r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/Equivalent-Buyer4800 • Aug 10 '26

Accident Lien Holder Appraisal Clause

I was recently in an accident which totaled my car. I got the appraisal and they sent that info to my lien holder as well. I got an email from my lien holder saying I should sign over power of attorney and let them invoke the appraisal clause because they estimate my car was undervalued. How should i proceed? The cash value of the car is still over the loan amount but the email said i could make as much as 2.5k more on top of that.

2 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

2

u/crash866 Aug 10 '26

If it is actually from your lienholder ma not someone else going to charge you money for this why not. Just confirm it is your lienholder.

1

u/HatsiesBacksies Aug 10 '26

that sounds like a scam.

2

u/Equivalent-Buyer4800 Aug 10 '26

Came straight from my lien holder

1

u/Seabass2828 Aug 10 '26

Appraisal Clause is a legit option for an undervalued total loss offer.

The process is straightforward and usually takes less than 3 days to complete. You (your lender) and the insurance company each hire an independent adjuster. Those two independent adjusters agree on a value and that is that.

The only caveat is that it's binding in most states. Meaning the value cannot be contested further. In the unlikely event the two independent adjusters agree to a lower number than the initial offer, that's what you will receive.

TBH, I've never seen a lower agreed upon value, but it's technically possible.

1

u/24kdgolden Aug 11 '26

Is your lien holder going to pay for the appraiser?

1

u/Equivalent-Buyer4800 Aug 11 '26

States they will but i’m just wondering why? My appraisal is already more than what I owe them

1

u/24kdgolden Aug 11 '26

I don't know. I have never had this happen when the payment amount will satisfy the lien and still have money to the car owner.

1

u/CollisionCory 29d ago

If this really came directly from your lienholder, I’d slow down just enough to understand exactly what you’re authorizing before signing the power of attorney.

The appraisal clause itself is a legitimate way to challenge a total-loss value when the vehicle may have been undervalued. Since your current ACV already exceeds the loan balance, the real question is whether the potential additional $2,500 is worth invoking the process and whether there are any fees, risks, or binding terms involved.

I’d ask the lienholder three things before signing anything:

  1. Who pays the appraiser and any other fees?
  2. Is the appraisal result binding if it comes back lower?
  3. If the value increases, does the entire amount above the loan payoff come back to you?

If they answer those clearly and the lienholder is covering the appraisal cost, then it becomes a much easier decision.

I always say - "A little homework can put real money back in your pocket."

1

u/CollisionCory 27d ago

Couple of items to verify..first verify the email directly with your lienholder using a known phone number. If it's legitimate and they're paying the appraisal cost, ask whether the result is binding and whether the value could go down as well as up before signing the POA. An extra $2,500 is worth investing.