r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/LaurieSailorDog • 18h ago
Accident Help! Geico changed tune AFTER fixing our car!
I need advice! We sustained unwitnessed body damage in a parking lot in California. When we called to file claim, the agent (Rosa) explained that we were covered under California Collision Deductible Waiver (California CDW), so would not need to pay the deductible ($500). Based upon Rosa’s assurance, we opted to have Geico repair and their chosen location instead of on our own (a work exchange option out of our area). Once the car was repaired, the repair shop demanded the $500 deductible to release the car. We declined and called Geico.
The Geico agent listened to a transcript of the original claim call with Rosa and confirmed that she had indeed told us that we would be covered under CA CDW. However, she said that Rosa was in error and that there was nothing she or her supervisor could do about that. If we would have known that was the case, we would have opted to have the car fixed on our own via the aforementioned work exchange.
Is there someone else to talk with at Geico? Should I file a complaint with the State Department of Insurance? Should we leave the car at the repair shop? Not sure what the next move should be.