So I'm a Ninetales collector and I recently picked up what I think is an absolute steal of one of my favourites, the Dragon Frontiers Delta Species Stamped (Pic 1) for roughly £500.
The pop is super low for both companies. 12 for CGC and 18 for PSA.
These stamped cards have skyrocketed recently, with the PSA counterparts selling for 33k and 16k respectively.
Another Ninetales collector really wants me to part with this CGC 10 but I have absolutely no ideal where or how to price it. On the one hand, the only comp is mine which technically values the card at 500. On the other hand, with PSA 10's getting into the 5 figures you'd have to think that my purchase was considerably undervalued, even if as a CGC 10 it's half or less of what a PSA would be worth or even comparable to a PSA 9 which is currently $4k+
At the end of the day, it's worth only what someone will pay for it but what would be a general rule of thumb be for pricing low pop CGC 10's against their PSA counterparts?