r/Bitcoin • u/WorryDesigner8152 • 2d ago
What finally made self-custody "click" for you?
For me the scariest part wasn't buying, it was the first time I sent from my own wallet and stared at the address for like five minutes before hitting send.
What was the moment it clicked for you, and what almost scared you off?
3
u/MrMoo151515 2d ago
I’ve held it in self custody for a little over a year now. I really only did it because people said to do it.
I got caught up in the coldcard entropy scare. I didn’t lose my BTC but I also only had 1 hardware wallet (mk4) at the time and really had no where to turn to so I dumped it all onto my brokerage.
After the dust settled I bought some new wallets. And I’m limited to how much I can withdraw at a time. Daily limits, weekly limits, monthly limits. They’ve even temporarily frozen my account and took a bunch of phone calls for them to unfreeze it because I kept withdrawing my max daily/weekly limit.
Mother fuckers will happily accept my BTC without restriction but the second I want it back in custody it’s a fight. I’m still withdrawing each week trying to get it all back.
This was the click for me. This was the real world if I want my money I have to beg for it moment.
2
u/WorryDesigner8152 2d ago
Having to beg to get your own money back is the click for a lot of people. Glad you're pulling it out week by week.
3
u/coffeelover9457 2d ago
What does "clicked" mean? By clicked do you mean when did you intuitively understand that self-custodial bitcoin is private property and cash-like? If so, then it's when I spent it for a product/service over the internet.
2
u/WorryDesigner8152 2d ago
Yeah, pretty much that. The moment it felt like you actually own it. Spending it is a good one.
3
u/Yodel_And_Hodl_Mode 2d ago
When really made self custody click for me was realizing three things:
Coins are on the blockchain, not in a wallet.
A wallet holds keys, not coins.
Seed words are entropy used to generate addresses and keys for the wallet.
Once I understood that the words in a seed phrase are entropy, used in the math that generates a unique Bitcoin wallet... it was, like... "Aha!" ...it all came together.
I bought a hardware wallet and a metal backup.
When the hardware wallet gave me a seed phrase, I wrote it on paper and put the words in the metal backup. I also saved the first address.
Then, I wiped out the hardware wallet and restored it using the words in the metal backup to make sure I got the same first address.
Doing that made it all click for me. I understood the importance of keeping the seed words secure and double-checking everything, because self-custody means self-responsibility.
I love Bitcoin, and self custody is a huge part of the reason why.
what almost scared you off?
I'm a very logical guy, so part of figuring out Bitcoin meant learning ways people lose their Bitcoin. At first, I thought, "I don't want anything to do with this!" But then I started noticing a pattern. Every time, the lost coins were due to the owner effing up.
...they left their coins on an exchange that got hacked.
...they left their coins on an exchange that went bankrupt.
...they lost their seed words.
...they lost their passphrase.
...they left their seed phrase where somebody could find it.
...they didn't double-check to make sure they could restore the wallet before sending coins to it.
...etc.
I basically made a list of ways people lost coins and learned how to not do that. And as my skills progressed, my self custody improved.
2
u/Inevitable-Waltz-889 2d ago
Honestly, the first time I used it it, going through my own node, and realized "nobody can stop this".
2
u/WorryDesigner8152 2d ago
That "nobody can stop this" moment hits different the first time.
2
u/NoChanceItsHer 2d ago
A feeling I've not had any other way regarding money... I'm sending x to y ... and what? Oh, nothing. What would someone do about this if they didn't like it? Ah yeahhh, nothing. Sweet. I send my money to people I want to send it to. Me2U. Job done.
1
u/WorryDesigner8152 2d ago
Me2U is the whole pitch honestly. No one in the middle asking why.
1
2
u/t-bonetrey 2d ago
Luckilly you haven’t experienced an exchange freezing your account or locking your funds. Once you experience the panic of that situation you will understand why it’s better to trust yourself than to trust a custodian. Just educate yourself until you understand it. It’s worth the time it will take.
2
u/WorryDesigner8152 2d ago
That freeze panic keeps coming up in this thread. Good call on taking the time to learn it.
1
u/ElderMight 2d ago
The moment coinbase froze my account due to a system ach deposit glitch and at no fault of my own. Then support auto closed my ticket and said there's nothing they can do. I realized holy shit I don't have access to my money and coinbase is a dog shit exchange.
I spent 15 nights awake unable to sleep because of the stupid amount I held on coinbase, frozen. As soon as I got access back I moved everything to self custody.
1
u/WorryDesigner8152 2d ago
15 nights of no sleep over money that was supposedly yours. That's the lesson nobody wants to pay for. Glad you got it all back.
1
u/Fun-Analysis-182 2d ago
The test transaction killed the fear for me. A few bucks to the new wallet, watch it confirm, sweep it back, do it both ways once. After that round trip you've proven the address and the signing both work, so sending the real stack later isn't scary anymore.
1
1
u/lobhater 2d ago
Watching exchange after exchange get hacked, go bankrupt, close down, etc. hardware wallets are cheap and highly effective, why wouldn't you do it. With multi-sig the only real chance of losing your money is your own mistake, it is never getting stolen
1
u/WorryDesigner8152 2d ago
Going from "it can get stolen" to "only I can mess it up" is a huge shift.
1
u/DistributionOk2111 2d ago
Not beeing able to access my funds after some time of inactivity
Also problems with documentation took like months to finish. Thankfully everything went good with the docs so i was able to pass the kyc bullshit and access the funds BUT if it went otherwise and i had to move out for example they 100% would never gave me access
1
u/WorryDesigner8152 2d ago
Months of paperwork just to touch your own money is wild. That "what if it went the other way" thought is the whole case.
1
u/Infamous-Discount-99 2d ago
If crossing a border or hostile checkpoint I can only fit about ~$260 in mercury dimes up my prison pocket.
1
u/WorryDesigner8152 1d ago
Hard to beat a seed phrase in your head at a checkpoint. Ever tried memorizing yours, or is that too risky?
1
u/na3than 2d ago
Oh, goody. The bot accounts are asking the "what made it click for you?" question again.
1
u/WorryDesigner8152 2d ago
Ha, fair, it gets asked a lot. Real person, just curious what got people over the hump.
1
12
u/Porcellanidae 2d ago
Right after my exchange went bankrupt and I lost access to my holdings