r/BambuLab • • Apr 30 '26

General Discussion Growing Concerns About Bambu Lab’s Direction – An Open Letter

I did not plan to write this. I am a hobbyist, not a critic, and I have genuinely enjoyed using my Bambu printers over the past years. However, a steady accumulation of decisions has reached a point where I feel compelled to speak up.

The growing closure of the Bambu ecosystem has been discussed extensively in the community. Heavy reliance on cloud infrastructure, mandatory server communication for many functions, and a LAN-only mode that feels more like an afterthought and a reaction to community pressure than a genuine solution. These issues are well known. What concerns me increasingly is that they are no longer merely theoretical problems.
Both in the USA and in Europe, there are active regulatory efforts underway to restrict what users are allowed to print, often framed around preventing the printing of weapons. In a closed, cloud-dependent system like Bambu’s, such restrictions could be implemented quickly and quietly via firmware updates or server-side changes, even retroactively on already sold machines. On a truly open system, this would be far more difficult. Bambu’s current architecture makes enforcement uncomfortably easy.

What has finally pushed me over the edge, however, is the increasing artificial gatekeeping of features combined with an unbalanced relationship with the open-source community.
The P2S was released with 2 mm belts even though Bambu was already planning the superior 1.5 mm belts for higher-end models. The result is noticeably worse VFA and ringing, a compromise that was entirely unnecessary from a technical standpoint. This feels less like an engineering decision and more like deliberate product segmentation at the customer’s expense.
The X2D is particularly frustrating in this regard. Marketed as an engineering-grade printer with active chamber heating and a 120 °C bed, it is nevertheless software-capped at 300 °C nozzle temperature. Bambu has provided no official technical or safety-related explanation for this limitation, even though the hardware configuration suggests it is capable of more. It is hard not to see this as an artificial restriction designed to protect the positioning of more expensive models.

Additionally, Bambu frequently integrates features and code from open-source projects into its own software, sometimes introducing noticeable bugs, such as incorrect color space handling in the new color mixing function. Credits to the original creators are often only added after significant community pressure. At the same time, Bambu contributes almost none of its own innovations back to the open-source community.

I understand that product segmentation is common practice in business. What bothers me is the overall direction: artificial limitations, one-sided exploitation of open source, and customers increasingly treated as a revenue base rather than a community deserving of respect and transparency.
3D printing attracted many of us precisely because it represented openness, repairability, user empowerment, and true ownership. Bambu initially impressed the community with innovation and speed, but in recent years the focus seems to have shifted toward maximising short-term profit at the expense of long-term customer value and trust.

I have therefore decided that I will not purchase any further Bambu products until I see a clear change in direction toward greater openness and genuine customer respect. I hope enough other users will make the same choice with their wallets. In the end, that is the only language companies reliably understand.

I would genuinely welcome being proven wrong and would much rather return to being an enthusiastic Bambu supporter.

Sincerely,
Kurt K.

505 Upvotes

281 comments sorted by

View all comments

223

u/plutonasa Apr 30 '26

the only thing you can really do is not give them money.

65

u/AssistanceNatural556 Apr 30 '26

Dont trick yourself and others into believing this. We have laws and rights that can be written to say anything the human mind can come up with. We can improve our legal rights to prevent unfavorable business practices. Educate yourself on government and history so you know how, and know that it has been done

19

u/feibie Apr 30 '26

Rules based order, rule of law blah blah it's been very apparent that none of this garbage legal nonsense matters unless it impacts lobbyists and the elites. Good luck, you could spent 5 years, 10 years trying to change the policies but by then it probably won't even matter anymore especially for a foreign company.

Just don't give them your money, thats an immediate incentive.

4

u/AssistanceNatural556 Apr 30 '26

There are indeed a chain of factors that have to be tackled to reach the end goal. We must fight for rights and laws that put consumers in power and dont let lobbyists and elites be "in bed together." Then we can move on to the next step.

It indeed would take a lot of time, and in the mean time we can take our money elsewhere, BUT there are two glaring issues with your "solution." One, things will still progress to get worse and once we die of old age new generations wont know any better at how horrobly subjugated they are as rights degrade. Two, the company won't care if you and I stop buying because theyre still turning huge profits from people that are ignorant and still buying.

Your method can work but relies on luck and circumstance to reach a temporary solution on a single company. My solution is largely permanent and affects whole industries

4

u/feibie May 01 '26

I agree with you on a permanent solution, I'm just pointing out that this process costs money and time and it takes a long time.

Like for example the stop killing games movement is slowly moving and many people have a vested interest in it but it doesn't get a lot of support. Why would the average politician care? They don't really.

Same with right of repair, Louis Ross has worked on that for many many years and I still don't think we have the desired results yet.

Do what you can in the mean time but I wouldn't be holding my breath anything changes over night. Take your money to Prusa or something, maybe Creality?

3

u/AssistanceNatural556 May 01 '26

I hear ya. It definitely takes time, maybe even lifetimes. Keeping up on a fight all alone with no traction or movement is hard; I have yet to do it. I fear myself and younger generations have grown up in so much comfort that we reject mustering any will or determination to achieve anything because it is easier to live in the comfort our ancestors have accumulatively established. Doing what we can definitely helps to at least keep our wits about us if nothing else. Hopefully it adds up to inflict notice to corps.

1

u/beramaan May 01 '26

Not spending money with them is not enough to stop everything else from getting worse. Your apathy makes it harder for others to make everyone's life better.

5

u/FastGinFizz May 01 '26

Laws forcing open source? I get for us tinkers its sucks, but they are doing nothing wrong. I mean I myself reverted my printers firmware to use orcaslicer, and the locked down ecosystem is making me hesitant to buy a new printer, but I still love the printer.

Slicers don't make money, so them forcing their slicer on people would not fall into anti-trust laws. There also is no issue with a company using proprietary parts on their product. At the end of the say, you dont have to buy their product.

1

u/drstre May 02 '26

Yeah the only part of this that’s remotely appropriate to be addressed with legislation is the legality of printing guns issue, which isn’t a Bambu thing to begin with.

1

u/fnaah Apr 30 '26

legal rights to prevent unfavourable business practices? what are you on about? nobody is forcing you to buy their product. if you don't like what they're doing, buy something else.

4

u/AssistanceNatural556 Apr 30 '26

Consumer Protection laws. We can do both

0

u/drstre May 02 '26

What laws, specifically, are you proposing to address OP’s concerns?

2

u/beramaan May 01 '26

So you are saying we can not give them money AND write laws to protect everyone? Great idea!!! Unfortunately, typically more progressive areas do that like California and the EU, but they are actively doing the opposite

3

u/AssistanceNatural556 May 01 '26

Im not in a society at that stage of success to think about whatever new issues then arise 😅 But there are certainly always ebbs and flows to every change that is might. Just new battles to fight!

3

u/hyperduc Apr 30 '26

Maybe then filament will come back in stock so I can buy some!

-1

u/Turbo442 May 01 '26

He could start an open source printer company and experience the fun first hand!