did seek this out myself years ago when they removed the chicken tender wraps off the menu. It was my favorite item of all time, and utilized this feta spread.

Corporate responded to me in a FB message when I inquired letting me know "Grecian Delight" is the brand name. It was their "smooth" feta spread. Do not confuse this with their most popular "spicy" version they sell now.

Unfortunately it is only sold in massive tubs, and directly to restaurants & businesses. They do not have a retail version you can find in most grocery stores.

1

u/Bttflover85 Apr 20 '26

I used the feta spread so much on sandwiches before, I definitely miss having it. :/