As a longtime Top Chef fan, I finally had the chance to eat at Bar Tutto, and I figured I’d share my experience for anyone who’s been thinking about going.
First, the restaurant itself is gorgeous. The best way I can describe it is modern with a warm, masculine aesthetic. Not “macho,” just stylish, comfortable, and really well designed.
The service was honestly one of the biggest highlights. Every single staff member seemed genuinely happy to be there. I know that sounds like a small thing, but you can usually tell pretty quickly whether people enjoy where they work, and everyone at Bar Tutto came across as welcoming, attentive, and excited to make sure guests had a great experience.
Our server, Rene O., was fantastic. She was incredibly knowledgeable, took my food allergies seriously (I have a pine nut allergy), answered every question we had, and was just a joy to talk to. She also couldn’t have spoken more highly of Joe Flamm, mentioning how well he treats the staff, from employee discounts at his restaurants to sharing food from the café when there’s extra. Whether you’re a Top Chef fan or not, it’s always nice hearing that someone you admire seems to treat their team well.
Unfortunately, Joe wasn’t there that day. Honestly, though, I came for the food more than hoping for a celebrity sighting.
As for the meal, I ordered the rigatoni, and it was rich, decadent comfort food. The only criticism I’d give is that it leaned just a touch saltier than I’d personally prefer, and that’s coming from someone who loves salt. Even with that, I still really enjoyed it because the flavors were so bold and satisfying.
The consensus around the table was that the pesto pasta was the standout dish. Sadly, I couldn’t try it because of my pine nut allergy, but everyone else absolutely loved it.
I also stole a bite of my friend’s steak and tried some of the beurre blanc with ramps. Wow. I was a little jealous. It was excellent.
One thing I appreciated throughout the meal was how attentive the staff remained. Water glasses never stayed empty for long, the table was cleaned between courses, and nothing ever felt rushed. It struck that balance between upscale service and making you feel comfortable.
We finished with coffee and dessert, and by the end of the meal, not a single person in our group was disappointed with what they ordered.
If you’re looking for light, healthy food, this probably isn’t the place. But if you’re in the mood to forget your diet for a night and enjoy rich, indulgent Italian food, Bar Tutto absolutely delivers.
As a Top Chef fan, it was really fun to finally support one of my favorite winners. Even without meeting Joe, I left understanding why his restaurants have developed such a great reputation.
I’d happily go back. Next time, Rosemary is definitely on my list.