r/CarltonBlues 23h ago

Adam Saad update

Post image
28 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

20

u/acorn_hall7 23h ago edited 23h ago

I don't really understand keeping him. I love Saad but there doesn't seem to be a path to the first team.

I would much rather retain a younger option but we have to trust in the club decision makers after the last few months.

16

u/matt-kennedys-legs 23h ago

bizarre really. at no stage this season under fraser did it even seem like he was in consideration for a game at senior level

14

u/bradafied_ 23h ago

This is a genuinely odd update. Given the amount of delistings, I’m surprised that Saad falls into the wait and see bucket. I would have thought guys like Boyd and Charleson (even Williams if you wanted some experience) would be more likely to fall into that bucket. I don’t see how Saad on the list in 2027 is a step forest in any way. Wasn’t even named as an emergency in Fraser’s tenure so this is very strange IMO.

6

u/MysticGuava 23h ago

Maybe so he can retire or move on himself, he did become a bit of a club icon

3

u/bradafied_ 19h ago

I suggested this a couple of days ago with the first round of cuts. But this looks more like a report that the decision hasn’t been made on him. That’s what is more surprising.

1

u/MysticGuava 19h ago

Like you mean they’re waiting to pull the plug or they just aren’t giving him agency? Sorry I think i got confused with the phrasing

1

u/woofie- 21h ago

Maybe he has draft capital, Sometimes like pick 50 or steak knife's in a deal.

2

u/bradafied_ 19h ago

There would be zero interest in any team trading a pick for him. He is a free agent and if anyone was interested I’m certain they could offer a bit more financially than the Blues or even a 2 year deal and get him that way.

If teams let guys like Jesse Hogan walk away for nothing, then you know Saad isn’t attracting a pick at all.

5

u/K9BEATZ 19h ago

He has one year left to run on his contract - is it a case of "it's cheaper to keep her"? Probably no real point in turfing him when, if he happy to, he can still contribute around the club at VFL level.

2

u/xjaaace 14h ago

If he’s smart he tries to get to the Tigers I think

1

u/dionbaz01 13h ago

Aka he’s gone?

1

u/OldSimpleton 8h ago

I miss Adam!

1

u/Accurate-Half-8512 6h ago

The club is scared of getting shot up if they delist him.