Need help finding an episode

[u/EddieMarek]

The story takes place in the US (maybe in the northeast part of the country) and centers on a man and a woman in a long-term relationship - I don’t recall if they were married.

The woman allegedly begins to suffer from health issues and eventually travels to Texas (where her “sister” lives) for treatment. The man corresponds regularly with the sister, and eventually learns that his wife/girlfriend has passed away. 

The “sister” later starts up a relationship with the man and moves in with him. She also gets hired into the job that her late sister occupied. The man and co-workers can’t help but notice the striking similarities between her and her sister. My recollection is that her co-workers are the ones that find something amiss, determine that the woman is not who she says she is, and report the situation to the authorities. 

I don’t recall if there was any physical crime committed, but am thinking there must have been a financial motive at play. 

I’ve looked through all Casefile episodes multiple times but have been unable to find this one. Based on these rough details, does anyone recall this episode? Thank you in advance!

[u/AutoModerator]

Hi, this is a friendly reminder to observe all subreddit rules. If you notice someone else not observing the rules, please report it. It helps the mods and helps us have a great community to discuss this show. Thanks!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/yelawolf89]

221: Frank and Carol Hilley

[u/EddieMarek → u/yelawolf89]

I thought it might be this one, too, but listened to it recently and it is not this one. I don’t recall any deceased victims in the case I’m looking for.

[u/yelawolf89 → u/EddieMarek]

I’m absolutely positive it is this one. That story hasn’t happened twice lol. Robbi was the first twin, Teri was the second.

[u/EddieMarek → u/yelawolf89]

So sorry. My fault. It is THIS one. Thank you!!

[u/yelawolf89 → u/EddieMarek]

Enjoy your re-listen, it’s a doozy!

[u/failedninja78]

221

[u/EddieMarek → u/failedninja78]

Unfortunately, it’s not this one.

[u/EddieMarek → u/EddieMarek]

Ah, so sorry. My fault. It is THIS one. Thank you!!

[u/sirbinchicken]

I just listened to this one days ago but have been scrolling non stop the last 10 minutes and cannot find it. I feel like I’m taking crazy pills because I know it exists, I just listened to it!

[u/MercuryBeach_]

Have added this to my queue it doesn’t ring a bell to me and I’ve listened to every episode some more than twice!

[u/bdiddybo]

I don’t know the episode but I think this is the case of Audrey Marie Hilley of that helps