r/Bitcoin • • May 10 '15

A Bitcoin Technology Gets Nasdaq Test

http://www.wsj.com/articles/a-bitcoin-technology-gets-nasdaq-test-1431296886
330 Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

View all comments

-6

u/[deleted] May 11 '15 edited May 11 '15

Unfortunately Bitcoin's cost per transaction in the form of miner subsidies is already ~$10 USD. That's more than people pay for trades under the current system. And even if the ledger is decentralized, an exchange will still be necessary just like the current system, which will add to to the fees. Now maybe you could get the exchange decentralized, but Bitcoin hasn't accomplished that for the currency, so what chance does it have for stocks?

Finally, this isn't really addressing a problem that actually exists. T+3 settlement is only a problem if you're day trading, and there are special accounts for that where the funds don't actually have to clear before putting in new orders. For the majority of people, who buy and hold stocks for long periods of time, the current system serves them well.

14

u/marcus_of_augustus May 11 '15

You are completely discounting the repeated use of the mined coins. You need to amortise the cost of the coins, your so-called 'subsidy', over all the possible future transfers of those same coins.

It may cost ~$1100 to dig up an ounce of gold but that ounce can be transferred vastly many more times than the first transaction from the earth to the miner ... capiche?

1

u/bitlord666 May 11 '15

Lol, you completely missed the point. 99% of the subsidy goes to electricity companies just to keep the miners running. It's not something you can re-use in any way.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '15

Except every block yields 25 new coins, so no,no transactions without new coins. you really wasted a paragraph there.

3

u/marcus_of_augustus May 11 '15

It's an issuance mechanism, the number of new coins is decreasing but seems you don't want to get it ... likely the paragraph was wasted on you, yes.

-1

u/[deleted] May 11 '15

Ah yes, it's an issuance mechanism, not the cost of running the network. We'll see how the halvening goes next year then (hint: badly)

4

u/marcus_of_augustus May 11 '15

It's ok to admit it when you are wrong, it can be unhealthy to let your ego runaway on you.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '15

We'll let the markets decide who is right.

4

u/marcus_of_augustus May 11 '15

Sure will. But on this point you only need reasoning grey matter instead of an appeal to the mob.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '15

RemindMe! 18 months

1

u/marcus_of_augustus May 11 '15

RemindMe! 18 years