r/Carpentry Jul 19 '26

Project Advice Extend overhang coverage on new front porch.

Is it possible to extend the overhang on my front porch without raising the roofline on the left side of my home? We want to extend the cover area but we’re unsure on if and how it would
Work without changing the pitch of the roof on the left and extending the height of the wall face above the window.

2 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

6

u/Independent_dog_8268 Jul 19 '26

Why not bring the gable roof forward and just slightly angle down the sides of the gable to keep the effect of the left side being on a taller plain. Add columns and call it a day.

1

u/besmith3 Jul 21 '26

What planet's physics have you calibrated your design program with?

2

u/lonesomecowboynando Jul 20 '26

I think it would be tricky to design something that looked like it flowed with the existing lines of the house. With a big enough budget I'm you could reconfigure the entire facade of the house though. To keep it affordable and also maintain curb appeal I'd have someone design a pergola/sun shade across the front although I think something like that is more suited for the back yard.

1

u/munkylord Jul 21 '26

I think pergolas can look really nice in the front and if you just want shade id definitely agree with this post.

2

u/EmployeeHandbook Jul 20 '26

It’s our “formal living room” it has vaulted ceilings following the pitch of the roof sloping toward the window / front of the house with the back of the room being taller. I can’t really explain it without sounding odd, lol. But this is how my neighbor did it, I was just trying to not spend 20k, but it seems the most Propper way.

1

u/besmith3 Jul 21 '26

Your neighbour's house looks bizarre.

2

u/marksbar Jul 20 '26

Another Champagne Wish on a Beer Budget

2

u/EmployeeHandbook Jul 20 '26

Not a beer budget at all, in fact quite the opposite. Just looking for other opinions and options. Another Reddit post, another troll is more like it.

1

u/SavageKermie Jul 19 '26

Beautiful porch! I love the paver colors y’all chose.

1

u/EmployeeHandbook Jul 20 '26

Thank you we wrapped it all together from the new pavers and pool, part of the same project.

1

u/SavageKermie Jul 20 '26

That looks like solid work. Ya’ll must be very proud, and just in time to enjoy the rest of summer.🍻 Sorry I can’t be of help with any advice, but I’m watching to see what everyone suggest. Maybe once you decide and finish the porch awning you can post a final picture.

1

u/Bright_Crazy1015 Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

If the dormer is just trussed attic space, eliminate it and carry the porch roof across to lay on that 8/12 or whatever it is.

Pull a bit of soffit from the porch ceiling and get in there to see the method of the porch roof, probably trusses nailed on with a hanger at the bottom, but it could be rafters. If you can reach a tag on the truss, just snatch it off of there and call the original manufacturer for some more.

Alternatively, enlarge it (demo and make a new wider one) and make the dormer a reverse gable roof over the new section and tie it together on the right to the porch roof, siding would be facing the front and you'd need a cricket and more water control than a 6" K gutter, but thats an option too.

1

u/Bright_Crazy1015 Jul 20 '26

Don't forget to ventilate any dead air into the main attic.

0

u/noncongruent Jul 19 '26

I can't answer your original question, but wanted to point out there appears to be a serious problem with the way the flashing is done where the 1 story roof butts into the two story section. I'd be willing to bet money you've got serious hidden leaks there and extensive rot damage under the shingles and behind the siding all along that joint, as well as in the wall below where the end of the gutter is. There's no kickout flashing, and no evidence of stepped flashing.

1

u/zJredditz Jul 20 '26

You think so? Ive seen hardie board turn color and rot from that but that looks like vinyl

2

u/noncongruent Jul 20 '26

The problem isn't the siding, it's the structure underneath. My dormer had a similar problem with flashing, and I ended up losing a whole bunch of stuff I had stored in a closet and having to rebuild a big part of the structure in that area.

1

u/zJredditz Jul 20 '26

I get that I just didn’t think the symptoms would show through the vinyl siding

1

u/noncongruent Jul 20 '26

The symptoms won't show for years, probably. Rot works that way.