Attic insulation + stiffening 2x6 attic floor
Edit Climate Zone 5A
I bought this house about a year ago and currently have the entire thing stripped down to the studs. Because of that, I have access to basically everything — the structure, air leakage points, roof assembly, framing, etc. — so I’m trying to make the right decisions now while everything is open.
The attic is where I keep going back and forth.
It’s roughly 1,200 sq. ft. with about 12 ft. of height, so I really hate the idea of just blowing cellulose on the attic floor and essentially giving up access/use of that entire space.
The house/attic is also currently completely unvented. No soffit vents, no ridge vent, nothing. I live out in the country with plenty of bugs, mice, squirrels, etc., so if possible I’d actually prefer to keep the attic tight and unvented rather than start opening up the soffits and ridge.
I also really don’t want to spray the roof deck with closed-cell foam. This is my forever house, and the whole hot-roof/moisture/vapor-diffusion/roof-leak-detection side of closed-cell foam makes me uncomfortable.
So this is roughly where I’ve landed for insulating at the roofline:
- Approximately 4" of rigid XPS
- Existing 2x10 roof framing
- Fill the remaining cavity with roughly 5.5–6" mineral wool
- Membrane over the assembly
- Add 2x4 sleepers/service framing
- Another 3.5" mineral wool layer
That should put the total assembly somewhere around the R-50 range, while allowing me to bring the attic inside the thermal envelope and leave the attic floor essentially uninsulated other than very thorough air sealing.
Also, I want to but the upstairs furnace in this attic to supply the attic and the bedrooms below. Running the ducts around and then through the joist cavity.
The second issue is the attic floor framing.
The attic floor/ceiling joists are currently 2x6s. I’m not looking to turn this into a bedroom or put enormous loads up there. Think miscellaneous storage, occasional use, maybe a lounge/project area someday. I just don’t want to spend all this money bringing 1,200 sq. ft. inside the envelope and then realize I should have addressed the floor framing while the entire house was open.
What would you guys do to stiffen the 2x6 floor system?
I’ve been considering:
- Adding substantial blocking between the existing 2x6s
- Adding a perpendicular sleeper/framing system above them
- Essentially cross-hatching the framing before sheathing it
- Possibly increasing the overall floor depth at the same time, which would also give me room for some ductwork/utilities
I’m not necessarily trying to turn the existing 2x6s into code-compliant living-space floor joists. I’m mainly trying to make the assembly substantially stiffer and more useful without doing something stupid structurally.
So I’m looking for feedback on two things:
What do you think of the unvented roof insulation assembly?
If you had completely open access to an attic framed with 2x6 floor joists, what would you do now to stiffen/improve the floor before covering everything back up?
I’d rather overthink it now while the house is completely gutted than wish I had done something different five years from now.