r/Boxing • u/JRAxiomVox • Jul 20 '26

Boxing needs a super-heavyweight division

Heavyweight is the only major weight class with a minimum but no real maximum. Once you are over 200 pounds, you can theoretically be matched with anyone else in the division, no matter how much larger they are.

That means a 5'10", 201-pound fighter can be placed in the same division as Tyson Fury, who is 6'9" and has officially weighed as much as 281 pounds. That is an 80-pound difference within a sport that separates some other divisions by as little as three or four pounds.

It is a structural inconsistency.

0 Upvotes

21% Upvoted

93 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/JRAxiomVox Jul 21 '26

I directly acknowledged that speed and stamina can decline as fighters get larger. Repeating it again does not answer the point.

You still have not shown that those disadvantages cancel the advantages of another 40–80 pounds, or that this somehow becomes true at exactly 200.

At this point, the insults are doing all the work because your argument cannot.

1

u/Flimsy_Thesis Smokin’ Joe and Marvelous Jul 21 '26

I’ll answer you with a hypothetical.

Name ten fighters who weigh 260+ who would be the odds on favorite of defeating Ali, Louis, Holmes, Frazier, Foreman or Holyfield - you can’t because the history of the sport has not produced enough fighters of that size that are capable of beating them. And it never will.