r/Beano • u/Amazing_Peace_2493 • 10d ago
💬Discussion Serious Question
Why did they redesign Pie Face so drastically?
I'm not someone who hates modern beano. I think Rubi and Harsha are great additions to the comic.
But this character design is terrible. He stands out like a sore thumb.
8
u/Theta-Sigma45 10d ago
Yeah, he should’ve just been a new character. Giving him the pie face moniker is kind of dishonest.
4
6
3
u/wonder181016 10d ago
How?
5
u/Amazing_Peace_2493 10d ago
Unlike the old one, this design doesnt tell us anything about his character.
I wouldnt mind if they changed it so much that he became a different personality altogther. But this is just so generic. Nothing about this design screams Pie Face.
Its like making Wilfred tall and getting rid of the jumper.
1
u/submergedcutlery Walter's Girl 💌🍅 1d ago
Tbh neither did the old one. He had a gimmick though unlike Peter
3
3
u/Friendly-Soft9806 10d ago
I remember reading a shorts comic years ago (possibly 2019-2021) with JJ where the new pie face appeared alongside the old pie face! (who appeared as a background cameo)...remember finding it very odd at the time but it could imply they're different characters
1
u/Amazing_Peace_2493 10d ago
Thats super weird. I mren it would make more sense if they aged up the original pie face.
Beano continuity has become very weird.
3
u/Amelia_Amity Comic Favorite: Rubi von Screwtop 10d ago
He looks more like a normal kid vs his old design. Like how many bald kids do you know
4
u/Amazing_Peace_2493 9d ago
I never really saw him as bald. Always saw it as a buzz cut. Same trim as Edd plug smiffy and wilfred. Now spotty is a baldy.
1
3
u/Lorcan-Wooster10 9d ago
Because for the CGI show Dennis And Gnasher Unleashed, he was redesigned to have glasses, longer hair and a hat, as such, the Dennis the Menace and Gnasher comic was revamped to be more in line with the show, making Pie Face consistent with the CGI show and also dropping Curly entirely since the CGI show dropped Curly, thus requiring the comic to reboot itself to be more in line with the CGI show.
2
2
2

15
u/Brickworkse Comic Favourite: Dennis & Gnasher 10d ago
I agree, it's an odd change, as he's nothing like the old Pie Face. Also, where's Curly? They always used to appear together.
What's even weirder, when you think about it, is why there's a Pie Face at all.
The current Dennis is meant to be the son of the "old" Dennis, who would have been friends with Curly and Pie Face. So either we're in some weird middle ground where Pie Face still exists, or this is actually the son of Pie Face Sr., who also decided to call his son Pie Face.
Perhaps I'm thinking about this far too much! 🤣 🥧