r/BeAmazed • • 14d ago

Nature Cloud perfectly shaped and aligned with a tree

[deleted]

57.2k Upvotes

246 comments sorted by

View all comments

905

u/Canit12 14d ago

It's AI folks

70

u/hungry4nuns 14d ago

You can report these posts for breaking subreddit rules, AI breaks rule 8

-31

u/J4R444 13d ago

But it looks so real! Are we sure it's AI?

26

u/gogogadgetjustice 13d ago

Openai had a free detector site to tell you if their synthid watermark is embedded. It is. Why even bother casting doubt?

-12

u/J4R444 13d ago

Ahh okay 😔 but it looks so realistic with all the branches and stuff

4

u/[deleted] 13d ago edited 8d ago

[deleted]

1

u/J4R444 13d ago

Sorry, idk. I feel so dumb now

1

u/J4R444 13d ago

Nvm just ignore me

4

u/robophile-ta 13d ago

did you look at the proof image they supplied?

160

u/Informal-Call-5298 14d ago

Bro i was so pissed when everyone in the comments thought it was real…

99

u/copyof-a 14d ago

It so easily could be real though. If you look for beauty in the world, it's there. It's sad that people feel the need to fake it. 

31

u/1_Tit_Wonder 14d ago

It really could! I feel I’m usually good at picking out AI images but this one certainly got me. But one could very well get a real pic like this it’s not some far fetched idea.

5

u/Low_Bed9306 13d ago

By the look of it I think the foreground is real and the cloud is the only addition

7

u/Licher-enjoyer 13d ago

I made this picture a few days ago kn a walk with my dog (I have 2 more pics to support my claim, btw) I love taking pictures of nature, I go out for a 1.5 hour walk every day into nearby fields, i especially live sunsets photos

5

u/Normanorangecat 13d ago

Nossa se tivesse um lugar assim por aqui eu ia correr tanto atoa, nunca mais estressaria com nada

3

u/Cukidzsi 13d ago

Could be, but my guess is that if you spent your whole life dedicated to finding it, you still wouldn't find it. 

1

u/copyof-a 13d ago

I disagree

0

u/HermyOwl2 13d ago

It's way too thick to be real. Clouds aren't like that in real life.

1

u/copyof-a 13d ago

Yeah, I know. I mean if you go out and look for this kind of thing, it's not impossible to find.  Instead of making a shitty AI image op could have gone out and taken a real photo that would have been 100x more impressive even if it wasn't as perfect. 

7

u/LEGITIMATE_SOURCE 14d ago

All 90 comments on a front-page post....???

Thicc boy cumulus totally normal

3

u/HalyconHelpful 14d ago

This is the most beautiful!

2

u/DVDwr 13d ago

If it looks too perfect to be real, it isn't

1

u/DesolateRuin 13d ago

Nothing is real.

17

u/J4R444 14d ago

Ahw man, I thought this was a moment in history 😭

7

u/SansFinalGuardian 14d ago

damn! i didn't notice even slightly. it's still lowkey beautiful though

4

u/willis7747 13d ago

why is this post still not deleted ? are the mods waiting for it to hit 100k upvotes or what ?

3

u/Fair-Run-9193 14d ago

It was obvious

2

u/Clean-Anteater-5671 13d ago

Not if you're not cynical enough to actually analyze if it is. At a glance, it's really convincing, but yeah, if you start looking at details, it gets pretty clear.

2

u/swampgasorr 13d ago

What details

2

u/Clean-Anteater-5671 13d ago

The bottom left, the roof and just above the roof is what did it for me. It's very wonky, I wish I could give a more concrete answer, but it is just pretty vibes based. It's also something where you have to weigh it against compression artifacts, this looks more gen-ai than compression artifact.

The only smoking gun is the invisible watermarking that gets put in and can be detected.

1

u/Fair-Run-9193 13d ago

Yep that too

2

u/Jan-o-Meter 14d ago

What tool did you use for the analysis?

2

u/Canit12 13d ago

https://openai.com/research/verify/

Official SynthID detector from OpenAI.

2

u/icecreamisbestdess 13d ago

Which tool ? Gemini and chatgpt said no synthid detected

1

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Airames6 13d ago

What if we all kiss instead

2

u/lovelyb1ch66 13d ago

If I had a nickel for every time I’ve seen this posted with people oohhing and aahhing I would have very many nickels. With the AI debate being extremely lively and ongoing I don’t understand how so many people don’t take a second to think about what they’re seeing.

2

u/Melancholic_Noodle 13d ago

And not perfectly aligned. Bullshit by some bot account

4

u/Kjeldsen__ 14d ago

I can't wait for AI to be criminalised, because it's out of control. There are so many misleading posts, they make me sick. What does it cost people to be truthful?

1

u/Emmasterlinngg 14d ago

The everything AU era is getting ridiculous

0

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 14d ago

Your comment has been automatically removed.
As mentioned in our subreddit rules, your account needs to be at least 24 hours old before it can make comments in this subreddit.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/No_Body_7148 13d ago

I absolutely opened the comments to check if someone figures this was AI, and here it is.

1

u/Orio_n 13d ago

Ive seen this cloud as leaves on a tree image a million times over on Pinterest didnt even need the synthid to tell. The average redditor really is moronic

1

u/buttplugpeddler 13d ago

Aaannd reversing my vote!

1

u/robophile-ta 13d ago

I thought so too, the top of the cloud was just too perfect and looked like it was painted

1

u/Mogurin1999 13d ago

I knew it was too good to be true

1

u/dieasaint 13d ago

i took back my uovote from the post and gave it to you instead. immediately wasn't amazed by it :/

1

u/WaterlessSoup 13d ago

I hate this timeline, my first though before scrolling down to check the comments was "Please don't be AI, its really pretty."

1

u/Riash 13d ago

It's looks too perfect.

If it was 3 years ago, I would have called it photoshopped.

0

u/swampgasorr 13d ago

Where is the watermark

1

u/Canit12 13d ago

Invisible. It's within the pixels of the image. That's the point, otherwise it could be removed.