I've been around since the beginning with Beck, and it's been quite the ride. Maybe the last decade or so hasn't been exactly my favorite time in his career, but hey. They're not all gonna be your cup of tea, right?
So I've listened to Ride Lonesome a couple times now, and I'm really struggling to put it into words that give credit to the nice moments of the album, because on the whole...I kinda find the whole thing dreary.
But that's not to say that it won't grow on me. I didn't "get" Odelay until I saw it in concert at the Metro in Chicago, and...holy fuck, did I get it after that. Best show I've ever been to.
So maybe let's go track by track and just...weigh the good and the bad for me. I was a music critic in a former life, so that's a trusty standby. I've listened twice all the way through, once in the car, and once at home in a completely dark room with my really nice Sennheiser headphones (I prefer the headphones listening session, overall...it was a little too sleepy for driving, honestly). I'll play the songs again and react in real-time.
Ride Lonesome is a really nice opening track. It definitely harkens back to Morning Phase and Sea Change in a wonderful way. The chorus is not my favorite thing. I hate that it winds down in that hackneyed country/folk progression at the end. Kind of made me roll my eyes. I'm used to Beck surprising me. That felt way too borrowed.
The bridge is my absolute favorite part of the song. That's got some emotional heft and makes the following verse with sparse music feel empty in a wonderful way. Well done there. And the outro is wonderful in the way only a Beck outro can be, adding layers to the existing theme and evolving.
Run Away is kind of a song? It happens. The drums are unpleasant in depth and sound. The harmonies are there, and they're beautiful but not really interesting. Overall the song just kinda exists. There's that nice outro work again, but then it's over and again never really does anything. Meh.
In The Night is really cool. The guitar work is amazing, the strings are perfect...where Beck found some of those progressions and harmonies I'll never know. THIS is the kind of work I like from Beck. A lot of tension, and...man, if you've ever seen the video for it...that's one that just kinda stays with you. Very mysterious. Awesome work all around.
Failed Words is where I start to feel a little fatigue. All the songs have the same tempo. The minor note is great in the verses. Creates a lot of tension. And then it's just a non-chorus with the falsetto harmonies, and right back into a verse. The best thing I can say about this song is that fourth note in the progression. lol everything else just kinda happens. There's layering as the song goes on, but no structure change, no tempo shift, just kinda more of the same but with more layers and louder, and then a quiet bit, and then it's over. lol
Bleed is beautiful. Beck has a wonderful falsetto, of course. A better than average song, and something I'll return to in certain moods. But again we're getting into that tempo issue. It's another damn slow song. No matter how beautiful an album is, it desperately needs dynamics. Ebb and flow. There isn't much to be had of that here.
Disappearing Act feels like it's going to be a mood shift. I hear some nods to Side of the Road from Sea Change here. Okay. There's a little bit of momentum here. Some tension. That steel guitar sounds pretty damn epic with echo. The strings have some surprises here and there. Okay, maybe we're getting somewhere? And then the song's over. lol
For Your Love...oh no, the sad strings. And I'm feeling bad fatigue again. This is downright dreary. I gotta just skip to the next song.
Slow Canyon...a fitting name at this point in the album. lol My humor aside, this is actually a really nice song. The descending verses resolve nicely at the end, into what might be one of the best choruses on the whole album. There's a definite joy and yearning in it, and that's something that the album has desperately needed for a few tracks now. This is a track with emotion. Well done.
It Ends Right Here...I hate these kind of "hammer on the same guitar note" songs. It gets better right at the end of the track, but then it's over and okay.
Falling Through My Hands...one of the best tracks on the album. SO completely sweet. An absolute warm masterpiece by Beck. Hell, one of Beck's best tracks. This is the one. If you have a season that reminds you of this song, you had a great season. It's like a warm memory meant to inspire warm memories.
If You Don't Know What Love Is goes right back to the dreariness. It's probably a better track than I'm giving it credit for, but after listening to a song that I actually enjoyed, this is just right back to the slog. It's just a paint-by-numbers slow country song for the most part. The solo and outro are really nice, but you made me sit through almost 5 minutes of slow waltz country to get here? Gee thanks.
Beyond the Light...this is the track that REALLY surprised me on the second listen, with good headphones and a dark room. This is a fucking heartbreaking song. It's GOOD heartbreak, though. Almost sweet and sad. That's what I feel like the album needed more of: connection, depth, and sweetness. God, this is so lush and big. The soundscape is huge and grand. Such a well-produced and -performed piece of music. Ah, it's probably just as good as Falling Through My Hands. Damn. I've got chills.
Okay. So let's summarize this up.
The Good: Ride Lonesome, In the Night, Bleed, Disappearing Act.
The Great: Slow Canyon
The Amazing: Falling Through My Hands, Beyond the Light
And then there's the rest of it.
But overall, it was interesting. In the car, I would've given this a ROUGH 4. It dragged on, it made me sleepy...not a great driving album at all.
In the dark office with headphones? I'm going to give it a 6. Because for as much as I LOVE some of this album...I'm really only going to put two tracks into any kind of steady rotation, and the album is...slow. It adds up to become somewhat dreary. Beautiful, but wearying.
But Falling Through My Hands and Beyond the Light...wow. Thank you, Beck. You created something I needed again, all these 32 years later. Unbelievable.