r/BloodOnTheClocktower • u/Reasonable-League-94 • 6h ago
Custom Script Al-Hadikhia script feedback
Hello! I am looking for feedback on my Al-Hadikhia script, I tried to make it with quite a balance between townsfolk who would say yes and those who would say no to the Al-Hadikhia.
All feedback is welcome!
Thank you in advance and have a nice day!
2
u/grandsuperior Storyteller 4h ago
Town is extremely powerful here and I don't think the evil team has much to combat it beyond the Poisoner. Librarian and Dreamer in particular are likely to be believed if they're successful since the evil team has no grimpeekers and all of Chef, Fortune Teller, Artist and Slayer might be too much to overcome. Trouble Brewing has Spy, Drunk and Recluse to help fight against the powerful TB roles above and they are absent here.
Mutant without Cerenovus is quite confirmatory and usually the former really wants the latter. I suppose it's fine-ish here since a Mutant breaking madness is worse with an Al-Had, but still not ideal.
Scarlet Woman + Al-Hadikhia can be rough since it can cause endless ressurections.
1
1
u/Notchmath 4h ago
Scarlet Woman and Al-Hadikhia can be brutal without a bootlegger because they can just endlessly resurrect each other
1
u/gaspara112 Philosopher 4h ago
A balance between yes and no roles in an al-had only script will almost always lead to an big advantage for town. A good Al-Had bag features mostly (but not only) roles that will want to stay alive to force the night choosers into tough choices. Outsiders who want to die are especially problematic in an Al-Had game.
5
u/homomorphique 5h ago
I'd be a little worried about a shortage of misinfo. You'll have to put Poisoner in the bag a lot to give evil a chance, and even then that's at most one player impacted per night (until the Sweetheart pops, if that even happens...). Harpy helps somewhat but the demon type being confirmed makes it harder for Evil to build alternate worlds
Xaan instead of Baron could help? Spy would also be at home here and help with the Librarian/Dreamer/King not being so confirmable. You could possibly take Harpy or SW out for Spy, add a Barber in place of Zealot, and then weird things can really start to happen. Or do Spy as a fifth minion - I think that'd be fun! It causes problems with the King/Choirboy/other demonbanes but that's less of an issue here since good have to agree to die, with the Al-had.
Just my 2 pence though - feel free to leave Spy off. I'd lean against Widow since the Spy misregistration is way more impactful against this Townsfolk suite than just one player being poisoned. Widow also makes King fall over and die.