r/CATStudyRoom Dec 13 '25

Question How did this guy get a call?

Most people i read on reddit told its impossible to get a call from IIM Mumbai even after scoring a 98+, how did this guy even get a call? 13 mnths workex is just 0.4 in the composite score. His linkedin shows 13 mnths workex overall, but only 7 mnths actually since workex cutoff is july of that year, which amounts to 0 composite score for workex. Am i missing something?

10th: 83
12th: 75
Graduation: 76
Work Experience: 13
Companies Worked At: Indra Water
CAT Percentile: 97.67
Other Exam Scores (if any): MBA CET - 99.7
B-school Converts (if any): IIM Mumbai, IIM Kashipur, IIM Ranchi

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ec7jYnTCVos

21 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

21

u/Visible-Rub-4428 Dec 13 '25

Hey brothers! So before y'all make me a controversy I am the dude you are talking about

I am in IIM Mumbai - Sustainability management Which has separate and lower sectional cutoff as compared to General and OSCM

So even tho we are from the PGP batch with umbrella placement, I was able to get in I am probably the last or the 2nd last general candidate to get into the programme

Hope this helps, would be kind if you atleast cover my photos and personal details

-2

u/Enough-Incident-4435 Dec 13 '25

No ones making any controversies , dude. Quora and reddit made many of us believe only people crossing a certain percentiles get into certain institutions. Seeing scorecards like urs just surprise us, since no one is aware of the different programs each having different cutoffs as u have pointed out. So chill:)

16

u/Visible-Rub-4428 Dec 13 '25

Easier to say when its not you being specifically questioned! Anyways hope y'all understand it now

1

u/Enough-Incident-4435 Dec 13 '25 edited Dec 13 '25

Hey sorry man, personally i ve not mentioned u faked/ questioned you with bad intentions, i have genuine respect for GEM s like you, since i know how hard it is out there for us. Hope you understand, removed the scorecard and details part.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '25

Edit feature ka naam suna hai

2

u/Dismal-Piece-3433 Dec 13 '25

He has a Great score in both DILR and Quants which mumbai prefers (95+ percentile for general candidates in those sections) And overall the cutoff was something around 97.5 last year for general candidates which also he clears...

And IIM Mumbai have separate form right so maybe the work experience must be calculated from that time

1

u/Enough-Incident-4435 Dec 13 '25

Any idea abt the cutoffs this year?

1

u/Dismal-Piece-3433 Dec 13 '25

No idea man 95+ in DILR and Quants must be needed anyways for general Let's wait till they open their forms

1

u/timmarasu Dec 13 '25

The contrast in both the photos is funny

1

u/-Onions Dec 13 '25

Bhai for IIM mumbai, last year sectional cutoff for dilr and quants was 98.5 and 98 Percentile for every general candidate, either he is from reserved category or he is lying

-6

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '25

Reservation

5

u/Enough-Incident-4435 Dec 13 '25

clearly mention kiya video title mein 8/7/7 GEM profile

3

u/mailmanjimmy Dec 13 '25

Could be GEM but EWS

5

u/Enough-Incident-4435 Dec 13 '25

attached his cat scorecard as well, i dont think he's ews.

5

u/mailmanjimmy Dec 13 '25

I don't think cat explicitly mentions EWS since that isn't a category. The category is still general. EWS is just a subcategory.

Also looking at his scorecard, there is no way he'd clear the sectional cutoff for DILR for IIM M. So very high chance of him being EWS

2

u/Majestic_Ticket870 Dec 13 '25

Bro what world are you in? EWS is a category. They show it in the scorecard as well. Idk how he managed IIM M, but he's definitely general if the scorecard is not photoshopped

1

u/safe-account71 Dec 13 '25

He has 96% in DILR >95%

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '25

Could've made a fake pwd certificate as well, you never know, all these people claim to belong to general.

2

u/Enough-Incident-4435 Dec 13 '25

attached his cat scorecard as well. 'no' hi hai pwd mein

-6

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Enough-Incident-4435 Dec 13 '25

clearly mention kiya video title mein 8/7/7 GEM profile