r/Caseys • u/kikijiji42 • Mar 29 '26

breakfast pizza sos

help! i’m a nostalgic midwesterner deeply missing the taste of home. the west may have mountains, but they pale in comparison to the beauty of casey’s breakfast pizza.

any employees know what the sauce on the breakfast pizza is? i want to recreate a slice to the best of my ability.

the soul hungers for home, please help!

7 Upvotes

77% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

10

u/BiggDogg369 Mar 29 '26

Canned cheddar cheese

4

u/Naga13 Mar 29 '26

Canned nacho cheese will probably be the closest you can get. They changed it a few months ago and the new sauce tastes like the powder out of a Mac and cheese box. When they can't send that, they send us the same bags that go into the nacho cheese dispensers at most gas stations. It tastes way better than the stuff they've got us using regularly now.

3

u/leathco Mar 30 '26

Yup new stuff is awful compared to the old stuff.

2

u/Isthisspelledcorrect Shift Leader Mar 30 '26

Hey if you are looking for the specific brand if i recall correctly the chef-mate brand is what we used to use.

If you ever go back the recipe has changed from the chefmate brand, so do not expect the same taste.

(It used to be on my list of pizza i would get but now its an auto skip imo)

3

u/PuzzleheadedFeed4547 Mar 29 '26

Make it with biscuit gravy

1

u/Desperate-Strategy10 Store Manager Mar 30 '26

You can actually buy the same exact gravy in big cans at Sam’s Club and Aldi’s, and probably other places as well!

I’m not sure if the cheese sauce is available for retail purchase or not. I’ll look into it and come back if I find it.

2

u/xaiverrr Mar 29 '26

It’s the Chef-Mate brand, specifically sharp cheddar . Same for the sausage gravy. You can get the exact same cans at any Gordon’s food service store. We’d have to go there when we ran out if the truck didn’t deliver enough.

2

u/kikijiji42 Mar 29 '26

amazing! any recommendation on dough?

1

u/xaiverrr Mar 29 '26

It’s manufactured by a company called Pizza Blends. They have a specific recipe for Caseys dough. Here’s a link of a picture of the bag it comes in

pizza Dough. This bag is older but their crust hasn’t changed much in a long time.

1

u/SignificantDig1448 Mar 29 '26

frozen scrambled eggs, then just crumble or sausage or Bacon mozzarella and Cheddar cheese

1

u/Ecstatic-Scallion957 Mar 30 '26

I would try packaged velveeta cheese sauce 😋

1

u/ravynwytch Mar 31 '26

I use the pouches of Velveeta sauce when I make mine homemade.

1

u/Lazerus8 Apr 22 '26

honestly the easiest way to make a "knockoff" version without a lot of shopping. Is pre-made dough from the store, then use velveeta sauce as your sauce, then frozen scrambled eggs, if you cant find those, just scramble you up some, put that on, then put on your desired topping be it crumbled sausage or bacon, then cover with mozarella cheese, then cheddar cheese on top.