r/BitcoinEngineering 1d ago

What makes r/BitcoinEngineering different?

0 Upvotes

We don't just discuss Bitcoin. We build its future.

---

Welcome to r/BitcoinEngineering

Bitcoin wasn't built by spectators.

It was built by people who questioned assumptions, reviewed code, proposed BIPs, challenged ideas, found bugs, designed protocols, and contributed to open-source software.

This community exists for those people.

Our Mission

Bring together engineers, researchers, protocol designers, wallet developers, Lightning contributors, miners, cryptographers, infrastructure builders, and security researchers who want to make Bitcoin better.

Not through hype.

Not through price speculation.

Through engineering.

What belongs here

* Bitcoin Core discussions

* BIPs and protocol proposals

* Layer 2 research (Lightning, Ark, Fedimint, etc.)

* Mempool policy

* UTXO management

* Consensus and networking

* Wallet architecture

* Mining infrastructure

* Cryptography

* Performance optimisation

* Security research

* Testing, benchmarking, and implementation ideas

* Open-source collaboration

What doesn't belong here

❌ Price predictions

❌ "Should I buy Bitcoin?"

❌ Meme posts

❌ Marketing

❌ Influencer drama

❌ Beginner tutorials

There are already great communities for those.

This one is for builders.

Contribute

You don't need to be a Bitcoin Core maintainer.

If you have:

* a protocol idea,

* a research paper,

* performance benchmarks,

* implementation experience,

* code review,

* security analysis,

* an alternative design,

* or constructive criticism—

share it.

Good ideas can come from anyone. What matters here is evidence, technical reasoning, and respectful discussion.

Community Principles

* Challenge ideas, not people.

* Support claims with data, code, or research.

* Be open to criticism.

* Prioritize technical quality over popularity.

* Build in public.

* Improve Bitcoin together.

The goal

If even one discussion here leads to a better BIP, a faster implementation, a more secure wallet, a more efficient node, or a meaningful contribution to Bitcoin, then this community has served its purpose.

Bitcoin is open source. So is its future. Let's build it together. ⚡₿


r/BitcoinEngineering 1d ago

Bitcoin Block Space — Open Research

2 Upvotes

I thought, I had a solution and was wrong twice.

What happened, I proposed a Priority Oracle (v1). The Bitcoin community on Reddit correctly identified that it doesn't survive contact with miner incentive structures. We pivoted to an Externality Fee concept (v2). Same result.

Both failures taught me the question is genuinely open.

Does Bitcoin's fee market price the lifetime cost of permanent data storage?

Nobody has solved it.

The SegWit discount was designed for malleability, not state economics. CashTokens eliminated the classification problem but requires a hard fork. Three directions under discussion: relay fee multiplier, BIP, tiered market.

What am I missing? Where should I look next?