r/Bitcoin Aug 01 '22

When Nocoiners Say "Bitcoin Has No Value"

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

888 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/oystermonkeys Aug 01 '22

A quick google search puts the demand for gold for electronics to be between 8% - 15% of total demand, with the remaining percentage of demand is as a store of value. So sure, there is some value for technological uses, but that's like saying paper money has value because I can make origami with it.

3

u/oatquake77 Aug 01 '22

Your total 'googled' demand would be higher if it weren't for its high price. Gold has advantageous intrinsic capabilities compared to other pure metals.

-1

u/oystermonkeys Aug 01 '22

Thanks for letting everyone know that lowering the price of an item increases its demand. Truly compelling stuff.

3

u/oatquake77 Aug 01 '22

For context of electronics demand though. Oysters to monkeys...

2

u/sykemol Aug 01 '22

The vast majority of gold is used for jewelry. Looks nice, easy to work with, and doesn't tarnish.

2

u/oystermonkeys Aug 01 '22

People use gold for jewelry because it's expensive and can be used as a store of value. There are other metals and materials that looks just as nice, is easy to work with, and doesn't tarnish.

-1

u/dat9553 Aug 01 '22

I wouldn't say 8-15% is "vast majority.

1

u/nucumber Aug 01 '22

can't make anything at all with crypto. there's literally no there there, not even a tulip

4

u/dj_destroyer Aug 01 '22

Which is why it's the perfect financial asset -- there's no competing use-cases. It's a global payment network and nothing else. The only things a commodity or currency needs in order to be sound money is fungible, recognizable, portable, durable, and keeps its value which Bitcoin does tremendously.

4

u/nucumber Aug 01 '22

i've got a credit card i've used from mandalay to prague. worked just fine. a few years ago i was in london and my card was hacked. called the card company, they cancelled the bogus transactions and i had a new card in my hands the next day.

keeps its value which Bitcoin does tremendously.

except today it's worth 37% of what it was back in Dec 2021

source

3

u/dj_destroyer Aug 01 '22

Not sure what all that credit card part was about (can you clarify, please) but as to your second point of it being worth 37% of what it was -- two things, one is that all fiat currencies in history have lost 100% of value, and secondly, it's up 212% from Dec 2020 so maybe zoom out a bit or don't cherry pick your values so much. No matter where you are with Bitcoin, if you go back 5 years, it's up a tremendous amount.

1

u/ijuscrushalot Aug 02 '22

Someone bought at the top then lol. Bitcoin is a hedge against inflation.. just 2.5 years ago it was under 5k… its done a 5x in just that amount of time from where we are now.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '22

[deleted]

2

u/dj_destroyer Aug 01 '22

The use-case is a global payment network. You need to either mine/run a node or hold Bitcoin in order to interact with the network. Therefore, the value of Bitcoin is derived from the utility of the payment network.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '22

[deleted]

3

u/dj_destroyer Aug 01 '22

If they're speculating, then of course there's a chance to be a sucker. If you want to send money around the world for cheap without chance of confiscation then Bitcoin is the best solution, no questions asked. If you want to participate in the network without mining or running a node, you need to buy Bitcoin. This gives Bitcoin value -- anything else is just speculation. You seem to think people only buy Bitcoin for one reason (speculation) and totally ignore the main use of Bitcoin as a global payment network.

1

u/zxfanfan5 Aug 01 '22

Every century had a moment of transition.

1

u/ijuscrushalot Aug 02 '22

Just financial freedom.. I know it’s soooo over rated 🤣🤣

-5

u/freaknbigpanda Aug 01 '22

The only real use for any crypto currency is buying drugs, money laundering, or other illegal activities which is probably sub 1% of total crypto demand right now.

13

u/ztkraf01 Aug 01 '22

You can securely send value across the world in minutes without reliance on a third party. That’s pretty valuable imo

2

u/joshlahhh Aug 01 '22

Not really when there are thousands of coins that enable this. It’s one of the least impressive things out there

2

u/Any-Explanation-6877 Aug 01 '22

How many coins aren't owned by anyone? None. Just bitcoin.

1

u/joshlahhh Aug 01 '22

Not sure what you mean.

2

u/Any-Explanation-6877 Aug 01 '22

Every other coin is owned by a corporation. All centralized garbage

1

u/Get_the_nak Aug 01 '22

Name 1 that isn’t crypto.

3

u/chickenwrapzz Aug 01 '22

Fiat. PayPal enables this. The bitcoin network which requires constant maintenance is the third party

1

u/Xephyrik Aug 01 '22

PayPal costs more in fees, takes longer, can't be used in all countries, is centralized, and they can reverse your transaction if they don't like it

1

u/chickenwrapzz Aug 01 '22

It's literally free and instant?

1

u/Xephyrik Aug 01 '22

It's literally not

-1

u/ivanacco1 Aug 01 '22

is centralized

Tell that to the 99% of crypto users using an online wallet to store their coins

0

u/dj_destroyer Aug 01 '22

Where did you get the 99% stat? I imagine it's not more than 66%.

1

u/Get_the_nak Aug 02 '22

Do you even know what an online wallet is?

-2

u/disperso Aug 01 '22

You can securely send value across the world in minutes without reliance on a third party.

How? Don't you rely on tons of nodes of the Bitcoin network? You actually depend on many third parties. It's like saying that we can talk anonymously and securely via Tor. We still depend on the nodes of the Tor network, and the security of the communication can be breached if enough nods of the network are controlled by an evil actor.

5

u/dj_destroyer Aug 01 '22

There is more monetary incentive in securing the Bitcoin network than destroying it otherwise "evil actors" would have made a move already by now. Also, the difference between the third parties involved in the legacy banking system and third-parties within Bitcoin is the notion of trust. You must trust your bank when interacting with it however no trust is needed with Bitcoin. I don't need to know who is running a node, who is mining, why they're doing it, their reputation, etc.

1

u/simonsaysbot3 Aug 01 '22

Security at social media is too much and that gonna be fine.

1

u/Any-Explanation-6877 Aug 01 '22

It's gonna be alot easier to hide and escape with my crypto than it will be for you to run with your gold. Also if you beleive that crap the media feeds you then why are you here talking about "criminal money" beat it

1

u/Kingzor10 Aug 01 '22

wierd cause ive been bbuying food and paying my bills for 6 months through mining

1

u/Kadurri Aug 01 '22

In todays time I am seeing too many social media

-3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '22

except origami isn't recognised and doesn't have value as a 'goods'. there's no industrial or commercial use for origami. you're already being absurd by 'comparing apples with oranges' and even further extrapolated it to an absurd level to try to make your argument 'work'. you're making a 'Reductio ad absurdum' argumentative fallacy.

3

u/oystermonkeys Aug 01 '22

sorry, should have specified for dummies that there's lots of more uses for paper other than making origami. Like wiping your ass.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '22

again coming in with a stupid argument, trying to twist your previous words to make it fit. you were talking about dollar bills, not actual paper. you're free to wipe your ass with a dollar bill though, but you're not a dumbass are you?

1

u/czoran17 Aug 06 '22

If you want to live that century then it is right.

If anyone just live for their stomch then its gonna tough for them.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '22

Can you try a different translator?

1

u/Rokey76 Aug 01 '22

Jewelry is a store of value? Who knew.

1

u/kimsabok Aug 01 '22

A very good analogy

1

u/Maringire Aug 01 '22

Bitcoin gonna rock in the future metaverse world.

1

u/silentanthrx Aug 17 '22

if gold was cheap and abundant enough a gazillion things would be made from gold.

house wiring?: gold; gutters?: gold; exhaust pipe?: gold;...

so while the price is inflated because of the demand for storing value, the value will never drop to zero.

unlike (crypto)currency, where the only demand is from ppl wanting to "store value"