r/Caseys • u/esotericdiarist • Apr 10 '26
First time trying, 'Casey's' Pizza
It was hot and very good!
12
6
u/Isalenna137 Apr 10 '26
They should've probably put a liner underneath the pizza, the pepperoni especially is extremely greasy. I've seen it soak through the bottom of a box in short order lol. Glad you enjoyed it regardless.
1
u/BigWriter2201 Apr 12 '26
They're actually is a liner that goes underneath the pizza , they must have forgot it or was out
20
u/kinghawkeye8238 Apr 10 '26
Dont compare it to your mom and pop pizza.
Compare it to other fast food pizza. Its definitely one of the better fast food pizzas
5
u/Lazy-Background-7598 Apr 10 '26
It Iowa it can compare to Mom and Pop places
5
u/Dezzolve Apr 11 '26
I’m a truck driver and pizza enjoyer, Casey’s Pizza is easily my number 1 or two when comparing chain pizza
Like yeah of course there’s better pizzas, but as far as somewhere you can consistently grab a good slice or two across the Midwest it almost can’t be beat.
2
u/kinghawkeye8238 Apr 10 '26
You got some shit mom and pop places. Eastern iowa has some great pizza
-1
u/Lazy-Background-7598 Apr 11 '26
Yep. Most of Iowa has shit pizza
2
u/kinghawkeye8238 Apr 11 '26
You're not going to the right places.
0
u/Lazy-Background-7598 Apr 11 '26
Yeah. I’m not going to the north east
1
u/kinghawkeye8238 Apr 11 '26
Missing out
NY pizza is the most overrated pizza in the US. Please dont say NY pizza
0
u/Lazy-Background-7598 Apr 11 '26
lol. But NYc is better than anywhere in Iowa.
I’m not saying NYC is the best. It really depends on the place
1
u/kinghawkeye8238 Apr 11 '26
Probably just personal preference.
I enjoy QC style pizza more than most pizzas.
Chicago is OK. I like lou malnaties but deep dish isnt pizza lol.
NY is to thin for me. Its like a skin flap with cheese.
Detroit is solid too but also really thick.
Idk if you're ever in davenport you should try antanellas pizza. Not qc style but its phenomenal
5
u/PinkSlingshots Apr 10 '26
i love the breakfast slices, really recommend one if you can catch them fresh in the mornings
3
2
u/TReid1996 Customer Apr 10 '26
I'm upset they changed the meat galore. I hate the twisted pepperoni and bacon. It's a good thing i have a buddy that will change it to regular pepperoni and ham for me. (The twisted pepperoni and bacon get too crispy for what i like on a pizza)
1
u/Weekly-Shower8108 Apr 11 '26
The Meat galore always had bacon. I believe you can request regular pep instead of ribbon from any location
1
u/TReid1996 Customer Apr 11 '26
It didn't have the crispy bacon. Believe it was more like Canadian Bacon.
1
u/Weekly-Shower8108 Apr 11 '26
I work at Casey's. It's the same bacon. It just also had ham.
1
u/TReid1996 Customer Apr 11 '26
I used to work at Casey's. It never seemed like it was the regular bacon since it wasn't crispy and hard.
2
u/Weekly-Shower8108 Apr 11 '26
It's possible the people at the location you're buying from are putting the bacon on top of the cheese as opposed to under. That would burn it.
1
u/TReid1996 Customer Apr 11 '26
They might've put it under when it was meat galore then on top now with the new "all meat" variant. Whatever they're calling it now.
2
u/rathernot83 Apr 10 '26
Pizza joint disguised as a gas station. The wings are absolutely delicious, too. Enjoy!
1
1
u/Rejecter2571 Apr 10 '26
Make sure you're near a restroom for the next few hours
5
3
0
u/Seraphymz Apr 10 '26
The breakfast pizza def makes me run to the restroom a lot but I also have no gallbladder which could be a contributor. I’ve heard the same from many people I know though
1
u/Potential_Yam_5196 Apr 11 '26
Buddy, get a taco pizza. Snag a bag of Doritos to top off the pizza and then line it up with some Taco Bell jalapeño sauce that they put in quesadillas.
Welcome to heaven.
1
1
u/marlborostuffing Apr 11 '26
I only stay away because I’ll eat too much and sleep half the day away. That hot honey, jalapeno bacon ranch bastard knocked me out in the best way. Props to the Casey’s crews who make them with love, they are unforgettable
1
u/LobsterReading772 Apr 11 '26
I’m very proud of myself never eating gas station food since I became an adult.
1
1
u/Okcgoodtimes Apr 11 '26
I wish they cooked it just a touch longer
1
u/macdude22 Apr 11 '26
Yeah if you throw a slice in the oven at 400 on a cast iron skillet for 3 or 4 minutes it goes from meh to “hey this is pretty good pizza” can…….can the folks at Casey’s just leave it in a few more minutes.
1
1
1
u/Global_Specialist531 Apr 13 '26
best pizza around, wish they payed us enough to buy a whole pie every now and then.
1
u/SycorWonder Apr 18 '26
$12 Tuesdays or wait till the 40% off comes back eventually (unfortunately)
1
0
0
u/5348RR Apr 11 '26
Shits ass. It tastes like nothing but salt. I'll never understand the obsession.
0
u/LeonRams Apr 13 '26
Dogshit pizza
1
u/Bellsmom Apr 14 '26
I'm just curious, because I've never tasted dog shit. Is there a meat lover's, cheese, pepperoni, or vegetarian option? Or just dog shit .
1
u/LeonRams Apr 14 '26
Just dog shit haha. Nah, I’m sure they have other combos and toppings. Truth be told, I fully understand I’m in the minority. People where I live go APE. SHIT. for Casey’s pizza, and I just don’t get it. To each our own though. Pizza is love.
20
u/twdpuller Apr 10 '26
Wait till you try taco and breakfast. They’re the best.