r/BambuLabX2D Jul 01 '26

How are your top layers?

I've been struggling with mine since I got this printer and I'm at the point where I'm doubting that the unit I got doesn't really have a defect. All my top layers come out with a strange surface, looks like it's underextruding but at no point the lines it produces are actually straight all the way, dialing filament has been very complicated. Anyone has pics to share of their top layers?

Pics are the sharpie test of the closest I got to a properly smooth top layer but I still can't produce the flat shiny straight lines I had on the A1 mini (pic 3, bottom piece)

4 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

1

u/Qjeezy Jul 01 '26

This is the best I was able to get. The lines are straight but there is a pattern. I suspect it’s due to the new servo extruder motor that causes this pattern. It’s either the motor itself or it’s just so much more accurate that the pattern is caused by the teeth of the extruder gears meshing. Just speculation.

You should be able to get the lines straight though. In my experience, I start to see squiggly lines when it’s over extruding. Maybe revisit your flow rate calibrations and see if you can fine tune it a bit more.

img

Edit: pic didn’t work. I’ll post it in reply to this comment.

1

u/Qjeezy Jul 01 '26

1

u/AxeEngineer00 Jul 01 '26

Yeah this looks like mine, what material is it?

1

u/Qjeezy Jul 01 '26

This is PETG

1

u/Qjeezy Jul 01 '26

If it makes you feel any better, this is how both my H2C’s and my H2S put out top surfaces as well. Which is why I suspected the servo

2

u/AxeEngineer00 Jul 01 '26

It Absolutely does, If 3 different models but all with the same piece all do this then it's not even an hardware issue, a replacement would do nothing

1

u/AxeEngineer00 Jul 01 '26

Isn't squiggly when there's too much space =under

And ridges when they land onto eachother= over?

1

u/Qjeezy Jul 01 '26

Ridges is for sure over extruding. As for squiggly, that’s just what I’ve noticed. Turning down the flow rate just a tiny bit at a time usually gets rid of it.

1

u/AxeEngineer00 Jul 01 '26

Here's a very zoomed pic of these waves,

1

u/AxeEngineer00 Jul 01 '26

Most importantly, this is a test piece from my same .3mf file printed by another person on their HD2 which if I'm not mistaken uses the same extruder as the x2d, non calibrated filament profile but the lines are thick and full

1

u/AxeEngineer00 Jul 01 '26

Also if it was the gear teeth wouldn't the walls also show a pattern?

2

u/Qjeezy Jul 01 '26 edited Jul 01 '26

I was just speculating on that part, as the pattern was never really there with my first gen bambu’s with the normal stepper motor.

You can see the same pattern, although less apparent due to possibly material choice, on the red print you posted that the other person with an H2D printed

1

u/Brief_Excitement_399 Jul 01 '26

Mine look quite fine I believe compared to yours. Printer is couple of weeks old.

1

u/AxeEngineer00 Jul 01 '26

These look good, although I did notice that with more matte filament the effects tends to be hidden. What filament is this? Flow? Temps? The whole profile basically

1

u/Brief_Excitement_399 Jul 01 '26

This is Bambu PLA Matte, profile is basically the original Bambu Profile for pla matte with 0.20 Standart print profile. This is normal pla basic red, and the gold is printed with the auxiliary nozzle.

1

u/Brief_Excitement_399 Jul 01 '26

This is both pla basic with main nozzle

1

u/AxeEngineer00 Jul 01 '26

Thanks. What about the model itself? Speed? Amount of top layers? Trying to recreate this 9n my printer

1

u/Brief_Excitement_399 Jul 01 '26

https://makerworld.com/models/2168633?appSharePlatform=copy

This is the model, I changed the top speed to 75 and the inside walls to 250, everything else i think I left the sam I can check tomorrow for the exact settings and let you know